John Edgar's Brothers and Keepers: A Struggle Against the Prison Institution

1124 Words3 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Prison poulation research paper

At the base of most stories is conflict; the protagonist verses the antagonist. This conflict is what works to drive the plot and contributes to the climax and resolutions of a story. The conflicts of a story are not always obvious and most times there are multiple conflicts within a single story. This case is no different for Brothers and Keepers by John Edgar Wideman. Wideman’s work is memoir that focuses on a comparison between himself and his brother that works to understand how each one of them ended up where they did in life. With in this work by Wideman there exist numerous conflicts, protagonists, and antagonists. One of the main conflicts that occur throughout the novel is between Robby (the protagonist) and Institutions (the antagonist). (Abbott 55).
The institution as an antagonist represents many different places/ideas toc Robby. However the first and possibly most obvious conflict is between Robby and the law as an institution. Robby is faced with an immediate conflict with the law after he is originally arrested and placed in jail. There was a two-year period between Robby’s arrest and his sentence. This in itself is a conflict and shows institutions acting as the hero’s chief opponent. “Though his constitutional rights to a speedy trial and speedy sentencing had clearly been violated, neither those wrongs, nor any others…were brought to the attention of the Pennsylvania Supreme Court…” (Wideman 19). The conflict continues because the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania took three years to deny his appeal, and by that time Robby was already at Western State Penitentiary serving a life sentence. This section of the book is viewed as a conflict because it was a barrier that Robby was placed up against. This conflict never r...

... middle of paper ...

...cognized as the antagonist. That is not to say that Robby is our hero and institutions are the anti-hero, instead what that is saying is that the institution is the constant oppressor that Robby must continually fight against just to receive the rights he should be granted as a citizen. Robby faces and still is facing a daily battle against the institution to keep his humanity, self-dignity, and vigilance to go on living and fighting.

Works Cited
Abbot, Porter H. The Cambridge Introduction to Narrative. New York: Cambridge UP, 2009.
Print.

Wideman, John Edgar. Brothers and Keepers. New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston, 1984.
Print.

Wideman, John E. "From Brothers and Keepers to Two Cities Social and Cultural
Consciousness, Art and Imagination: An Interview with John Edgar Wideman." Interview by Jacqueline Berben-Masi. Callaloo 1999: 568-84. WSULIBS. Web.

Show More
Related

  • Wednesday Wars By Gary D. Schmidt: Literary Analysis

    891 Words  | 2 Pages

    First, the author uses conflict to show what the characters have to overcome throughout the course of the story, such as Mrs. Baker forcing Holling to do chores at school and

    Read More

  • Analysis Of Irwin's The Jail: Managing The Underclass In American Society

    1064 Words  | 3 Pages

    In the novel, The Jail: Managing the Underclass in American Society, Irwin claims that the jails are inhabited by individuals based on their offensive behaviors, and most importantly, based on their social status, notably being poor. “The public impression is that the jail holds a collection of dangerous criminals. But familiarity and close inspection reveal that the jail holds only a few persons who fit the popular conception of a crime…some students of the jail have politely referred to them as the poor” (Irwin 1). In Chapter one, Irwin describes what a jail entails. He explains that a jail is the foremost start into the criminal justice system. Those individuals placed in jails, normally do less than a year 's time in a jail. A jail is created for individuals who cannot make their bail, and most likely have committed a

    Read More

  • A&P by John Updike and Gryphon by Charles Baxter

    788 Words  | 2 Pages

    Two stories are brought together “A&P” and “Gryphon” to represent the struggles that every character faces. Sammy the main character in “A&P”, and Tommy the main character in “Gryphon” face a struggle that will put them to the test. For Sammy the struggle is, should he stand up to his boss and defend the girls or should he let it go. Tommy faces the conflict of, does he believe the substitute teacher and defend her against everyone else or does he follow what everybody else is doing. In their stories, Tommy and Sammy are put up against a conflict that they have never seen before, and their “job” is to decide what they should do and how they should approach the problem.

    Read More

  • A question of Freedom a Memoir of Learning, Survival, and Coming of Age in Prison by R. Dwayne Betts

    2042 Words  | 5 Pages

    In this critic, I will be analyzing and comparing two books. The first book is “A question of Freedom a Memoir of Learning, Survival, and Coming of Age in Prison” by R. Dwayne Betts. The second book is “Newjack: Guarding Sing Sing” by Ted Conover. In this comparison will first give a short summarization of both books. Second I will be answering the fallowing questions, what prisons are discussed? What types of prisoners are there- age, race, sex, level of crime? How current is the information? What are the conditions of the prisons? How are the prisoners treated? How are the guards and their viewpoints represented? How are the prisoners and their viewpoints represented? What forms of rehabilitation are there? What are the social relationships with other inmates? What opportunities are available to occupy prisoners? What point of view is the author taking – critical, Positive, does she/he write from the viewpoint of a guard, a prisoner? What evidence is/are the author’s points based on and how is the evidence presented - for example, first hand observations, Statistics? Also what changes, if any, are proposed or discussed by the author? How does the information in this book compare with what you’ve read in the text and articles and what you have observed on a class trip? Lastly what is your opinion of the information and viewpoint expressed in the book?

    Read More

  • Different Points of View and Beliefs in "The Chrysalids"

    515 Words  | 2 Pages

    Just because people within a family are blood related and living together, it does not mean they are identical in their beliefs and actions. In some cases the generations of people in the family have the same way looking at things and understand the same sets of rules and believe in same kind of moral behavior. Unlike that, in the novel, “The Chrysalids”, the protagonist, David Strorm and his father, Joseph, the antagonist have very different characters and conflicting points of view.

