In Praise of Big Brother: Why We Should Learn to Stop Worrying and Love Government Surveillance

1896 Words4 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Surveillance and privacy

Part I:

James Stacey Taylor's article, "In Praise of Big Brother: Why We Should Learn to Stop Worrying and Love Government Surveillance" begins reviewing the concept of "Big Brother" as it was originally presented in George Orwell's 1984. The Big Brother started off as a fictional character in 1984-- a dictator of Oceania within a totalitarian state. Set within a society in which everyone is under complete surveillance by the authorities, mainly by telescreens, the people are constantly reminded of this by the phrase “Big Brother is watching you” (Wikipedia) . Taylor goes on to explain some examples of recent surveillance technology and how it is applied in lives today. An interesting note and comparison between today’s technology and that of the telescreens in 1984, is that people could be sure that they could not be watched by Big Brother’s telescreens by going out of the cities into the country, where they only had to take care that their conversations were not monitored by hidden microphones (Taylor 227). He contrasts the two, highlighting the fact that “Such an escape is not impossible, for spy satellites can be used to monitor people wherever they go” (277). From there, Taylor perpetuates the framework for his position on the Big Brother notion. Taylor argues that, "rather than opposing such an expansion of surveillance technology, its use should be encouraged -- and not only in the public realm" (227). Taylor’s argument presented in a more formal construction is as follows:

i. If is ever morally permissible for the State to secure information about past events, then it is morally permissible for it to do so through the use of surveillance devices.

ii. It is morally permissible for the State to secure information about...

... middle of paper ...

...d to the rights-based and consequentialist views could only help his argument be more whole or better-rounded.

Part IV:

Overall, I do agree with Taylor. Initially, I did not want to agree with or praise the idea of Big Brother. The idea of constant surveillance had me worried, but any worries I had, he had already thought of and thoroughly explained how privacy would be covered throughout different scenarios. Clearly, his logic is infallible, valid and all major concerns have been covered and accounted for within his article.

Works Cited

"Big Brother (Nineteen Eighty-Four)." Wikipedia, the Free Encyclopedia. Web. 07 June 2010. .

Taylor, James Stacey. "In Praise of Big Brother: Why We Should Learn to Stop Worrying and Love Government Surveillance." Public Affairs Quarterly July 2005: 227-246.

Show More
Related

  • Takeover of Technology in 1984 by George Orewell

    628 Words  | 2 Pages

    In a world filled with technology we must ask ourselves, is technology taking us closer to the world of Big Brother? In the novel 1984 by George Orewell, Orwell has generated this unbelievable world in which no one would ever think to be possible, but then again pondering upon it our worlds are quite similar, it is slightly alarming. It was not noticed till recently that perhaps our technology is pulling us closer to the world of Big Brother. The technology used in the novel 1984 are correlated to the technology we use currently.

    Read More

  • Privacy In Peter Singer's Possible Man

    1162 Words  | 3 Pages

    “With surveillance technology like closed-circuit television cameras and digital cameras now linked to the Internet, we now have the means to implement Bentham's inspection principle on a much vaster scale”(Singer) Bentham's inspection principle is a system that allows the collection, storing and dissemination of data on individuals, corporations, and the government. This collection of data has large implications in regard to privacy and security. “There is always danger that the information collected will be misused - whether by regimes seeking to silence opposition or by corporations seeking to profit from more detailed knowledge of their potential customers.”(Singer) What is done with the information collected is the main issue in terms of privacy. We do not want to be marketed to, or inundated with spam from third-party sources. We also do not want our private social circles and experiences to appear that they are being monetized or subjected to surveillance outside our control. In addition, surveillance has a large effect on the government that can beneficial or detrimental to democracy. Exposure of government secrets may make officials tread carefully when making decisions, ensuring that politicians are nothing but just and fair.“The crucial step in preventing a repressive government from

    Read More

  • Government Surveillance vs Privacy

    1439 Words  | 3 Pages

    Surveillance, however, is as old as man. Anthony Zurcher (2013) for the BBC said, “Chinese general Sun Tzu [in 544 - 496 BC] wrote…‘Enlightened rulers and good generals who are able to obtain intelligent agents as spies are certain for great achievements’" (Zurcher, 2013). Surveillance has been around for centuries.

