Life Tenure Essay

734 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Quizlet parkinson's disease

The nine members on the Supreme Court have the power to serve for life, also called Life Tenure. People have been saying that Justices should not be able to serve for life and retire when they want. Justices are serving well into their old age and they should be able to spend time with their family instead of working all the time on cases. Many people question the wisdom of judges in their 70s through 80s. Many elders have difficulties with health problems. A lot of elderly people suffer from illnesses like alzheimer’s, parkinson's, and respiratory problems. They have to remember to take care of themselves before their job. Judges are a huge influence on us. All the other judges have age limits, so Supreme Court Judges deserve them too. …show more content…

Justices should take care of themselves than going to their job everyday to take care of cases. They can suffer from alzheimer’s, which can make them forget rules, parkinson’s, which can be severe enough for a caretaker and 24/7 watch, respiratory problems, or many other things. A lot of health problems need someone to remind them when to take their medicine or help them get things. Sometimes, their health problems can lead to death. They should spend the time they have left with their family if it is a life threatening disease. Justices should not be this attached to their jobs to not even worry about their health. Diabetes is a disease elders can also suffer from. Diabetes is a very serious disease and out of nowhere, it can take over their body sending them to their hospital. Justices should have a limited time to serve because they have to take care of themselves …show more content…

Others might say that a Justice can serve for how long they want, even until they die. But when the Justices die suddenly, they are going to have to find a replacement out of nowhere. All the paperwork and interviews, when we can just have the new Justices ready until the other Justice’s term ends. Some may say that Justices spent years in law school to prepare for this moment. Other judges spent years in law school and went under a lot of stress and they only serve for 4-8 years. It is not fair that Justices get a better privilege for what they have worked up to. Supreme Court Justices should not serve for life even though some people might

Show More
Related

  • The Nine: Inside the Secret World of the Supreme Court by Jeffrey Toobin

    1205 Words  | 3 Pages

    ... eye. While Toobin gave me great insight to the people who make up the Supreme Court, this book has become dated in some aspects. Stevens and Souter no longer are a part of the Supreme Court. As this book shows, each individual Justice makes up the personality of Supreme Court, which is now sightly different, without Justices Stevens and Souter. The nine justices in the book served together longer than any other group of Justices. Toobin describes the how each of the Justices got appointed to the Supreme court, including the failed nominations that ultimately brought each of the Justices to the Supreme court. The Supreme Court shapes our country in ways that no other branch of government can, because they are appointed for life. Ultimately, nominating a Supreme Court Justics, is one of the most far reaching and lasting way a president can shape our nation.

    Read More

  • Larry J. Sabato's Thoughts on Constitutional Revisions

    1076 Words  | 3 Pages

    Preventing federal judges to serve for life is a good concept, except when the judges become too old to continue presiding. Setting term limits for judges would be a great idea, because it would add diversity to the court systems every time a new judge arrives. Some judges are just too old, and senile, to still rule on cases and do their job effectively; therefore, setting term limits would ultimately benefit the courts because it would allow for diversity, and a new judge who may have different standards.

    Read More

  • Pros And Cons Of Federal Court Judges

    1751 Words  | 4 Pages

    It is simple to be confused by the federal court judges and their decisions and how they go about them and how they are in their position. Personally, I always thought they were elected by the Supreme Court or someone or something higher than them. But I was very surprised to know that they were appointed (assigned a job or role to). This leaves the judges from having to go through a process of campaigning and running against others. Although by being unelected officials it has both pros and cons. Pros being, that they are trusted enough to handle cases that go to this point and being able to make a decision under the law to better the society. Cons being, if a federal court judge makes any misdemeanor or crime they have the ability to be impeached

    Read More

  • Lifetime Tenure for Supreme Court Justices

    1624 Words  | 4 Pages

    The Honorable Jonathan Yates, former deputy general counsel for the Committee on Government Reform and Oversight of the U. S. House of Representatives, writes, “This lifetime term now enjoyed by justices not only contravenes the spirit of the Constitution, it counters the role intended for the court as a minor player in the equal judiciary branch of government. Term limits are needed to adjust the part of the court to the intent of the founding fathers” (Np). Judge Yates explains that the greatest powers of the Supreme Court did not originate from the Constitution or Congress, but from their own rulings (Np). The most prominent of which, was being Marbury v. Madison, in which the court granted itself judicial review, or the power to determine the constitutionality of legislation (Yates). Furthermore, the intended role of the court by the founding fathers was so small, that it did not have a home, or meet to hear any cases (Yates). An amendment to the Constitution removing the lifetime tenure of U.S. Supreme Court judges needs consideration by Congress. Lifetime tenure on the U.S. Supreme Court has led to four points that could not have been foreseen by the creators of the Constitution. The first problem resulting from the Supreme Court’s tenure policy is that judges’ are holding on to their seats, disregarding debilitating health issues. The second issue that has arisen from lifetime tenure is the use of strategic retirement by sitting judges to ensure a like-minded replacement. The third development resulting from lifetime tenure is the steady decrease in case decisions by the U.S. Supreme Court. The fourth and final effect lifetime tenure has had on the Supreme Court is an increase in celebrity status of the judges, which has le...

    Read More

  • The Brethren: Inside The Supreme Court By Bob Woodward And Scott Armstrong

    519 Words  | 2 Pages

    The Brethren: Inside the Supreme Court, by Bob Woodward and Scott Armstrong, gives the public an intimate description of the justices who serve on the Supreme Court in the 1969-1976. This book also gives an unprecedented look at the daily work and personal lives of the justices. The book describes the relationships the justices have with each other and the relationships they have with their clerks. Woodward and Armstrong give the reader insight to the justice's personalities and their personal agenda. There is an appearance that the justices use their positions on the Supreme Court to push their ideologies and create laws instead of enforcing the laws set by congress.

