Response to Lit. Essay: Esperanza Rising
Body Paragraph- Reason1- Circle
To begin, Papa's spirit travels with Esperanza when she gives Papa's doll to Isabel. This first appears when Esperanza gets told Isabel hasn't been awarded the Queen of May at her school. To cheer her up, Esperanza tries to talk her out of being angry, sad, and disappointed, which didn't work to well. Finally, Esperanza reaches under bed and takes out valise where she keeps her most prized possession. Esperanza handed the doll, the one Papa have her as a birthday in Mexico, to Isabel and instantly a smile spread across her face. Esperanza tells her to take good of it, and also said Papa would've appreciated it, too. At that time the book quoted, "She lifted the doll
…show more content…
from the valise and handed it to Isabel. 'To keep as your own.'" ( pg. 227) Esperanza, who rarely took her doll out of the valise, now decided to give it to Isabel as a token. The doll was almost one of the last parts of Papa, but now she has already given it away. Esperanza's doll had not only been present at this time; it showed up in the beginning when she is getting the doll, when she saves it in the house-fire not too far away, and lastly in the train ride to L.A. with the little "dirty-peasant-girl". These various events with the doll showing up all relate to Papa traveling with Esperanza, but in the form of a very special doll. It is clear that Esperanza feels Papa is with her when she gives her doll to Isabel, so Papa's influence is still with her, though the doll isn't with her. Response to Lit. Essay: Esperanza Rising Body Paragraph- Reason 2- Square Secondly, Papa's influence comes to Esperanza when she tries to hear the Earth's heartbeat in L.A.
This instance first occurs when Esperanza, Mama, and the servants have now reached California, met Juan, Josefina and Isabel, and have set up a camp to rest before moving on. Then, Esperanza wanders off into the valley seeking a scenic place above on the valleys. When she finds a spot on the valleys, she tries to hear the Earth's heartbeat, but ends up with no success. Trying, intensively, several times she gives up and starts to cry wondering why she couldn't hear it. The book quoted here when Esperanza was trying to hear the heartbeat,"...If she lay on the land, and was very still and quiet, she could hear the heartbeat of the valley. 'Can I hear it from here, Papa?'" (pg. 91) Esperanza had only heard the heartbeat once before in Mexico with Papa. Now she's trying again; but ending with no success. The Earth's heartbeat had a big connection with Esperanza to Papa, and though she'd heard it before with him, now she feels like it's a connection not only with Papa, but with Mexico and valley its self. Through the whole story the heartbeat had showed up three times before; once with Papa in vineyard in Mexico, the second time was now when she's trying to hear it all by herself, and lastly when she finally hears it with Miguel on the tops of the valley. Though she hasn't actually heard the Earth's heartbeat, Esperanza at least tries to hear it, which shows she is trying to reach …show more content…
Papa through the heartbeat and experiencing Papa with her through the heartbeat. Response to Lit. Essay: Esperanza Rising Body Paragraph- Reason 2- Square Lastly, the spiritual essence of Papa living among Esperanza is illustrated when Miguel brings Papa's roses from Mexico to L.A for Esperanza.
The bringing of the roses when everybody had come back from a long day at work and were eager for eating dinner, when Miguel brought them all outside . They all gathered around a make-shift shrine with a few rocks and a few roses, not just any roses, Papa's roses. From them everyone had questions, but Esperanza was first; she asked if those roses were Papa's roses, and if they were, where did they come from. Miguel answered by saying, quoted from the book, "'Yes, these are your Papa's roses', said Miguel, smiling at her" (pg. 123) Till that night, before Esperanza was shown the shrine and roses, she'd thought they had burnt away in the house-fire in Mexico. These roses, which were planted by Papa, was for the relationship between Miguel and Esperanza, for their un-breakable friendship. But to Esperanza these roses didn't mean just the friendship between them, but the family-bond between them, though Miguel was a worker in El Ranch De Las Rosas, the ranch Esperanza used to live in. So, finding out that a few roses were saved from the fire meant a lot to her and Miguel; it meant Papa was almost "growing" or "rising" again, but in the form of a plant, close to them. The presence of the roses played three significant parts in the book; first when they were planted by Papa for Esperanza and Miguel, secondly when Miguel quoted, "' In Mexico
we stand on different sides of the river'" (pg. 37) toward Esperanza's misleading actions, and lastly, right at this part, when Miguel brings the roses to L.A. from Mexico. Through this piece of final evidence, of when Miguel brings Papa's roses, shows Papa traveling with Esperanza, and finally staying with her through the roses.