    Read More

  • The NSA, Privacy and the War or Terrorism

    1550 Words  | 4 Pages

    Edward Snowden is America’s most recent controversial figure. People can’t decide if he is their hero or traitor. Nevertheless, his leaks on the U.S. government surveillance program, PRISM, demand an explanation. Many American citizens have been enraged by the thought of the government tracing their telecommunication systems. According to factbrowser.com 54% of internet users would rather have more online privacy, even at the risk of security (Facts Tagged with Privacy). They say it is an infringement on their privacy rights of the constitution. However, some of them don’t mind; they believe it will help thwart the acts of terrorists. Both sides make a good point, but the inevitable future is one where the government is adapting as technology is changing. In order for us to continue living in the new digital decade, we must accept the government’s ability to surveil us.

    Read More

  • Essay On Lack Of Privacy In 1984

    1567 Words  | 4 Pages

    Big Brother and modern day government have been able to control its citizens through surveillance equipment, and fear all for a little more power. There is much to learn from such an undesirable form of society, much like the one of Oceania in 1984. Examining Big Brother government closely, alarming connections can be made to real-world government actions in the United States and the cruel world within Orwell's book.

    Read More

  • Freedom And Security In George Orwell's 1984

    845 Words  | 2 Pages

    George Orwell’s Famous book 1984 is about a man who struggles to live under the superintendence of Big Brother. Throughout the novel, Winston struggles with constantly being surveilled and the lack of freedom. Similarly, in our world today, there are government agencies that have the power to listen to phone calls, track people's movements, and watch them through cameras. Winston’s world of surveillance and inadequate confidentiality both privately and publicly is in many aspects much the same as in our world today and the people should demand regulations to be set in place to protect their privacy.

    Read More

  • Analysis of George Orwell's 1984

    4217 Words  | 9 Pages

    ...ailed as a system of government. Perhaps in Orwell's socialist commentary he failed to take notice of the trends being embraced by capitalism. Behavioral psychology states that reward is a far greater incentive than punishment is a deterrent. In society today thought control is much more pleasant, subtle, and diverse than it was in Orwell's vision.The media, television, the internet, computer games, and movies serve to indoctrinate us into the norms of society in a way which is much more complex than Big Brother's propaganda. We are depoliticized, kept away from the real issues by superficial diversions, much like the proles. Big Brother may not exist, but his name is everywhere. Perhaps Aldus Huxley's Brave New World would have better served as a predictor of modern society's fall. Orwell predicted that the truth would be concealed and that what we hate will ruin us. Huxley thought that the truth would be drowned in irrelevance and that what we love will ruin us. Orwell's political commentary and philosophical issues are still relevant, but we live in a world far more complex than he could have ever predicted. Big Brother isn't watching. He doesn't need to. We're watching him.

    Read More

  • Persuasive Essay On Government Surveillance

    1761 Words  | 4 Pages

    Andrew Guthrie Ferguson thinks that people should be able to choose what areas they want to be secure from “physical and sense-enhancing invasion.” Another scholar, Joel Reidenbuerg, believes that current views of privacy do not fit well with the current technology, instead surveillance is dependent on “the nature of the acts being surveilled.” One more scholar, Chris Slobogin, believes that “the justification for a search should be roughly proportional to the intrusiveness of the search” (Hartzog, 2015). Point is, legal issues surrounding government surveillance is a complex topic without a perfect all-encompassing solution; each situation is different and should be treated

    Read More

  • Deotological Perspective of State Surveillance

    1737 Words  | 4 Pages

    The deontological ethical system, ethical formalism, articulates that what is considered moral is the motive or intent of the actor and not the consequence of the action (Pollock, 2012 pg 26). Philosopher Immanuel Kant states that the only thing that is good is good will, if a person does an act from good will; it can be considered moral action even if it results in bad consequences. Kant states that you should treat people as ends in themselves and not as only means to an end. In order to examine if governmental monitoring is ethical from a Kantian perspective, an examination of the why government is monitoring its citizens must be discussed.

