John Mcwhorter Argumentative Essay

423 Words1 Page

John McWhorter’s article about how the term African American should not denote Americans who are descendants of slaves in America. Rather, the word “Black” should be used for these people. McWhorter’s article is structured like an argumentative essay. He opens with a powerful thesis, stating that the US needs to let go of the term “African American” and start using the term “Black – with a capital B.” McWhorter’s first set of paragraphs talk about how people who are actually from Africa and have immigrated to the United States differ vastly from most Black Americans. People from Africa speak multiple languages, have different cuisines, and are culturally vastly different. Black people and African immigrants share less in common than a “working-class …show more content…

McWhorter briefly states that African immigrants also face racism in the same manner as Black Americans. It creates a comparison between African immigrants and Black Americans and helps create a need for separate terms for African immigrants and Black Americans. McWhorter explains how the term African American “carries an air of standing protest.” He explains how this term is connected to the many problems descendants of slaves faced throughout the Americas. However, it forgets the several accomplishments that descendants of slaves in America accomplished. McWhorter lists off a series of accomplishments to reinforce his idea that the term African American should be changed to Black. McWhorter ends with a concession about how no term is perfect, but some are better than others. Most carry a highly negative connotation or come from a place of struggle. The “Black” also carries an air of power with it. McWhorter rephrases a quote from James Brown, where he exchanges the term Black for African American. This further exemplifies how there is a need to change the term. In the same way, people follow traditions for the simple reason they are traditions - people use the term African

Open Document