One Good Beating

1056 Words3 Pages

One Good Beating

Many contemporary Scottish plays explore the conflict that can exist

between people of different generations. In this essay I am going to

discuss whether or not Linda McLean’s “One Good Beating” conveys this

issue of conflict and explore the other themes throughout the play.

Although “One Good Beating” only consists of three characters

(Robert-dad, Elaine- daughter and Stephen-son) there are many

conflicts throughout the play, many of which are between all three

characters over the same issue.

Stephen is in conflict with his dad Robert because when he was younger

he used to beat him. Stephen is still affected by his traumatising

childhood even though he is in his mid thirties.

Stephen: “But he never hit you”

Elaine: “If he thinks for a minute you’re stuck in the past he’ll

Beat you”

These words illustrate how Stephen has been emotionally scarred by

what his father did to him and can’t live his life properly because he

is living with the memory of his tragic childhood.

This conflict, which has grown between these two characters, does not

just go in the one direction, Robert is in conflict with Stephen but

for an entirely different reason.

Robert never loved Stephen however Stephen continued trying to change

his father’s opinion. The only way Robert could react to this was to

hit Stephen.

Robert: “I couldn’t give a tuppenny damn whether you forgave me or not…”

Stephen: “all I wanted from him…I wanted him to love me…”

Robert: “ …I don’t like you”

Robert’s only problem with his son was that he had been born. However

he didn’t love Stephen because he could not love any one. It was just

simply because he did not like him.

Robert: “its temporary, Elaine knows I love her.”

These words emphasise even more that it was just his son he had a

problem with and that he was devoted to his daughter.

Stephen is not the only one in conflict with Robert. Elaine is also in

conflict with Robert because when she was young, Robert killed her

puppy.

Robert: “ … dead something. Puppy maybe.”

Elaine reacts to this by (stage directions) hitting the coal-shed

door, which demonstrates that she has never forgiven her father for

what he did and still feels strongly about the issue. She is also in

conflict with her father because he hit her mother and brother and

buried their mother without even informing them of her death.

Elaine: “ you didn’t even give her a proper funeral”

Elaine: “ you never told anybody she was dead”

This emphasises how she felt about her mother and how much hate she

has for her father because of how he mistreated her mother.

Open Document