    Read More

  • Summary: The California Electronic Communications Privacy

    466 Words  | 1 Pages

    In the novel this quote is using because Big Brother is checking every citizen and member of the party because he want to have control for everyone and he need to make sure that no one of the citizen try to reveal to him that is why he have telescreen in every where. The same thing is happening right now because citizen are complaining about how the NSA that represent “Big Brother” is collecting every information about then. “It appears that the police now have a device that can read license plates and check if a car is unregistered, uninsured or stolen. We already know that the National Security Agency can dip into your Facebook page and Google searches. And it seems that almost every store we go into these days wants your home phone number and ZIP code as part of any transaction.” People believe that we are living in the 1984, every student, high school teacher, college teacher, and every one who have read the novel could think that U.S is living in the 1984 because the novel is every accurate with everything that is happening right now with the NSA collecting everyone data but they also believe that is not only the NSA that is begging of all of this, also is the government because the NSA is only following the rules that the government says, the really “Big Brother” here is the government because they only are following the rule that he

    Read More

  • Privacy vs. Security

    1260 Words  | 3 Pages

    Most people concerned about the privacy implications of government surveillance aren’t arguing for no[sic] surveillance and absolute privacy. They’d be fine giving up some privacy as long as appropriate controls, limitations, oversight and accountability mechanisms were in place. ”(“5 Myths about Privacy”). The fight for privacy rights is by no means a recent conflict.

    Read More

  • That's My Tracker Analysis

    581 Words  | 2 Pages

    Throughout the years, technology has brought great advances and conveniences to humanity, but it also comes with a cost of privacy. Nations, Jobs, lives and families depend on the web for their security and prosperity, and we have all come to rely on these corporations to run our lives. Technology has taking over our viability, not just mentally, but physically. 1984 by George Orwell, tells of a society where the technology has superior control over people with no privacy at all. Big Brother is the technology they use to babysit their every move and our own ideation. A society like this seems bizarre, but today's society reflects this theme without us even knowing about it.

    Read More

  • Ethics of Surveillance

    1069 Words  | 3 Pages

    The world erupted in outrage following revelations by Edward Snowden regarding the extent of surveillance perform by the National Security Agency. Privacy becomes one of the hottest topic of 2013 and was chosen by the world’s most popular online dictionary, Dictionary.com, as the Word of the Year. However, the government is not the only one that conduct data gathering and surveillance. Employers often monitor their employees, and businesses collect data on theirs customer. The morality of these practices is a topic that generates heated debate.

    Read More

  • Summary: A Surveillance Society

    285 Words  | 1 Pages

    In the selection “A Surveillance Society” Thompson and Hickey used positive and negative approaches to deliver the information about the benefits and risks of high-tech surveillance. Surveillance is growing very rapidly in today’s technological world; and for once the US is not in first place in this category instead it is our mother country Great Britain. The government sees the benefits in this technology because it is a way to watch everyone for the citizens safety. For example, surveillance helps police to crack down on more traffic violations using cameras and computers to photograph a vehicles license’s plate. But even other wider government agencies use this surveillance; Total Information Awareness Program is used to prevent terrorism.

    Read More

  • Government Surveillance Pros And Cons

    858 Words  | 2 Pages

    Privacy is not just a fundamental right, it is also important to maintain a truly democratic society where all citizens are able to exist with relative comfort. Therefore, “[Monitoring citizens without their knowledge] is a major threat to democracies all around the world.” (William Binney.) This is a logical opinion because without freedom of expression and privacy, every dictatorship in history has implemented some form of surveillance upon its citizens as a method of control.

    Read More

More about In Praise of Big Brother: Why We Should Learn to Stop Worrying and Love Government Surveillance

Open Document