    Read More

  • Term Limits In Supreme Court Justices

    1089 Words  | 3 Pages

    Life tenure creates at least three problems. First, it allows bad judges to stay on the bench for an indefinite period of time. Second, life tenure allows all judges, including those judges who were very good at what they did, to stay on the bench even after they are long past doing their best work. Third and finally, life tenure allows justices to “rig the system”, as their productivity and effectiveness drastically decrease, while they wait for a president to nominate their successor who has similar viewpoints to theirs (Lazarus

    Read More

  • Why Is The Judicial Branch The Least Dangerous

    666 Words  | 2 Pages

    Their long term in office liberates judges from partisan burdens and inhibits attacks on judicial power by the executive and legislative branch. Independence gives the judicial branch the ability to guard the Constitution and the rights of the people against the legislature. That means that he believes that the judicial branch is less likely to abuse a person's as compared to the executive or legislative. He felt that judges should have independence from the sanction of the executive, legislature, and the individuals so they can satisfy the judicial qualities defined in the Constitution. The U.S. Constitution offers that federal judges are selected to life term thru good behavior, so the courts can remain independent from the other two

    Read More

  • Georgia State Court System

    1956 Words  | 4 Pages

    Supreme Court and Court of Appeals judges are elected in nonpartisan statewide elections. Mid-term vacancices are filled by appointment. State law requires that nominees are state residents and have practiced law for a minimum of seven years.

    Read More

  • The Second Challenge: Imperial Judiciary

    1279 Words  | 3 Pages

    People have always been concerned about our judicial system making massive decisions in an undemocratic manner and while there are parts of our nation’s history (Jost). There have been decisions that were dreadful for our nation, Dred Scott v. Sandford; but there are decisions that everyone can agree with in retrospect, Brown v. Board of Education. Also, there are decisions that still divide us as a nation, Bush v. Gore and Roe V. Wade. There are a lot of issues that come from our current judicial system; however, I understand that the problems that come from it are not going to come from any quick fix, and we may have to live with some of them. Looking at the history of the judicial branch of the United States Government, I believe it needs to be limited in its judicial review power, but have certain exceptions where necessary in some cases.

    Read More

  • Career Essay

    583 Words  | 2 Pages

    In 2012 nearly 205,000 people were employed as a physical therapist in the United States. The average salary of a physical therapist in 2012 was $79,860 per year. The number of jobs is estimated to grow 36% from 2012-2022. This job of physical therapy involves many and very important tasks to fulfill the needs of their patients. It requires many different educational requirements and you must have strong people skills.

    Read More

  • Punishment of Offenders

    1029 Words  | 3 Pages

    ... or appointed to their positions because of our supposed confidence in their impartial views when it comes to dispensing justice. However, the trend in the past few years has been for legislatures to minimize the discretion given to judges at sentencing, partly in an attempt to treat similar defendants more similarly and to avoid the effect of rogue judges. These policies have effectively taken some of the important discretion away from the very people who are supposed to be the most intimately involved in our due process. Legislators are too far removed from this process to be mandating broad strokes of punishment without considering each and every case on its merits. If we want to improve our criminal justice system and develop a long-term strategy for addressing the overcrowding in our prisons, then both "3 Strikes Laws" and Mandatory Minimums must be changed.

    Read More

  • Judicial Restraint Definition

    449 Words  | 1 Pages

    Judicial disagreements, conservative versus liberal or restraint versus activism, will continue to characterize the nature of the land’s highest court. Regardless, the Supreme Court will continue to serve as a “referee” regarding the actions of the executive and legislative branches. The battle between judicial restraint and judicial activism has been a significant part of United States Supreme Court history, and the conflict will epitomize President Obama’s Supreme Court nomination

    Read More

  • Benefits Of Ageing

    1730 Words  | 4 Pages

    In today’s society, what was once said to be true and taken as fact regarding older people is no longer the whole story. As Laslett states, “At all times before the middle of the twentieth century and all over the globe the greater part of human life potential has been wasted, by people dying before their allotted time was up.” (1989a), and to a great extent a lot

    Read More

  • Advantages And Disadvantages Of Judges

    1104 Words  | 3 Pages

    Many judges, whether appointed or elected, tend to serve for life. Often times, once they are in place, then it is very difficult to remove them. The advantage of having judges that are older is for their experience and wisdom. These judges are typically able to make sound judgments. They have obtained a degree of respect from their community and judicial colleagues. If a judge is able to maintain a sound mind and is physically fit to stay on the bench, then there should not be a cause of concern. However, with the aging process, the human body begins to decline. Unfortunately, sound judgment and memory begins to diminish. The body begins to weaken and it becomes increasingly difficult for a judge to keep up with the demand for the job. Often time than not, the judge is the one who decides when he should step down. If he a defiant person, then that decision will be a difficult one for him to make even though his stepping down would be for the betterment of all people. Most judges are able to continue serving even into advanced ages. As long as they are capable, then they should continue to do

    Read More

  • Value of Life Essay

    909 Words  | 2 Pages

    Human life is full of meaning. As humans, we assign value to many things. However, what happens when we assign a specific value to a human life? This is the issue being presented in the article, “What is a Life Worth,” by Amanda Ripley. The government is determining a monetary value to a human life, and it does not appeal to the masses. There are many problems with the cold calculation, and most people cannot see the other side of the numbers. The economic value of a human life is calculated based on the income the person was receiving, but when the check is given to a loved one of a small amount, the compensation is misinterpreted as an overall value of the human life. The true value of a human life should not be combined with the monetary value that is determined by the government, or the value of life would be worth very little.

    Read More

More about Life Tenure Essay

Open Document