Wait a second!
More handpicked essays just for you.
More handpicked essays just for you.
Arguments for and against school dress codes
Importance on dress code in school
Arguments for and against school dress codes
Don’t take our word for it - see why 10 million students trust us with their essay needs.
Recommended: Arguments for and against school dress codes
Imagine you’re student, a female, let’s say. It’s boiling hot out, and you feel as if you could faint any minute. Your jean shorts and two-finger-thick tank top are soaked in sweat when an administrator tells you that your shorts are less than 2 inches away from your finger-tips, and your tank top is too thin and shows bra straps that “are distracting to male students and teachers, and makes them uncomfortable.” You then are told that you need to change into a pair of sweatpants and a thick, long sleeve shirt that has “Dress code violation” printed on the fabric, for all to see. Many students-the majority of them being women-constantly go through the struggle of choosing what to wear that is suitable for their school dress code. Not only do …show more content…
This is proven in an article called “6 Advantages and Disadvantages of School Dress Codes” when the author states, “There are people who love dressing up and more comfortable wearing certain clothes with cuts and designs that fit their body build. If school dress codes prevent them from wearing these types of clothing, this might affect their performance in school. Critics of these policies argue that children should be allowed to be in clothes they are comfortable with.” This evidence shows that many schools want to control and disregard the need for students to be comfortable. Also, everyone has a different body type, so it could be possible that some students are incapable of following the dress code, or that they cannot learn and focus properly. According to theatlantic.com, “Many of these protests have criticized the dress codes as sexist in that they unfairly target girls by body-shaming and blaming them for promoting sexual harassment. Documented cases show female students being chastised by school officials, sent home, or barred from attending events like prom.” This is extremely discriminatory because these young women are being sent home from school because of a simple detail that …show more content…
For example in an article on futureofworking.com the text states, “They [rich and popular students] target these students who either wear shabby or inexpensive clothes and those who they consider odd or with poor taste by bullying them.” This text is giving off the idea that it’s bad for your child to wear what he/she wants because they will get bullied for their poor taste in clothing, or lack of money and designer apparel. The people who support this also think that the bullying will automatically stop out of nowhere if dress codes are enforced because there will be rules to follow. But weren’t there rules in the first place? Can’t the school stop these problems without making the victims of bullying change? Archive.northjersey.com harshly expressed, “‘A lot of the disciplinary problems were for bullying,’ Marinelli said. ‘It's very easy for kids to get picked on for wearing the same clothes over and over or something that's not in style.’” Not only is this a disgusting thing for someone to have said about students who are bullied because of what they wear because they are immediately implying that it’s the victim’s fault that they were getting picked on, and not the person that is responsible for the bullying and their behavior. This quote implies that students must wear clothes that are in style or that are
In a bigger picture, students don’t come to school for a fashion show they come to school for an education. Somewhere along the line some students and parents have forgotten that simple fact. In some districts, like Wilson County Schools, the dress code violations got so out of hand that administration had to threaten suspensions, “During the first six days of the policy change 184 high school students were suspended.” (Creech, 1). The Lima Senior High School campus made the same decision as the Wilson County Schools. On Tuesday January 27, 2009, the Lima City Schools suspended about 164 students for dress code violations. They both knew that their students were having problems following the rules, and since the punishments that were set didn’t affect the students they did the one thing that got the students attention.
Schools typically justify their dress codes by maintain that it’s important to keep the classroom free of any distractions, however, that language actually reinforces the idea that women’s bodies are inherently tempting to men and it’s their responsibility to cover themselves up.
Students that are in public schools whom do not require the use of uniforms wear what they please while looking up to fashion icons; such as Michael Jordan, Beyoncé, Britney Spears, P. Diddy etc. Everyday either before or after school many students utilize electronics like TV, computers etc. Students then may feel like they need to idolize their fashion icons and the best way to become them is to dress similar in any way affordable. However, they’re plenty others that are not as interested or worried about who’s the next fashion mogul. Therefore leaving these individuals vulnerable to being bullied. With that said public schools are known to be divided into diverse segregated congregations. For instance normally there are your math geeks, cheerleaders, Football jocks, the band, and gang affiliated. However within these groups they’re considered popular with similarities in judgment ...
According to greatschools.org, “Enforcing a strict dress code can place the focus of school on clothing and rules, rather than on education.” Most schools have specific uniforms that a child must wear in order to attend. Many children that go to school, have single parents and / or more than one ...
...e effects of dress code in schools helps prevent bulling and allows them to be themselves and keeps negative advertising out of the classrooms. Enforcing these rules impacts the students on a daily basis without them even realizing it. In addition, this makes students feel safe from being bullied or treated differently depending on what they wear. The feeling of being able to be unique and diverse leaves teens feeling like they have the upper hand in the dress code policy, which is a feeling that all teens love.
