Holden's Phony

927 Words2 Pages

Victor Migliorino Mr. Chomin English Grade-10 6/9/2024 The thought of growing up can be a very exciting thing for some people, but for others it can be scary, but that doesn't change the fact we all have to do it some time. In J.D. In Salinger’s book The Catcher In The Rye, we see these fears through the main character of the story, Holden Caulfield. This story takes place in New York after Holden gets kicked out of his prep school. Leading him to live on the streets for a while so he doesn't have to face his parents. This book is all about Holden's struggles with refusing to grow up and his fears of people he's closest to losing their innocence to the cruel adult world, as well as his struggles with mental health and loneliness after being …show more content…

Holden frequently talks bad about the adult world for being fake and insincere. He calls these people “phonies”. One example is when he talks about his brother D. B. who now writes for Hollywood, “Now he’s out in Hollywood, D.B., being a prostitute” (page, 2). Holdens disrespect for adults is also shown when he is observing people in the bar which he lied about his age to get into, “People always clap for the wrong things” (page, 84). This shows that Holden is deeply troubled by the insincerity he sees in the adult world. His harsh judgments and constant need to point out people he thinks are “phonies” are his way of trying to protect himself from becoming what he hates, but while doing all this criticizing he doesn't realize that he's already started to become what he hates. Holden’s constant need to find realness shows he’s scared of losing his innocence and becoming what he hates. This supports the themes of fear of growing up, loss of innocence, and mental health by showing how upset he is with the world. His criticism of people is his way of ignoring his situation and his struggles and what he is …show more content…

Salinger shows how hard it is for Holden to grow up, the loss of innocence, and dealing with his mental health. I feel that the author did a decent job at showing some of these themes through the story but I do think there were a lot of relationships and a lot of repeating situations and some of the dialogue feels the same for some characters but other than that i think it was ok. Overall, The Catcher In The Rye is a decent book about the difficulties of life after school and the acceptance of growing up. It makes me think how difficult it can be for people to stay true to themselves in a world where more often than not it feels fake. Holdens story shows how complicated the road ahead might be, but it doesn't change the fact that we all have to go through it

Open Document