Phineas 'Denial In The Book A Separate Peace'

740 Words2 Pages

A Separate Peace What is denial? Denial is the action of declaring something to be untrue. “Denial is the worst form of the truth” (Ella the Wise and Powerful). In the book A Separate Peace there are three reasons why Phineas denied that there was a war. The first reason is because he broke his leg and no military branch would accept him in. The second reason is that since he couldn’t go to fight in the war, he didn’t want any of his friends going. The final reason was he was coping with Gene breaking his leg. Why would anyone deny that there was a war? Phineas denied that there was a war. He did this because he sent letters after letters to the navy, the military, the air force, and the army. They denied him time and time again. All of his friends and his classmates kept getting accepted to any of the military branches. He me must have felt embarrassed because when he sees and hears about how all of his friends are getting accepted he was getting denied. That also made him feel useless because the only reason that the military wouldn’t accept him was because of his leg. That is why he probably felt useless, because when all of his friends are going to be heading off to fight in this great war that had to be fought, he was going to be back in the states and be at home or at some job instead of fighting in this great war. …show more content…

Phineas denied the war again and again. Phineas kept denying that there was a war because he didn’t want to accept that Gene had broken his leg on purpose and that Gene would go off to fight it the war and he couldn’t because Gene broke his leg. You can see that he didn’t want to accept it because when they were doing the trial Phineas got up and ran way until he broke his leg and then when Gene came to visit him he tried to get away from

Show More
Related

  • Phineas 'Coming Of Age In John Knowles' A Separate Peace

    651 Words  | 2 Pages

    In John Knowles’ A Separate Peace, characters Gene and Phineas begin their journeys to adulthood in a war torn environment. The dynamic formed between a world full of struggle and the crucial age of development in high school proves to be an excellent setting to examine the abilities of both Gene and Phineas to “come of age.” Being a Bildungsroman, the theme of coping with war and death is highlighted via the imagery that surrounds both Gene’s epiphany moment at the marble stairs, and its introduction at the beginning of the novel. Additionally, Knowles employs a flashback to set a nostalgic and somewhat reflective mood, which further extends this meaning. In Knowles’ “coming of age” novel A Separate Peace, the use of imagery surrounding the marble stairs, and a reminiscent flashback aid Gene is discovering that war and death can never be understood.

    Read More

  • A Separate Peace ': Phineas' Escape From Reality

    703 Words  | 2 Pages

    Throughout the novel, Phineas develops a theory that the war is a ruse made up by “fat old men who don’t want us crowding them out of their jobs” (Knowles 115). This is not just a joke between him and Gene; it is part of what makes up Phineas’ character. He always chooses to accept whatever is preferable rather what is truthful. It is also possible that his theory about the war is caused by the fact that his broken leg prevents him from enlisting; if he cannot participate, then he refuses to accept it as the truth. Phineas does eventually inform Gene that, “I always knew

    Read More

  • The Great Gatsby Dialectical Journal Chapter 1

    346 Words  | 1 Pages

    1. The most crucial point in Chapter 1 is the call Tom receives from his lover. After Nick, Jordan, Tom, and Daisy spent a well mannered night together, the phone rings and Tom rushes to it. When Daisy follows behind it’s revealed it’s a mistress from New York. This is a crucial point as it reveals the falseness in Tom and Daisy’s relationship. Although it initially looked as if all was fine, a larger theme of disingenuousness is behind their relationship.

    Read More

  • Tim O’Brien's Going After Cacciato

    568 Words  | 2 Pages

    Not because of strong convictions, but because he didn't known. He didn't know who was right, or what was right, he didn't know if it was a war of self-determination or self-destruction, outright aggression or national liberation; he didn't know if nations would topple like dominoes or stand separate like trees; he didn't know who really started the war, or why, or when, or with what motives; he didn't know if it mattered; he saw sense in both sides of the debate, but he did not know where the truth lay; he simply didn't know. He just didn't know if the war was right or wrong or somewhere in the murky middle. So he went to war for reasons beyond knowledge. Because he believed in law, and law told him to go. Because it was a democracy...He went to war because it was expected. Because not to go was to risk censure, and to bring embarrassment on his father and his town. Because, not knowing, he saw no reason to distrust those with more experience. Because he loved his country, and more than that, because he trusted it. Yes, he did. Oh, he would rather have fought with his father in France, knowing certain things certainly, but he couldn't choose his war, nobody could. (p. 234-235)

    Read More

  • Phineas 'Denial In John Knowles' A Separate Peace

    1212 Words  | 3 Pages

    Denial, the defense mechanism of the previously ignorant, buries problems beneath lies, which only allows them to grow at unbeknownst to others. With it's presence, the evaded issues multiply at alarming rates, problems that can be avoided with simple acknowledgment. Naive and desperate, Phineas, a character from the novel A Separate Peace, consistently demonstrates the quality of denial through his actions pertaining to his friendship with Gene, his best friend. Finny suppresses his knowledge of his friend's jealousy in favor of believing that their fraying friendship provides a haven towards both boys. By portraying Phineas as one who avoids conspicuous issues, The author, John Knowles, teaches the importance of acknowledging core troubles,

    Read More

  • A Separate Peace Archetypes

    1077 Words  | 3 Pages

    Even as negative as these feelings are, they still prove to help people become successful in this world as they navigate through tough times and they use these feelings to re-inspire them to work harder and achieve more. Furthermore, Phineas' viewpoint is too innocent to last in the real world. For example, Finny views the world as he views sports which Gene explains as, "Everyone always won at sports. When you played a game you won, in the same way as when you sat down to a meal you ate it. It inevitably and naturally followed. Finny never permitted himself to realize that when you won they lost" (27). As idealistic as this sounds, it is not plausible to live by this statement in the real world and expect to succeed. Since Finny refuses to see logic in this statement but Gene understands the underlying problem with it, Gene is more likely to survive and succeed in this world because he understands not everything can be the perfect version that a person wishes it to be. Phineas' pure heart and innocent intentions are good in theory but they do not last in this world which demands more cunning and strategic motivations such as the ones Gene