Sally is the prettiest girl at Esperanza's school, and one of Esperanza's friends. She has pretty black suede shoes that Esperanza envies. What Esperanza really envies is Sally sexual maturity, which is why she wants the suede shoes. Her next story with Sally, “The Monkey Garden” continues to emphasize this symbol. Sally and Esperanza are at the neighborhood garden when Sally starts talking to some boys. They take her keys and tells Sally she has to kiss them to get them back. Sally agrees and Esperanza runs to an adult, who doesn't seem to care. Esperanza then grabs some large sticks and a brick to fight. “But when I got there Sally said go home. Those boys said leave us alone. I felt stupid with my brick. They all looked at me as if I was the one that was crazy”(pg 97). Esperanza doesn't understand what is going on, and runs to the other side of the garden. She cries herself to sleep under a tree. When she wakes up she ends the chapter saying “I looked at my feet in their white socks and ugly round shoes. They seemed far away. They didn't seem to be my feet anymore. And the garden that had been such a good place to play didn't seem mine either”(pg 98). Esperanza doesn't recognize her feet because those are the feet of a child, the child she used to be. This event is when Esperanza realizes that she can't play in the garden anymore, or be a child. She needs to grow up, mentally and
In the book, Esperanza doesn’t want to follow the norms of the life around her; she wants to be independent. Esperanza states her independence by stating, “Not a man’s house. Not a daddy’s. A house all my own,” (Cisneros 108.) The syntax of these sentences stick out and are not complete thoughts, yet they convey much meaning and establish Esperanza’s feeling of not belonging. Esperanza’s feeling of not belonging is also emphasized when her sisters tell her that the events of her life have made her who she is and that is something she can not get rid of. Her sisters explain that the things she has experienced made her who she is by saying, “You will always be esperanza. You will always be mango street. You can’t erase what you know” (105.) What her sisters are trying to tell her is that the past has changed her but it doesn’t have to be a negative thing; it can be used to make her a better person who is stronger and more independent. Esperanza realizes that the things around her don’t really add up to what she believes is right, which also conveys the sense of not
I have chosen to do my final project on the fiction novel, Esperanza Rising written by Pam Muñoz Ryan. The novel, Esperanza Rising was published in the year 2000 by Scholastic Inc., in New York, New York.
Esperanza, the most liberated of the sisters, devoted her life to make other people’s lives better. She became a reporter and later on died while covering the Gulf Crisis. She returned home, to her family as a spirit. At first, she spoke through La Llorona, a messenger who informed La Loca that her sister has died. All her family members saw her. She appeared to her mother as a little girl who had a nightmare and went near to her mother for comfort. Caridad had conversations with her about politics and La Loca talked to her by the river behind their home.
...ioned “roses after roses”, which would be a metaphor for the dead amidst the beautiful roses, which is quite similar to the incident about the gun and the rose, and how all the hurtful things are beneath the beautiful things.
Esperanza is constantly influenced by the women in her own family including her mother, sister and other various family members. Even early in the novel Esperanza recognizes that the boys hold more powers than the girl. She states “The boys and the girls live in different worlds” and how once outside of the house her brothers will not talk to the girls (10). Her brothers recognize that if the other boys in the neighborhood see them with their sisters, they will be mocked. This signals that Esperanza has internalized that the men hold more power even from an early age and her male siblings hold mor...
Esperanza's syntax reveals that innocence is irrevocable. Reminiscing of the Monkey Garden Esperanza "suppose[s], the reason why [they] went there" was because it was "Far away from where [their] mothers could find [them]"Cisneros (95). In the garden the kids were able to play without any adults around. The garden became a place of rejuvenation for Esperanza, where only kids were allowed and the horrors of the adult world remain unnoticed. Esperanza observes, "Things had a way of disappearing in the garden, as if the garden itself ate them, or, as if with its old-man memory, it put them away and forgot them."(95). This shows that the garden was a place where things easily went unnoticed and it was not uncommon to loose things. For Esperanza, this represents the place where she is forced into her loss of childhood, and comparing this to a forgetful old man makes sense since when people mature they loose their innocence and childlike attributes. When the boys stole Sally's keys "they were all laughing" and "[Sally] was too" however, "It was a joke [Esperanza] didn't get"(96). The boys take advantage of Sally by stealing her keys so Sally seizes the opportunity to be able to flirt back with them.
