Wait a second!
More handpicked essays just for you.
More handpicked essays just for you.
Fall of the Han and Roman dynasty
Decline and collapse of the roman empire and han empire
Fall of Han and Rome
Don’t take our word for it - see why 10 million students trust us with their essay needs.
Recommended: Fall of the Han and Roman dynasty
The Decline of the Han Dynasty
Digvijay Naruka
History 131
Dr. Peifer
November 23, 2014
Han Empire was certainly one of the biggest empires, easily comparable to the Roman Empire. It was China’s longest lasting empire that reigned for over four centuries. They had a strong military, improved the Great Wall of China, and introduced an examination system to join government. Moreover, Han’s achieved success in politics, trade, and technology became the base of many modern inventions. The fall of the Han Empire was a result of long lasting damage that happened over time. It became politically unstable. Another reason for their fall was migration. Finally, the revolts severely weakened the empire. Therefore one can see that the Han Empire
…show more content…
fell because of political instability, migration, and revolts. One of the main reasons for the decline of the Han dynasty was political instability. During the period of later Han, a period of quick succession of young Emperors began, one as young as two years old. Because of this, the old tradition of appointing Empresses as regent for the prince started once again. Empress Dowager, as they were called, would then assign a male relative as the head, because of their limited outings, to keep check on the empire. As a result, most of the power shifted towards the relatives of the empresses, who took positions as government officials. They used this power to increase their own wealth instead of the good of the empire. As was the case during the reign of Hwan Ti, as mentioned in the book, The Imperial History of China, The brother of Queen Dowager Liang, exercised major power in the empire. He was given a huge territory to control along with the revenue that came with it. Emperor Hwan Ti also appointed Liang-Ki, brother of Queen Dowager, as his prime minister. All this power only managed to increase his arrogance that he had the audacity to appear in court with his sword on, which was considered a serious offense, for which he was still forgiven. If this was not enough, he continuously abused his powers and became the reason for the miseries within the empire because of his misrule and excessive exactions (Macgowan, p-124). While the relatives of the Empress were busy in their power hungry benefits, another group of people, eunuchs, gained highest power within the government and had great influence over the decisions of the emperor. They had titles that gave them considerable control over parts of the empire. They also corrupted the government by setting up government positions by inheritance or by selling the positions to the highest bidder instead of the qualified acquiring the position as set by the earlier emperors. Eunuchs were the cause of great riots and massacres during the Han Dynasty. When they saw that they were in danger of being discovered or saw that someone was a threat to their authority, they either gave a fake order or persuaded the emperor in eliminating the threat. All of this proves that political instability was a cause that played an important role in the fall of the Han Dynasty. Migration also led to the fall of the Hans.
As Sophia mentions in her article that “… the migration, due to a variety of causes, of the ethnic Han population of northern China towards the south: created a general disorder that had not been experienced during the Western Han…” (Psarras, p-22). The causes of this migration were not instantaneous, and eventually led to the fall of Han. For example, some of the Emperors of the Han dynasty wanted nothing but luxurious lifestyle, and spent a huge amount of empire’s treasury during the economic crisis. Moreover, the court and the huge army that was defending the empire against nomadic tribes on the borders put a huge strain on the empire’s economy. In order to fund these armies and construction of fortresses, the government imposed high taxes. Because of these changes, peasants suffered the most as they were forced to work on constructing these fortresses, and were required to do forced labor for a month. Moreover, the high taxes imposed on them further increased their suffering. While the peasants were suffering, the aristocratic families had attained the hold of the large estates of the country, bought government positions, and used bribery to gain special influence with the eunuchs. They paid insignificant taxes, and easily protected their wealth by using the influence of their position as government officials. With the increasing power of the aristocratic family, the central government found it extremely difficult to maintain an effective defense against nomadic raids, which forced them to impose ever increasing taxes on the peasants. These unbearable tax burdens, along with the compulsory labor, forced the peasants to migrate towards the south. The result of this was very low tax revenue, which created a disorder in the empire, and crumbled the empire economically. Besides the migration of peasants to south, high number of revolts also led to the decline of