    Read More

  • Why the Confederacy Lost the War

    716 Words  | 2 Pages

    Each author agreed that the battles were not the only reason for the fall and death of the Confederacy. While battles were being fought on the battlefields, the home fronts were had their own battles to fight. McPherson discusses what he calls as the “internal conflict” thesis, which blames the uneasiness among the southerners. The government was being blamed. Southerners were opposing conscription, taxes, and habeus corpus. McPherson points out that these could not have been reasons for the loss. The same thing was happening in the North. Therefore this internal conflict with the home front government does not have a plausible role in why the South lost the war. If the North was fighting the same type of opposition at home, then shouldn’t the war have ended in a stalemate? Also, the non-slaveholding whites and the slaves were feeling alienated. Rich slaveholders who wanted to keep slave labor alive were fighting the war. The two alienated groups were fighting a war on the wrong side. The non-slaveholders opposed sec...

    Read More

  • Bayard’s Search for Subjective Truth in Faulkner’s The Unvanquished

    526 Words  | 2 Pages

    Later in the book, he again reflects on the war. He catalogs the proofs that he has been given — injured and half-starved countrymen — but persists in his existential doubt. He notes, “So we knew a war existed; we had to believe that, just as we had to believe that the name for the sort of life we had led for the last three years was hardship and suffering. Yet we had no proof of it. In fact, we had even less than no proof; we had had thrust into our faces the very shabby and unavoidable obverse of proof…” (94). Because he has not seen the battles, he has difficulty acknowledging the reality of war.

    Read More

  • The Moral Equivalent of War by William James

    1130 Words  | 3 Pages

    To have a war for the sole purpose of having a war is ridiculous. Another civil war right now would hardly reflect the original Civil War and we would not be able to predict the consequences it might bring. All wars do not bring the benefit that James is looking for.

    Read More

  • Character Analysis: The Super Suicide Society

    657 Words  | 2 Pages

    Phineas didn’t return back to school immediately that year, but when he does be finds out that Gene was thinking of enlisting in the war. Phineas is angry that Gene can enlist while he can't, so he comes up with a theory to keep him from enlisting. The theory is that the war is all a hoax and it is created by fat old men. Of course, Gene believes this and decides there isn't a point in enlisting now. Because Phineas also wanted to be a part of the Olympics he suggests that Gene should train to become an athlete in the 1944 Olympics.Mr Ludsbury tells the boys that there will be no 1944 Olympics due to the war, but Phineas still insists that Gene trains. Phineas even sets up a winter carnival with Olympic events for Gene to compete

    Read More

  • A Separate Peace, by John Knowles

    1215 Words  | 3 Pages

    ...couldn’t see anyone as his enemy. Even Gene had his own enemy to kill, “I never killed anybody and I never developed an intense level of hatred for the enemy. Because my war ended before I ever put on a uniform; I was on active duty all my time at school; I killed my enemy there. Only Phineas never was afraid, only Phineas never hated anyone (Knowles 196).”

    Read More

  • Dishonesty in The Great Gatsby

    1501 Words  | 4 Pages

    Lies are a treacherous thing, yet everyone tells a few lies during their lifetime. Deceit surrounds us all the time even when one reads classic literature. For example, F. Scott Fitzgerald makes dishonesty a major theme in his novel The Great Gatsby. The falsehoods told by the characters in this novel lead to inevitable tragedy when the truth is revealed. Jay Gatsby, one of the main characters in the novel, fails to realize that when one tells a lie, it comes back to bite you.

    Read More

  • Socrates and His Innocence

    907 Words  | 2 Pages

    Socrates lived such a private life that it lead to the most important revelation of his entire life. He would go about his life doing nothing but self-examination. In examining his life so strenuously others would come to him to be taught, or to have their children be taught by Socrates. They would offer him money and he would refuse. They would do whatever they could to learn anything Socrates had to teach. What they did not know is that Socrates was not teaching anyone he was simply going about his usual life and people just happened to learn from it. This was also why Socrates was put on trial. He was brought up on two charges, one of impiety and the other of corrupting the youth. These two charges set the course for the last month of his life.

    Read More

  • The Power of Guilt and Shame in Phaedra

    380 Words  | 1 Pages

    In neo-classical works of literature, the themes are often based on reason and passion. The two factors of influence collide in a struggle that an individual character or group of characters must overcome and decide which to follow, and this conflict usually leads to suffering, guilt, and shame. In Racine's classic, Phaedra, the title character is influenced by her overwhelming passion, which leads to her commit her crimes by the power of guilt and shame.

    Read More

  • Thucydides: The War Against Athens And The Peloponnesian War

    1078 Words  | 3 Pages

    In Thucydides’ opening, he believed that the war against Athens and the Peloponnesians was going to be a great war that it would be a fundamental event proceeding all other wars for the past and future. Beginning to understand the Peloponnesian War, how it started and who was blamed, it is important to understand the Athenians. Athens was a city-state of art, philosophy and great power. With great power and influence, arrogance also followed. Greece had just finished eighteen years prior with their war against the Persians. The Greeks had strengthened in numbers, and the Athens was at the top of all other city-states. The Athenians were the first to lay aside their weapons, and to adopt an easier and more luxurious mode of life; indeed, it

    Read More

More about Phineas 'Denial In The Book A Separate Peace'

Open Document