Wait a second!
More handpicked essays just for you.
More handpicked essays just for you.
Comparative analysis essay
Comparative analysis essay
Comparative analysis essay
Don’t take our word for it - see why 10 million students trust us with their essay needs.
Recommended: Comparative analysis essay
Short stories and films both have very similar structural elements with the tension in them increasing and the ways they use to make both visual and literature entertaining, however they both can be very diverse. “Little Old Lady from Cricket Creek” written by Len Gray and the 2 minute short film “Be careful with that Crossbow” have some similarities. It just seems that the plot flow and the words and visual aspects used for the characters in these two entertainment sources are not very cohesive. Take the Little Old Lady from Cricket Creek. The plot is an old lady who is applying for a job at an insurance company. Compared to a boy who is shooting arrows at a little girl’s face they are not really relatable. The element of tension rise and personality however are probably the only aspects these two have. The tension rise in the short story seems to be mounting equivalently with the short film. …show more content…
The tension build could not exist without an orientation to find what caused it.
The Little Old Lady from Cricket Creek’s orientation starts off as a traditional orientation with the characters being introduced and the setting they are in (which is Great Riveroak Insurance Company) which is the who and where part of the story. Then the “what” part of the orientation which is the old lady is applying for a job at this company. On the other hand, Crossbow doesn’t really show the “who, what and when” scenario. With the film just starting on a shot of the little boy shooting arrows. With no dialogue at all, it doesn’t tell who they are this forces the audience to really pay attention to the characters. As the short story seems to be more coherent, the film seems to be out of line which makes these two incommensurable. However the only thing that they do have in comparable is their rising
tension. Little Old Lady and Crossbow are both really entertaining narratives. This is due to of how high the rising tension or complication is mounting. Crossbow’s tension exist because of how the position of the arrows are to the little girl’s head and the use of angles and sound they use for it to make it really eye catching. Little Old Lady from Cricket Creek does the same build but with really descriptive word use and the actions that are occurring. For example the highest point in rising tension is when the old lady robs the company’s money, the phrase “she took a pistol out of her handbag” was one of the sentences that was from the section of the story. It is really needy for the reader’s attention. Unfortunately whatever goes up must come down and that is what is happening with the tension trend in these two narrative. This must mean that the resolution is near by The Little Old Lady from Cricket Creek ends with a really surprising and unexpected way with Mabel Jumpstone being the protagonist’s Mom!!!! This relationship revealment was much unanticipated which really made this story really successful when it comes to entertainment. I think the tension in the resolution probably dropped gradually. Whereas Crossbows resolution just drops completely because of how dull and sudden it is with the last arrow shot through the forest and into a gardener’s bottom then the boy tries to run away but then he get knocked out by a rake. This wasn’t much unanticipated as the short story. In comparison these two are very different with one story being unexpected and the other not really. But this plot structure cannot occur without characters playing them. The characters in Crossbow are very general with just boy and girl. However we can identify them with the actions they do to unlock their personality traits. Take the boy, we can tell he is very mischievous because of when he tries to run away from the gardener. People should see that very clearly. Whereas in the short story Little Old Lady from Cricket Creek, the characters seem to be more broad and specific than Crossbow with them actually having names and descriptive words used for their actions and appearance. Take Mabel Jumpstone, with descriptive words we can tell she is old without saying she is old like the phrase from the story “Mrs Jumpstone came shuffling and others like “like an old grey mare”. These two narrative are nothing alike when it comes to characters with one being narrow and the other being more broad when it comes to description. However the personality in the two protagonists of the narratives seem to have the same personality with both being mischief.e In conclusion, these two narratives seem to be very entertaining in their own unique way with one being suspenseful and the other just being straight up weird. They both have very authentic characters and really high rise tension which audiences seem to like. Although short film and short stories are quite different, they both are also the same because they are both entertaining narratives.
Many people assume that the book and movie of the same story are always very similar, but they are incorrect. In my comparison of the short story Rikki-tikki-tavi by Rudyard Kipling and the movie of Rikki-tikki-tavi, I found them to be rather different. There were many minor differences, but the three main topics in the short story that clearly differentiate it from the movie are the setting, the character traits, and the use of humor.
For these reasons it is clear to see that the three stories i read though they were created by the same person they still do have many differences and similarities. Out of the three i was most interested in sound of thunder mainly because it created the most suspense. That is what i thought of the three short
Fiction often imitates life, as well as life imitates fiction, as we will see in the following comparison between a newspaper article in the Philadelphia Inquire in 1987 and a short story written by William Faulkner in 1930. Although there are some differences such as the time, place and circumstance, the two studies are chillingly similar.