In the 2015 article on The Atlantic on The Sexism of School Dress Codes, stating that "Many of these protests have criticized the dress codes as sexist in that they unfairly target girls by body-shaming and blaming them for promoting sexual harassment. Documented cases show female students being chastised by school officials, sent home, or barred from attending events like prom." (Zhou, l.) There are more dress code policies for the females compared to the males. For example, girls should not use backless shirts, no spaghetti tops, no crop-tops that exposes the stomach, no short shorts, no miniskirts, etc. Boys on the other hand have no specific dress code policies. Dress codes may come off as sexist for women and they get insulted by it. An article on the problem with dress code from The Daily Princetonian stating "- women are policed so that they are no longer distracting to men, while men, if policed at all, are never told to change for the benefit of the opposite sex. The most prominent example that comes to mind when thinking of male-specific supplements to dress codes relates to sagging pants, an urban trend where pants are worn low to expose many inches worth of boxers. Efforts to ban these practices have never once mentioned how visible boxers would tortuously distract nearby females. Rather, they focus on visible underwear being inappropriate for a learning or work environment.", based on that article, dress codes seem to be a little too specific on what girls should or should not be allowed to wear, while boys only have a few dress code policies to worry
Students should be allowed to wear what they want to school and if bullying occurs then the bully should be punished. Bullying is something that is not going to stop no matter what schools do to try and prevent it. The only way to lower the amount of bullying in schools is to teach children about the consequences of their actions at an early
Dress code enforces the modest dress of students, preventing bullying and distractions.Numerous people believe clothing is a distraction and when eliminated the school environment is more professional and gives a better education to a student. Authority figures consider the school apparel enforcements are constitutionally sound, not affecting the child’s right to freely express, and providing a professional and working setting causing a better learning environment and decreased amount of bullying due to clear differences in appearance. However, opposers disagree with the restrictive code because of its limitations on individuality
The Survival Lottery (John Harris, 1975) is an example of a society being governed with a utilitarian philosophy behind it, with the purpose to live in a society where the majority of people will prosper. Harris’ Survival Lottery explains that organ donation should be an obligation of every human being, and that when selected randomly in a lottery, people are required to sacrifice their life so that their organs can be harvested and used to save the lives of two or more people who are in need of a transplant to save their lives. Harris’ justification for this is that there is no difference between killing one healthy person and allowing two ill people to die because they are both equally as innocent as the healthy person; it was just chance that they fell ill. Harris importantly excluded any people with self-inflicted diseases or illnesses such as liver failure due to excessive alcohol consumption from the lottery.
America’s school systems seem to have many issues concerning students receiving a quality education without distraction. A current debate argues weather a dress code policy is efficient or takes away from student’s expression. Administrators at schools should regulate a dress code policy because the system improves discipline and student’s attention, reduces social conflict and peer pressure related to appearance, and dress code provides a more serious learning environment.
When reading student handbooks there is always a page (or more) dedicated to the dress code rules. At first glance they seem like common sense. Until you notice that most of the regulations seem to target what girls wear. While many of the regulations are used in gender neutral terms they are applied to articles of clothing that is usually considered for girls and is all about limiting the things that even remotely show off the female form. These regulations tell girls that they need to be ashamed of their bodies and they are a distraction.
Too often kids of all ages are bullied because of what they are wearing or what they can not afford to wear, requiring uniforms reduces this issue, tremendously. Dr. Reginald Wilson, senior scholar at the American Council of Education in Washington, D.C., told Jet that, “Uniforms would help discourage violence because students will not have a need to fight over who looks better or want to cause harm in an attempt to take another student 's trendy clothes” (1). No matter how much money a student has or how little money one has, everyone would be wearing the same thing. If everyone wore uniforms and no one was put to a higher standard, then no child would get jealous of the other and want to fight/steal something from another. School uniforms keep kids focused on what the teacher is saying or, more importantly, what the have to do to graduate rather than what cute shirt Susie has on today. Although uniforms reduce crime and bullying in school it does not eliminate it all together. An opponent of the Philadelphia Plan said, “The social and economic factors that contribute to gang activity need to be addressed directly, and that failing students need extra tutoring--not a change of clothes” (Kizis 2). Changing a student’s appearance is not going to change their habits. Bullying, crime, and failure rates may go down, but they are not going to go away just
Having a mandated uniform policy in place assists in easing the burden of school clothing costs by allowing parents to shop for more reasonable prices, because the clothes will look the same regardless of the brand. School bullying can be reduced by not easily being able to determine the more expensive garments versus the less expensive, eliminating the ease with which individuals profile based on income status. Students who regularly bully other students based on clothing choices will be eliminated, improving student behavior. This policy also allows students to concentrate more on their studies than on the next new clothing fad, resulting in more academic progress. Reducing distractions stemming from student clothing choices enables students to concentrate on what they are in school doing, which is learning.
More and more, young women are being targeted and punished for dress code violations. While this may be due to the fact that fashion in today’s society is all about tight clothes, it could also lead to more
An article in the Wall Street Journal reports that students are still being ridiculed for wearing the wrong clothes, and in fact, fashion-related bullying appears to be on the rise, according to Dorothy Espelage, a psychology professor at the University of Illinois. This evidence contradicts the opposing team's argument. Additionally, the opposing team claimed that they have never seen bullying based on brands in our school, but this assertion is easily refuted since we wear school uniforms at SIS. Therefore, it is evident that bullying based on clothing, including brands and inexpensive clothing, is still prevalent and increasing in frequency. As bullying is detrimental to a student's well-being, it is crucial to prevent it and promote healthy development by implementing school uniforms globally, particularly in Hong Kong.