Wait a second!
More handpicked essays just for you.
More handpicked essays just for you.
Critical analysis trifles
The importance of critical analysis
Critical Reflection & Analysis
Don’t take our word for it - see why 10 million students trust us with their essay needs.
Recommended: Critical analysis trifles
Hi Marcos,
1. I really enjoyed reading your draft. I think you have good examples that support what you have to say in your essay, and also how you organize your points is easy to follow and understand.
Base 1: Unity
1. Yes, there is a clearly stated thesis in the introductory paragraph, which said “The documentary uses respected women in a political stance or publicized figure…to draw out emotion from the viewers to side with their stance.” I think if the thesis statement is written in one or two sentences, it would be simpler to get your point.
2. Yes, all the supporting paragraphs back up the thesis. The examples are detailed, and they support the thesis well.
Base 2: Support
1. Yes, there is specific evidence. I like how you come up your idea with the explanation on how the author of the documentary uses various methods to support the issue.
…show more content…
Yes, there is plenty of it, and the supporting points are explained in sequence.
Base 3: Coherence
1. Yes, there is a clear method of organization. The three different points that you mention in the introductory paragraph are stated separately in each paragraph.
2. Yes, transitions are used to connect sentences and ideas, such as “Another aspect” or “Lastly.” I see various transitions that are used properly in your essay, and they help to connect your ideas well.
Base 4: Sentence Skills
1. I don’t think there are rough spots where the sentences do not flow smoothly and clearly, and most of them seem clear to understand, especially the body paragraphs.
2. I don’t see any mistakes in grammar, punctuation, or usage.
Overall, your draft seems great. I like how your points are stated clearly and explained smoothly according to the topic, and I also like how you have concluded your idea. Thank you.
Hi Ra,
I really enjoyed reading your draft. I like how you organize the points about your idea. Your explanation of what the author has to say in the documentary is easy to understand as
2. Your conclusion paragraph should be more detailed. Restate in just a few sentences the points that you made in your paper and what conclusions you have drawn from those points.
...sition. For example, you could spend a paragraph on Jack's transition from a boy unwilling to kill a pig, to savagely killing the mother pig to killing Simon and Piggy and finally to hunting Ralph. Then you could spend another paragraph on Jack's transition from acting as a rule-abiding member of the group to leaving the group and finally to taking over the group. You could also, spend a paragraph discussing Jack's physical transition, from the school-boy uniform at the beginning of the novel to the savage beast hiding behind the mask at the end of the novel. Organizing your paper in this fashion allows you to separate and discuss each aspect of Jack's transition clearly and thoroughly.
With an evident attempt at objectivity, the syntax of Passage 1 relies almost entirely on sentences of medium length, uses a few long sentences for balance, and concludes with a strong telegraphic sentence. The varying sentence length helps keep the readers engaged, while also ensuring that the writing remains succinct and informative. Like the varying sentence length, the sentence structures vary as complex sentences are offset by a few scattered simple sentences. The complex sentences provide the necessary description, and the simple sentences keep the writing easy to follow. Conversely, Passage 2 contains mostly long, flowing sentences, broken up by a single eight word sentence in the middle. This short sentence, juxtaposed against the length of the preceding and following sentences, provides a needed break in the text, but also bridges the ideas of the two sentences it falls between. The author employs the long sentences to develop his ideas and descriptions to the fullest extent, filling the sentences with literary elements and images. Coupled...
What I learned rather quickly was that these very questions were all apart of why the assignment was given. What at first seemed to be a pointless exercise really answered these questions in a profound way which I want to share with you today. My hope is that you too get a renewed appreciation for writing and it’s history.
NOTE: This isn’t even close to how I would like the essay to be laid out. I’m just writing paragraphs and eventually I will get them in an order I like them and revise.
Chief Manuelito born in 1818 and died in 1893, was a known Navajo war chief during the late 1800’s. Manuelito led a group of warriors to fight against the oppression of the United States military. In contradiction of having the Navajo People removed and forced to walk to Bosque Redondo, NM during the long walk in 1864, Manuelito led a group of warriors to battle. He and other Navajo people hid in the Chuska Mountains to avoid being captured and to forcibly walk to New Mexico. He believed the Navajo people are to remain within the four sacred mountains and should not cross the three rivers. However, the group of people who continued to stay within the area began to encountered hunger and surrendered. During the confinement, Chief Manuelito
Aaron, good job. I thought that a lot of your discussion was interesting, though I agree with Gen that there were some issues, especially the lack of original research, To which I’d add that you didn’t.
Nice job on this, Alex. I like the thesis, and it is developed well, but it isn’t that terribly complex. It didn’t flow that well in the beginning, but it got better. Very clear, but style and higher-level thinking will help you get to the A zone. clarity: A-, thesis development: B, evidence: B+, style: B-, convention: B. overall: B
By dissecting the film, the director, Jennie Livingston's methodology and the audience's perceived response I believe we can easily ignore a different and more positive way of understanding the film despite the many flaws easy for feminist minds to criticize. This is in no way saying that these critiques are not valid, or that it is not beneficial to look at works of any form through the many and various feminist lenses.
...e. The absence of counter claims to many of his arguments while being supported makes the argument suspect. Adding with that some logical fallacy errors and phrases indicating guesswork without evidence and his thesis loses further ground. Looking at the article overall the argument is semi convincing depending on whether the reader agreed with him or did not before they read the article. If coming from the same viewpoint the argument is likely effective in further convincing them, however if coming from a different viewpoint the ineffective aspects of the argument coupled with a few potentially insulting phrases are unlikely to convince the reader.
The style of the essay changes tone from the first four paragraphs which leans toward a formal style; the formality is mainly due to the lack of “I” statements and first person point of view. The conclusion paragraph switches to a less formal almost conversational tone. ...
...rds to the research question. Overall however, I believe this was a good start to performing a study on this interesting and important topic.
There were some minor errors (mostly punctuating complex sentences) that I highlighted; none of them impeded meaning. Review the handout or ask me if you are confused about those complex sentences with the dependent clauses. Regardless, and I think I’ve told you this before, you have a passionate and clear rhetoric that makes your writing engaging to read.
Throughout this fall semester, I have learned many things. Before this class, I have never had to buckle down and plan out my writing so tediously. The many outlines, rough drafts, and final drafts have crafted me into a much better writer than I would have ever expected to become. While I have always considered English as one of my strong subjects, through this class I have learned that English has many more components than I originally thought. One of the most substantial of these components is a transitional sentence and through this class and the writing practice it has brought me, I have learned how to properly write them.
To begin I want to thank all of you for your cooperation and participation in helping me complete this assignment. I know how important your time is and I appreciate you giving me a few minutes of it.