Helen Nagel's The Miracle Worker

654 Words2 Pages

The Miracle Worker

When pondering on life as not only a blind child but also a deaf child, one might say perception of the world and life is impossible. In the movie The Miracle Worker, Helen Keller was blind, deaf and mute since she had been a baby. Helen was incapable of communicating to anyone. The question, “do you think she had an accurate idea of color,” to me, is defined through her inability to know the difference between colors and physical appearance on objects certain colors, for instance the sun being yellow. Because Helen was blind and deaf, she could not actually see the color pink or yellow I can see. Helen had never actually seen color; therefore an accurate idea of a color is nearly impossible.
Being blind or deaf would be very difficult, as the person who is blind has no way of visualizing the current world they live in, and being deaf, one cannot hear about the world. In the book What is it like to be a bat by Thomas Nagel, Nagel states an idea that without experience we cannot comprehend nor be conscious of what the world is truly like. Nagel believes that, “without some idea, therefore, of what the subjective character of experience is, we cannot know what is required of a physicalist theory” (Nagel, 1974, 437). Nagel is saying that without having any experience, one cannot fully know physical or mental truth. As Nagel explains the lifestyles of bats, it helps justify the outlook humans have on life in comparison. As a human, we cannot comprehend the reality of a bat, we cannot see what they see or hear what they hear unless we actually do see it instead of just assuming. It ‘s like a deaf and blind child to a child who is neither, reality is different, and they only know as much as they have learned throug...

... middle of paper ...

...hen she is let out of the black and white room or given a color television, she will learn what it is like to see something red,”(Jackson, 2012, pg. 281-282), which describes a woman who lives in a black-and-white room. In comparison, this helps me believe that Helen has not experienced colors being blind; therefore Helen cannot possess the ideas of any color in her mind because she has yet to experience it.
I think that Helen cannot see the accurate colors we can perceive. It is because of my own perception that I can actually see colors in the world. If I were blind I could never visualize the color pink that someone who can actually see, would. Helen for instance, had been blind since she was born, meaning Helen had never seen an accurate color in reality, nor could she fully imagine what a color looks like. Helen’s inexperience with colors justifies my belief.

Open Document