Randomized Controlled Trial Summary

1602 Words4 Pages

Liem E, Lin C, Suleman M et al. Anesthetic requirement is increased in redheads. Anesthesiology. 2004;101(2):279-283.

This study is a randomized controlled trial that was conducted with the approval of the University of Louisville Human Studies Committee. The trial was supported by grants from the National Institutes of Health, the Joseph Drown Foundation, and the Commonwealth of Kentucky Research Challenge Trust Fund. No conflicts of interest were apparent, nor did the authors have any financial connection to the products used during testing. The purpose of this study was to determine if the amount of desflurane, an inhalational anesthetic, required to maintain a state of anesthesia is greater in redheads than in those with dark hair. …show more content…

After a laryngeal mask airway was inserted, sevoflurane was discontinued and anesthesia was maintained using desflurane. The initial desflurane concentration was randomly assigned and ranged between 4.5 and 7.5 end-tidal volume %. Following an equilibration period of 45 minutes, noxious electrical stimulation testing began. Intradermal needles inserted bilaterally into the anterior thighs were used to deliver electrical stimulation for 10 seconds at a time at an intensity of 100 Hz, 60-70 mA. This level of stimulation is not tolerated by unanesthetized patients, but is undetected by those under general anesthesia. Response to the stimulation was evaluated by an independent investigator who was chosen randomly out of a group of four investigators for each session. Investigators were brought into the room just before the stimulation commenced. A response was considered positive if a gross purposeful movement of the arms or legs occurred within the first minute after stimulation. While the investigators were not blinded to the hair color or skin complexion of the volunteers, they were blinded to both the initial desflurane concentration as well as the desflurane concentrations for the duration of the study. Depending on if the volunteer moved or did not move in response to the electrical stimulation, desflurane was increased or decreased by 0.5 …show more content…

Dual testing via spectrophotometry and single nucleotide polymorphism analysis ensured that the two hair colors were being accurately represented. Other patient characteristics were not of statistical significance and therefore did not limit the validity of the study. Subjects were recruited from Greater Louisville, Kentucky, an area with a population of over 1,000,000. This indicates a large pool of potential subjects and, therefore, a significant degree of genetic diversity. Unfortunately, however, using volunteers may have created some bias due to the personality type of those who are willing to volunteer for such an experiment. The effort taken to blind the independent investigators was an additional strength of the study. Because investigators were chosen randomly out of a group of 4 for each session and the desflurane concentrations were unknown throughout the study, there was little room for bias. Last, the equilibration periods and movement of the stimulation needle indicated strong study design. Equilibration periods allowed for the desflurane to take it’s full effect before beginning electrical stimulation testing, while moving the needles prevented sensitization of the skin being stimulated. Both measures were critical to ensure that the data recorded was

More about Randomized Controlled Trial Summary

Open Document