How Does Janie Come To Harmony Between Two Identities In Their Eyes Were Watching God

2998 Words6 Pages

The character Janie from Zora Neale Hurston’s Their Eyes Were Watching God showcases the unexpected ways in which a person’s various clashing identities can come to a state of harmony. By taking an active role in her dreams and desires, Janie creates a world where she can be wholly herself. However, two pieces of herself–her strong individualism in her connection with nature and community and her role as a loving wife to a mutually loving husband–only are able to converge at the end of the novel. The novel suggests that attaining harmony between these two seemingly conflicting identities comes to fruition through the uncontrollable force of God and his role in the death of marriage during its peak of love and happiness. From the story’s introduction, Janie expresses a desire for love and dreams of …show more content…

Janie struggles with fulfilling both of her identities. Being a wife in a loving marriage while expressing her authentic self simply doesn’t function as she loses the time and circumstances to connect with nature. By the end of the book, however, she can claim both identities because of God’s interference. We see this in two different instances where both Joe Stark and Tea Cake are killed by illness. Janie describes Death in a personified form as she does with all forces of nature: she says he “stands watchful and motionless all day with his sword drawn back, waiting for the messenger to bid him come. Been standing there before there was a where, a when, or a then. She was liable to find a feather from his wings lying in her yard any day now,” (84). In this case, Death takes action after receiving a message or otherwise an order from someone who can be assumed to be God, considering Death has been there since before the completion of all creation, such as the concepts of time and place. Janie recognizes the intentionality of death and through this, the intention of the early deaths in the

Open Document