Han. Rebellions was also a factor that added to the fall of the Han Dynasty. While the Han dynasty was facing economic crises, another problem arose. There were several natural disasters, which weakened the already crumbling Han economy. The government was unable to offer its people with food, water, and relief support. Besides the already mistrust in the government, the new danger of disasters confirmed people’s belief that the Han dynasty had lost their Mandate of Heaven. This gave rise to a rebel faction called the “Yellow Turbans.” They revolted against the Han government, destroying and looting government offices and towns. As mentioned on a website called Kongming, “Although initial operations against the rebels resulted in setbacks and defeat, the uprising was quelled and the major leaders killed within nine months. However, the Han military and the power of the state were severely weakened. Many properties were destroyed and the loss of life on both sides was immense” (Jiang Zhi, para - 7). Because of these rebellions, the already weakened Han government did not have the resources and the man power to protect the borders from the external forces, which led to the eventual downfall of the empire. One can conclusively state therefore that the Han Empire fell because of political instability, migration, and revolts. The administrative power of the empire became unstable. People relocated to the south which brought about further instability. Finally, revolts also gravely destabilized the Han Empire. The weakening of the government along with the revolts put the empire in a state of chaos that led to the period similar to the warring states.
Han civilization declined for two reasons, internal dispute and foreign invasions. In the empire bureaucrats were competing for power and this caused crime to happen. Landowners rebelled against paying taxes witch caused peasants taxes to increase, landowners started privately making armies, and farmers were forced into enslavement. A clear sign of the collapse in the central state was
The Han Dynasty and Roman Empire existed around the same time period and both lasted around 400 years. They each had large populations (around 50 million), conquered enemies they felt as a threat, wanted to spread their boundaries and had strong militaries. The Han Dynasty, located in China, was built on other dynasties such as the Qin and Zhou. The Great Wall of China was built during
Both Han China and Rome had to deal with a weakening government, which in both cases led to landlords ruling over the peasants. The landlords' demands were added to the heavy taxes peasants also had to pay, leading to extreme poverty. The two civilizations faced declining cultural innovation, caused by scholars not creating
Han – a period of time in China in which the country was merge together (Dictionary)
The Han Dynasty and the Roman Empire were two grand empires that rose out of preexisting territories and provided relative peace over wide areas. The collapse of the Qin Dynasty (221-206 BCE), which was the first great land-based empire in East Asia, came after a period of war, confusion, and tyrannical rule. Due to the political disorder that stemmed from the early dynastic activity, the emergence of the Han Dynasty (206 BCE- 228 CE) sprung to focus on restoring order. On the other hand, the rise of the Roman Empire (44 BCE- 476 CE) originated from consolidating authority over aristocratic landlords and overriding the democratic elements of the earlier Republic. Instead, the Roman Empire redefined the concept of “citizen” as subjects to the Roman emperor. Both empires shared similar agendas to exploit their vast territories and resources, which helped them expand their political dominance; however, despite having similar political goals and foundations, their government system, cultural ideologies and imperial expansionist natures diverged.
Han China and Ancient shared bureaucratic governments. This means that they had a government ruled by unelected officials, giving the people little to no say in government. In Rome the ruler was once a king but then their government transitioned to an oligarchy, which would put the rich people in the highest place in society. On the other hand in Han China, which was an imperial dynasty, and emperors were decided by the Mandate of Heaven. The Mandate gave the common man a chance to become a major ruler during the Han period. The Han government was mainly influenced by confucian government while Romes was based on Roman law and the classics. The Han government spread Confucianism since that was the basis for their government. Rome also relied on local rulers to make sure that their many lands were following rules and not plotting against them. Both the Han and Rome shared a bureaucratic government which affected their social structures in different ways.
