Mystery and Menace in Black Veil and Signal Man

2169 Words5 Pages

If you are setting this submission as Premium, then please enter a

short description of what the essay is trying to achieve. Word Count.

Compare how Dickens creates a sense of mystery and menace in the

‘Black Veil’ and the ‘Signal Man’. Explain how he uses these theories

to explore his theme?

The opening of both stories are quite different. The Black Veil is

written in the third person and The Signal man is written in the first

person narrative. The Black Veil creates an atmosphere of cosiness and

warmth which is created by the items of clothing which are worn by the

doctor. ‘reposing in his dressing gown and slippers’ The atmosphere is

also created by pleasant thoughts as the doctor thinks of his native

place and dearest friends. ‘Then his mind reverted to his annual

Christmas visit to his native place and dearest friends’. There is

also a contrast within the story of the Black Veil negative against

positive for example Death and life or Squalid and cosy etc. In

contrast the Signal man’s opening draws great attention to the

audience. "Halloa! Bellow there!" Immediately there is an element of

mystery, the Signal man looks down the line instead of where the sound

is coming from. ‘he turned about, and looked down the line.’

We are then acquainted with the characters and introduced to the

problem at hand. In the Black Veil the characters are appealing

whereas in the Signal man Dickens makes the characters less appealing

so we can focus on the problem. The Doctor is portrayed as a

optimistic man who does not dwell on gloomy thoughts. ’If he could

only tell her that he had found a patient at last, and hoped to have

more’. The doctors is also compassionate towards the woman in the

Black Veil. ‘Are you i...

... middle of paper ...

...thout any friends or money and had

denied herself comforts for her son but her son did not seem to care

about the suffering his mother had endured for him and his welfare

became fixated on this woman’s mind which drove her to insanity in the

same way the figure appearing to the signal man drove him to insanity

as well. The story ends on an uplifting note. The doctor visited this

woman everyday and supported her financially. At last when the woman

died her last breath uttered a prayer for this doctor. ‘That prayer

flew to heaven and was heard’, and the doctor was blessed throughout

his life. Dickens leaves us with a moral If you are charitable then

you will be rewarded later in life from heaven for your good deeds.

One of the main purposes of this story is to awake the readers social

conscious by being aware of people who are less fortunate than

ourselves.

More about Mystery and Menace in Black Veil and Signal Man

Open Document