Justin Garcia's Trial

818 Words2 Pages

Ladies and gentlemen of the Jury. I am here to represent Justin Garcia, to prove the negligence of Jessica Nordeen. The law of negligence says that negligence occurs if an individual does something harmful that a person of ordinary intelligence would not do. In the next few moments,I will prove to the Jury that there was a breach of duty in the case of Garcia v. Nordeen.

Jessica is in fact guilty of negligence due to her actions which led Seth Garcia to suffer from Fetal Alcohol Syndrome due to the following reasons: In April of Jessica Nordeens senior year, she suspected that she might be pregnant. Gregory Buchner, Jessica’s doctor confirmed that she was indeed three months pregnant.

According to Jessica Nordeen’s Deposition, she mentioned that she looked over the pamphlet about drinking during pregnancy that Gregory Buchner gave to her, and she quoted “ Well, the Doctor gave me a pamphlet, and I kind of looked over it. I wasn’t too happy about being pregnant, so I wasn't very interested reading about it. I guess if you really want to have a baby, you want to know all about what's going on in there…I just knew that if I drank a lot, it might …show more content…

But since Jessica only contributes one hundred seventy five dollars per month, Justin Garcia is having a hard time looking for money for Seth’s expenses. We know that Jessica received inheritance from the sale of her deceased grandfather’s house. Justin is asking for half of the money to start a trust fund for Seth’s future expenses. Is it right for a mother to put her life back together with the inheritance she got, than helping her husband pay for the child’s needs for him to live a normal life and have a good future? Is it right to put herself first rather than her own kid, in which it was her fault in the first place due to her underage drinking during

More about Justin Garcia's Trial

Open Document