How Are Nick And Jay Gatsby Alike

668 Words2 Pages

In the Great Gatsby, written by F. Scott Fitzgerald, Nick Carraway, the narrator, describes the summer he spent in West Egg with a man, Jay Gatsby, whose grasp on time and reality is a little loose. Over the time he spent in West Egg, Nick became very close to Gatsby. One critic compared the two in the following way: “Nick’s mind is conservative and historical, as is his lineage; Gatsby’s is radical and apocalyptic – as rootless as his heritage. Nick is too immersed in time and reality; Gatsby is hopelessly out of it. Nick is always withdrawing, while Gatsby pursues the green light. Nick can’t be hurt, but neither can he be happy. Gatsby can experience ecstasy, but his fate is necessarily tragic.” This statement can be proven and defended because …show more content…

One obvious similarity is that both men live in the same neighborhood, West Egg. West Egg, the lesser or two neighborhoods, is the neighborhood for the lower and middle class. The other neighborhood, East Egg, is the neighborhood for wealthy and old money folk. Although Gatsby is very rich and not of the middle class, he is not of old money, which means he did not inherit his fortune. Which means that unlike the Buchanans, Gatsby earned his money by working for it. And although Nick is of old money, he is not as wealthy as his cousin Daisy. Another similarity between Nick and Gatsby is that both men are striving to achieve their American Dream, the idea that anyone can achieve success and prosperity through hard work and …show more content…

One difference is how the two men accumulate the money or make their money. Gatsby became rich because after he went to Oxford, he met Wolfsheim and became a bootlegger. Nick on the other hand went into the stock marketing business and although he is not as rich as Gatsby, with hard work, he's well on his way to achieving his American dream. Another difference is that although Nick is conservative, Gatsby is radical and can experience ecstasy. This means that while Nick is always withdrawing, Gatsby pursues the green light. Nick describes Gatsby to have an “extraordinary gift for hope, a romantic readiness such as I have never found in any other person and which it is not likely I shall ever find again.” (Fitzgerald, 2). And although this displays Gatsby as a hopeful dreamer, Gatsby’s determination to pursue his green light, or Daisy, causes his fate to become necessarily tragic. Another difference between the two is that Nick's grasp of reality sets him apart from Gatsby. The critic describes that Nick is too immersed in time and reality while Gatsby is hopelessly out of it. This is shown when Nick tells Gatsby that he cannot repeat the past and Gatsby replies "Can't repeat the past? ... Why of course you can." (Fitzgerald, 116). Believing that he can recapture certain elements of his past, Gatsby truly thinks that he can re-create scenes of his life and genuinely repeat the past. But in chapter 5 when he knocks over

Open Document