The Han Dynasty was established in 221 BCE by the rebel leader of the peasants, Liu Bang. Religion not only played a role in the Han dynasty’s rise, but also in their fall through conversion. On the other side of the spectrum, the Roman Empire between 33 and 300, were also undergoing change through religious beliefs. Similarly, both the Han dynasty and the Roman Empire were built by a spread of religious beliefs. In my opinion, religion is the most significant difference between the Roman Empire and the Han Dynasty China based on its effects on the political rule and nature of political authority during both eras. Religion is the most significant difference because societal practices and power structure of the two eras stem from the different beliefs. The Han Dynasty is built up from the spread of Confucianism. The Roman Empire is built up from the spread of Christianity. The two religion’s
In the Classical Era, the collapse of the Roman Empire was similar to the collapse of the Han Dynasty in that they both fell due to external and internal conflict. However, they differed in that the Roman Empire became politically and culturally fragmented while the Han Dynasty was reconstituted as a political and cultural whole.
The Han dynasty and the Roman Empire were both powerful empires during their era. However, the ways they obtained their power varied greatly because they used different methods that involved their political structures, which revolved around their centralized governments. The Han dynasty and the Roman Empire acquired very unique techniques that allowed them to control social and political. For example, the Han dynasty adopted a religion known as Confucianism, which monitored everything in the lives of the Chinese. Contrary, the Roman Empire established a monarchy but allowed its residents more freedom as compared to the Han. Nevertheless, the two empires were similar in political structures in that the power was depended on the wealthy that were in authority, the peasants struggled with their lives because of concerning issues such as food supply. The empires were able to create and preserve a peaceful and sustainable lives for a long time, unlike the past empires. Social distribution were under the control of the wealthiest and they could effortlessly impact community viewpoints and interactions among the residents. These two empires existed during the Classical Period had comparable and various social, political, religions, as well as economical values and practices. However, they both possessed differences and similarities in their economic and social perspectives even though the two empires were established around the same era.
Now you are probably wondering with all these similar factors that lead to the demise of the empires, how did China recover successfully? The Chinese empire unlike the Roman empire, held on to their cultural identity and tried not to accept diversity in cultures. This is also called cultural homogeneity. Cultural homogeneity create a sense of togetherness. This creates less organization and religious drama. China also had more advanced technological breakthroughs in the fields of agriculture and metallurgy. This is needed to progress and recover so you have ways of keeping up with the economy. The Chinese empire also had one common religion that mostly held up. Confucianism. Having mostly the same religion unifies most people, which is also needed for a recovery. With these main factors, the Chinese empire recovered successfully.
The Han wall was built as a cultural icon and a physical force. It was also the longest dynasty, lasting four hundred and twenty two years. The Han are the ones that restored the Confucian literature to China, established a strong central government, and set up the first public school system! The Han, being the builders of the second portion of the Great Wall extended and restored the Qin wall 300 miles into the Gobi desert.
Han – a period of time in China in which the country was merge together (Dictionary)
Maybe because Han had a more evenhanded ruling style and was not afraid of the enemy like Qin who had several attempts made on his life, Han did not focus a lot on his army. While both
In the early fifth century due to the weak Sui dynasty (561-617). The Emperor taxed heavy on its citizens and forced them to build large monuments and buildings with little to no pay. Many people as a result of this hard labor died. Fed up with heavy taxation and forced labor, rebellions occurred trough out Sui China and put the emperor to its grave 618. That same year Li Yuan, who was a Sui Governor in a Chinese province, later became emperor Gaozu of Tang declared himself ruler of the new Tang Dynasty. During his eight year reign, he united parts of China, relaxed harsh laws and promoted trade. After his retirement his son Li Shimin became the next Emperor of the Tang. He was also known as Emperor Taizong. During the reign of Emperor Taizong, China flourished economically and militarily. After his death, China enjoyed prosperity and peace brought about the soil faction of imperial protection over the Chinese regions.1 Also for the first time in this time period , China had trade relations with Yamato Japan. China also had strong diplomatic relations with the western world for the first time. In 674 the Sassanid Persian royal house fled the advancing Arab army and arrived in the Tang capital, Chang’an. Which became the most populist city in the world at the time, with two million
The Ming Dynasty had created an empire. They had the government, the military, and the economic system to prove it. At different points in time, The Chinese Empire was the greatest in the world, for trade, military, and other key factors in a society.