Holmberg's Mistake By Charles Mann Summary

1040 Words3 Pages

As children, students are taught from textbooks that portray Native Americans and other indigenous groups as small, uncivilized, mostly nomadic groups with ways of life that never changed or disfigured the land. Charles Mann’s account of Indian settlements’ histories and archaeological findings tell us otherwise. Mann often states in his book 1491: New Revelations of the Americas before Columbus that the indigenous groups of North and South America were far more advanced and populous than students are taught. He focuses on many different cultural groups and their innovations and histories that ultimately led to either their demise or modern day inhabitants. Mann’s biggest point, I believe, is that the Indian settlements he studied were much more civilized than grade school textbooks make them out to be. For instance, in the introduction, ‘Holmberg’s Mistake,’ Mann tells his readers about how Holmberg misinformed the world about the Sirionó being a tribe without history or common sense when they were, in fact, a highly populated tribe that flourished before diseases wiped them out. Another misconception is how North American natives roamed the land in small groups to hunt, fish, and gather their food. They actually were much more settled and even had better …show more content…

His book clears the smoke from our eyes of the stereotypes of indigenous populations, their cities, and their cultures. Through reading this book, we find that natives were so far advanced that most of their inventions and discoveries still hold true today. The book also proves to us that textbooks are not always the best resources, even though we have relied on them since public education systems became the norm. Mann’s recount of his studies have opened up a world of more civilized, intelligent, and useful depictions of Indigenous populations and flourishing cities throughout North and South

Open Document