Next, consider the text trying to express her frustration with life: “She wants to live for once. But doesn’t quite know what that means. Wonders if she has ever done it. If she ever will.” (1130) You can sense her need and wanting to be independent of everything and everyone, to be truly a woman on her own free of any shackles of burden that this life has thrown upon her. Also, there is an impression that her family does not really care that she is leaving from her sisters to her disinterested father. “Roselily”, the name is quite perplexing considering a rose stands for passion, love, life; while the lily has associations with death, and purity. Still at the same time the name aptly applies to her because the reader knows she is ultimately doomed to wilt away in a loveless marriage in Chicago. Even though she is convincing herself that she loves things about him it is all just a ploy to trick herself into believing that this marriage could be the answer to all her problems. Now on to the men of Roselily’s past most of which are dead- beat dads that could not care about what happens to their children, or where they go.
... They didn’t seem to be my feet anymore. And the garden that had been such a good place to play didn’t seem mine either” (Cisneros 98). The play place that was once so innocent and is now a junkyard that reciprocates Esperanza’s innocence that slowly turns into reality. She is growing up. Additionally, she gains enough confidence and maturity to make her own life decisions. This is shown when she makes the important decision of where she wants her life to take her. “I have decided not to grow up tame like the others who lay their necks on the threshold waiting for the ball and chain” (Cisneros 88). This shows Esperanza’s maturity to make her own life choices by herself. She is finally confident and independent enough to know where she wants her life to take her. Esperanza finally completes her evolution from young and immature to adult-like and confident.
Esperanza is a very strong woman in herself. Her goals are not to forget her "reason for being" and "to grow despite the concrete" so as to achieve a freedom that's not separate from togetherness.
Isabel was born on August 2nd in the city of Peru which is located in Peru. Her mother was named Francisca Liona Barros or as close family members knew her Dona Panchita. Her fathers name was Tomas Allende. He was a Chilean diplomat. Her father’s cousin was the President for the country of Chile. With her mother she had a very close relationship and her mother helped her with many situations. In the other Isabel did not have a very close relationship with her father. Her father was a very sexist person and did not treat her with much respect like he did to her brother. After years and years of fighting of fighting and being abused her mom decided to divorce Isabel’s father. After the divorce Isabel’s mom decided to move to Chile taking Isabel and her two other siblings with her. Her family starts to live in Santiago, Chile with her grandpa. It was tough for her to accustom to a new life. She was very young and she had to make new friends, go to a new school and she did not know the city at all in where her Mom grew up. A little bit after their arrival Isabel’s Mom married a diplomat known as Ramon Huidobro. He was a diplomat appointed to Bolivia and Beirut. Since he was appointed to those two places she had to go move there. In Bolivia she attended an American private school. There she started to learn how to speak English. In her opini...
Esperanza could be described as shellfish a example of this is when she hides the doll from the little girl on the train on page 69-70 it said “esperanza pulled away the doll and put it in her valise”But eventually changes her ways now she could be described as giving a example of this is when she gave peaches and the doll to isabel on page 227 it says “esperanza pulled her valise out from under her bed and opened it up gave the doll to isabel.” so from these reasons we can conclude that esperanza went from being shellfish to being giving.
Alan Nadel in May All Your Fences Have Gates: Essays on the Drama of August Wilson states “August Wilson’s female characters are represented as nurturers” (6-7).This is exactly how August Wilson presents Rose to his readers. A key element is that Wilson names her after a flower just as his own mother; whose name was Daisy. It is apparent that through Rose, August Wilson wants us to see his mother. He intentionally portrays her as the caring, ideal woman, and one who stands by her man no matter how difficult this may be.
Concerning the contextualization of A Rose of Family as a sign of the times of women at that point, where cultural norms of women lead to a life in domestication. The recognition of the rose here as it is carefully placed in the title of the piece as well bears significance to the physical rose and what it meant to the young women in the South during the 1800s (Kurtz 40). Roses are generally given as tokens of love and affection by males to females. There are even remnants of it today where young lads also profess their love to women with roses; women still see it as an act of endearment towards them.
the Roses due to the families association with the roses. There was three phases of the