The short story and the film have the same plots and the same conflict ...
A portion of the best movies ever in a wide assortment of literary genres have been adapted from short tales. In particular, when we look to the classical horror movies adapted from books; it seems that there is a remarkable number of fictitious films that were based on short stories.
...tail. Also, many camera angles that exploit the atmosphere of sexuality make these films very similar in the eyes of a regular viewer. Both movies allow the viewer to experience how life is much tougher under social pressures from the point of view of many characters. Not only do these movies focus on small details in various scenes, they show the complexity of making movies while incorporating a unique story line and keeping the viewer involved with each and every characters problems.
Authors of short stories, like Carter, have the freedom to write as much or as little as they want, in any manner they please. The genre of short stories is so vast and diverse that authors are allowed to write in different styles, lengths, and descriptiveness. However, the general public has specific expectations of films that producers, directors, writers, and actors must fulfill in order to create a successful film. In order for the audience to enjoy the film, Dan Rush couldn’t limit it to the ideas presented in Carver’s short story, he had to expand the details of the plot and provide more information to the audience. By providing more information and detail, this makes the film a more enjoyable and immersing experience for the audience.
There were many similarities in the written text and the screenplay, one being the situational and dramatic irony shared between them. Another example showing how both of the versions are similar is when Della was selling her things then cut her hair which was her prized possession to buy
These two films are not only similar on these surface levels, but also in their narrative structure and intent as well. Dorothy and Alice, both find themselves trapped in a world of their own fantasy, but with no context on how to navigate their way home. They are then lead by an array of strange characters who guide them on their journey. Dorothy meets the scarecrow, the tin man, the cowardly lion, and so on. While Alice crosses paths with the white rabbit, the cheshire cat, the mad hatter, and so on. With the assistance of their companions, both heroines maneuver their way through the challenges each fantasy presents. Perhaps the biggest similarity these films share narratively, is the underlying emphasis on empathy and perspective. Both
Love. What is it? An intense feeling of deep affection. Abuse. What is it? Violent treatment of someone. Now, that we have the correct meaning of the two, do they combine? Well, in many cases, they do, but are not intended to. Connecting a film to a piece of writing gives it a meaning and makes it whole. The connection between the two can be broad, or hard to understand, but will make the idea bigger as a whole. Have you ever read a good story? I mean a really good story? The kind of story that has you where you feel as if your entire life blinked before your eyes? Or the kind of story where it was so good that you want to read it over and over again? Have you ever thought about why that story was as good as it was? The same can occur in a
A Comparison of Little Red Riding Hood by Charles Perrault and Little Red Cap by the Brothers Grimm
Little women and Far away have a lot of similarities. Both movies are about love, romance, and drama. In Far and away one of the characters named Joseph is a hard working man but in the movie, the government burns down his house so he goes after the man in charge and ends up being locked in a room after he tried to kill the man in charge. That's when he meets Shannon for the first time really.Shannon is the man on charges daughter.He met her while she was getting her
Good stories don’t have to be writing in the same period of time or in the same place to be compared. A great example of short stories that can be compared ann were not written in the same year are: A Rose for Emily” by William Fulkner and “The Pura Principle” by Junot Diaz. This stories were have a lot similarities and differences. For example they were both a first person narrative, both revolve around characters who are ill and at some point in the story they both had the same elements of tone.
In conclusion, these stories are very similar in many ways. Out of all the themes that could be used to compare the two, the most important ones are hatred, manipulation and hatred. Hatred is disliking some one or something and there are many characters that dislike each other. Manipulation is using your creativity to come up with a way to get someone to believe something that is not true. Lastly, jealousy, which is wanting something that someone else has and doing things to get it which is what Iago did in the play and Fernand did in the movie.
"Books and movies are like apple and oranges. They both are fruit, but taste completely different.” said Stephen King (goodreads.com). It is indeed true, books and movies have several common things and yet have differences. They both give us the same story, but are viewed completely different. Reading books and watching movies are similar as they both tell a story and give details and information about the story. Reading books or watching movies gives the reader and the viewer the same feeling and emotions about the story. People can feel gloomy or pleased with the story after reading a book or watching a movie. Both books and movies have the same general concepts, which are the themes and main characters of