Holden Caulfield In Nothing Gold Can Stay

616 Words2 Pages

Holden faces many challenges in his life, including being kicked out of school, not feeling accepted, and most upsettingly the death of his brother, Allie. Similarly to the parting of Allie, Robert Frost reminds the audience that their world is engulfed in grief which is symbolized through nature. Nature embodies similar feelings of grief that Holden undertakes. Through comparing the imagery in “Nothing Gold Can Stay” by Robert Frost to events that happen to Holden Caulfield in J.D Salinger’s Catcher in the Rye, readers explore how tragedy impacts a person's life. Throughout Catcher in the Rye, Holden Caulfield attempts to hold on to his innocence that he had in his childhood. However, his experiences with classmates, the loss of his brother and situations similar to the one with Mr. Attolini, do not allow his spirit to remain innocent. Holden struggles to grasp what is left of his innocent childhood like it was gold, but as Frost explains, “Nothing gold can stay” (line 8). Childhood innocence is so valuable, but as the reader sees in Holden’s case, …show more content…

Frost brings this concept of temporary happiness and beauty to life in this quote, “Her early leaf’s a flower; / But only so an hour” (line 3-4). The image of a flower dying shortly after its bloom unites with the story of Allie and his unfortunate death. Allie’s time with Holden was limited, but it was part of the natural process that exists in everyone's life. The time when Allie was alive was filled with happiness, but when he departed Holden was faced with a feeling of emptiness. The allusion “Eden sank to grief” also implies a similar message. Eden fell to sadness when sin entered the world just as when Allie died, Holden entered into a time of deep despair. These quotes show reminders of how time passes and how people must continue our lives dealing with

Open Document