    Read More

  • Perspectives through Voices in Our Time by John Edgar Wideman

    667 Words  | 2 Pages

    Moreover, Wideman ends up having difficulties trying to represents what his brother is “saying” because he ends up writing his own personal opinions and thoughts. Although it was something he was trying to avoid considering it would be a manipulation of the story. Throughout the essay, the reader can observe how Wideman analyzes his past experiences with Robby, and how their relationship has transformed over the years. For instance, the author conveys the bonds he had with his brother in order to express that after all this years they still shared “common history, values, and style developed within the tall stockade of family, and that was enough to make us care about each other” (Wideman 674). In addition, he tells the reader how he wanted Robby to know that he was thinking about “Our shared roots and destiny” (Wideman 674) and how that thinking was getting him closer to Robby.

    Read More

  • The Hiding Place Quotes

    1676 Words  | 4 Pages

    2) What is the main conflict in the book? Is it external or internal? How is this conflict resolved throughout the course of the book?

    Read More

  • Deviance In Society: Wideman's Our Time

    1337 Words  | 3 Pages

    The story appears to be revolving around deviance. Deviance is defined as the violation of norms, whether the infraction is as grave as murder or as trivial as driving over the speed limit. However, what makes something deviant is not the act itself, but the reaction to the act. In this story, both Robby and John are deviants. John violated his society norms by doing something that is not expected of him. He became a scholar, married a white woman. This is not a bad thing in itself but the way John accomplished it is not good either. John pushed away his family and deliberately distanced himself from his Homewood community. This suggests that deviance is neutral in itself; it can be negative or positive. It is also relative, as it can be positive from one side and negative from the other. People often th...

    Read More

  • The Significance of Sibling Rivalry in Steinbeck's East of Eden

    1394 Words  | 3 Pages

    The struggle of sibling rivalry over ability and temperament has taken East of Eden in a whole new perspective. Steinbeck’s portrait on sibling rivalry shows the good vs. evil of each character in the story. The nature of good vs. evil as natural selection is also seen in siblings, as a compete for something physical, mental, or something emotional. The sibling rivalry from the biblical characters embraced Steinbeck’s characters throughout every concept in the novel, the good vs. evil confines the characters personality in every idea of Steinbeck’s novel. From the biblical story of Cain and Abel to Adam and Charles to Cal and Aaron the story continues through out every generation.

    Read More

  • The Society of Captives: A Study of a Maximum Security Prison

    1648 Words  | 4 Pages

    Gresham M. Sykes describes the society of captives from the inmates’ point of view. Sykes acknowledges the fact that his observations are generalizations but he feels that most inmates can agree on feelings of deprivation and frustration. As he sketches the development of physical punishment towards psychological punishment, Sykes follows that both have an enormous effect on the inmate and do not differ greatly in their cruelty.

    Read More

  • Summer of Wealth, Dreams and Desires in The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald

    736 Words  | 2 Pages

    These characters, however different they lie on the morality scale, all share the sinful trait of greed. They all ask, and take too much, ruining what the good that they had in their lives. Understanding their mistakes offers its useful readers a lesson, not to demand too much of the things we are offered. The characters struggle with their desires, each of them succombing to their passions.

    Read More

  • The Shawshank Redemption Prison: The Pros And Cons Of Prisons

    1212 Words  | 3 Pages

    The correctional system is based on helping offenders become part of society and not commit any crimes. Many prisons begin the correcting criminals since they are inside the jails, but many prisons do not. Prisons provide prisoners with jobs inside the prison where they get very little pay close to nothing and many have programs that will help them advance their education or get their high school diploma. There are various programs prisons provide to prisoners to help them get a job or have a skill when they are released from prison. In contrast, prisons that do not provide programs or help to prisoners rehabilitate and enter society again will be more likely to commit another crime and go back to jail. The Shawshank Redemption prison did not

    Read More

  • Sonny's Blues By James Baldwin Essay

    661 Words  | 2 Pages

    The eldest brother who is also the narrator of the story gives the reader a glimpse into their lives and the struggles that he and his younger brother Sonny go through. Through the narrators eyes Baldwin does a wonderful job showing how the brothers grew up to lead different lives but are both still struggling from the hold that poverty in Harlem has on them. Baldwin shows how both “the narrator and Sonny are both imprisoned and also free in exactly opposites ways” (spark note). For example, Sonny has physically been imprisoned due to his addiction to drugs but was able to escape from Harlem and create his own life through music. Whereas the narrator is physically free but trapped in the housing projects of Harlem which he clearly hates. It is Baldwin’s unique style of writing that has the characters asking themselves the question, “Does one embrace the hand that they are dealt in order to live or does one bow down and allow it to consume them?” Baldwin shows how each brother at different times in their life allowed for it to do both. For instance, in the beginning Sonny seemed to be consumed by his suffering which led him down the path of drugs but by the end he had embraced it and let his suffering playout through music. The narrator on the other hand seemed to embrace everything that he was dealt and did the best he could to better his life.

    Read More

  • Constraint

    684 Words  | 2 Pages

    Society has always had an influence on the way people think and act. Many beliefs and actions viewed as unique are many times shunned upon by members of society. This constraint on being an individual is explored in Gilman’s “The Yellow Wallpaper” and Joyce’s “The Boarding House.” Both authors show how society’s constraints put stress on individuals’ lives. In some cases this stress is good for the characters, but for some characters society’s constraints are too much.

    Read More

  • Revenge in Emily Bronte's Wuthering Heights

    743 Words  | 2 Pages

    There are many major themes of the book, but revenge is the most imminent theme, the factor that leads the protagonists to their dismal fate.  Bronte proves there is no peace in eternal vengeance, and in the end self-injury involved in serving revenge’s purposes will be more damaging than the original wrong.

    Read More

More about John Edgar's Brothers and Keepers: A Struggle Against the Prison Institution

Open Document