Healing And Autonomy Case Study

1342 Words3 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Importance of culture in health care settings

Instruction What affects peoples’ view on health status, treatment, and healing processes? When people face, the situations associated with sickness, death, spiritual and emotional distress, they are questioning their existence, purpose, and faith. The perspective through which they are looking for the answers depends on peoples’ worldview and beliefs. People’s behavior, decision making, the living path influenced by moral and ethical principles, society rules, religious values and beliefs. Christian Biblical Narrative principles (creation, fall, redemption, and restoration), affect people’s perception, reflecting a significant message set by God (GCU, 2017). Every person through long life path, seeking the purpose of own life, reasons of
The family in the case includes Mike and Joanne (parents) and James and Samuel (identical twin boys). James, one of the twin brothers admitted to the hospital with acute glomerulonephritis, and kidney failure, that caused by a streptococcus infection. Initially, James was brought to the hospital by his parents, due to acute glomerulonephritis, and his condition was exacerbated by concomitant symptoms, such as an elevated blood pressure and fluid overloaded in his system. Thus, the physician recommended an immediate dialysis as a first line treatment. Parents faced the situation, where they had to choose the treatment plan care. Mike and Joanne had a great bond with religion, which was affecting the decision making regarding James treatment. Next, Mike and Joanne struggled with a rough and challenging dilemma, what would benefit James health status? They tensed between trusting their son’s life into Gods hands or follow the traditional medical treatment. Based on previous experience, when they saw in their Church, how the person after stroke regained the mobility, after pastors pray, they refused the dialysis, and decided to rely on spiritual healing. It didn’t do the magic and James condition deteriorated, and after the evaluation, parents were told, that James needed the kidney transplantation. The ideal donor candidate was his twin
For centuries, there been a complicated relationship between medicine and Christianity. For long time Christian engaged in medicine practice in religious approach and involved in healing by Gods will and allowance. There been many burdens within spiritual healing process and modern medicine treatments. Christian relied on praying, using natural remedies, fasting and blessings (Porterfield, 2005).
Faith issue and controversy with medicine, can be seen in Mike and Joanne’s decision to postpone the dialysis and relying on their faith in God. Their faith and hope was growing on recently seeing the neighbor of a community healed in the process of a pastor pray service. It enhanced their hope, that James may be blessed with the same faith

Show More
Related

  • Chimerix’s Decision to Grant an Experimental Drug to a Terminal Patient

    2991 Words  | 6 Pages

    Josh Hardy of Virginia struggled with health issues throughout his young life. After his most recent bone marrow transplant in January 2014, he was unable to recover and lay hospitalized with an adenovirus. The rare experimental medicine is not available in hospitals like St. Jude which he is in. The life-saving medication is only carried by a specialized company called Chimerix. The drug Brincidofovir has not yet been released by the Food and Drug Administration to the public yet. Chimerix previously had a “compassionate care” program that enabled those in medical need to request Brincidofovir and they were granted with the drug, however Chimerix recently strayed away from this program and sought to take time and work on the development and advancement for the drug to be made publicly available. It will not be until approximately the year 2016 that the drug will be released on the market. The issue remains that a life threatening issue like Josh’s cannot wait two more years. Chimerix’s initial and later actions are key factors in determining whether the company follows the Benedictine faith, keeping their values correctly aligned in the light of Christian values. Chimerix’s was able to display the Benedictine principles in their company when they decided to grant Josh with the experimental drug, but their initial decision corrupted the morality of the company.

    Read More

  • Medical Saints: Cosmas and Damian in a Postmodern World

    1333 Words  | 3 Pages

    The relationship of science and spirituality can be a debate that many people have conceptualized. Jacalyn Duffin’s uses her historian and physician background to lead her to an important exploration of medical saints who spark miracles in the postmodern world that contribute to her three main observations. Duffin studies why physicians ignore miracles and prayer, why are miracles mostly about illness, and Comas and Damian in Toronto. Her personal scholarly experiences along with her first-hand observation with miraculous cure influence her work and accomplishments with “Medical Saints: Cosmas and Damian in a Postmodern World”. The book leaves the reader with a idea and understanding of the concepts Duffin studies to further develop the authority so more contributions can be made for this field. This book will give the reader an idea of these medical saints and how it is significant in the postmodern world today.

    Read More

  • Terry Tempest Williams' Refuge

    1924 Words  | 4 Pages

    Weaver, Andrew J. and Kevin J. Flannelly. “The Role of Religion/Spirituality for Cancer Patients and Their Caregivers.” Southern Medical Journal 97 (December 2004): pp. 97-98. 1210-1214. Spiegel, David. The 'Standard'.

    Read More

  • Kant Vs Mill on the Issue of Lying

    1763 Words  | 4 Pages

    Firstly, by looking at the first patient, whether she gets a kidney from her father or a “cadaver kidney” , there will be no difference because she needs a kidney nonetheless. The second patient however, cannot agree to give his kidney away because one of the main reasons is that he’s scared and lacks “the courage to make this donation”9. So right at this point, it can be seen that it would be better if the father didn’t give his kidney away because it wouldn’t cause him any happiness, whereas the daughter has two options to gIn everyday life, whether on a personal base or on a professional base, difficult scenarios, or also known as moral dilemmas, are present. Depending on whom the person is or what their belief and value systems are, the issue can be ‘resolved’. In this particular case, questions arise about whether it is morally right to lie to family members when something can be done, ignoring the fact of its after effects. The case will be explained in details later on including the patient’s state, but to answer this ethical question, two theorists will be presented for the con and pro side. For the con side, the deontologist Immanuel Kant will be presented with his theory that lying is prohibited under all circumstances, as for the pro side, John Stuart Mill will be presented for the utilitarian theory stating that whichever decision brings out the most happiness is the right decision. After discussing the case, my personal view of what is right will be stated with my own reasons, which is that lying is the right decision to be taken.

    Read More

  • Children Deaths from Faith-Healing

    728 Words  | 2 Pages

    Although only a small percentage of children are dying from faith-healing practices, the awareness needs to be brought to the public. Faith in a religion has many benefits but the idea of abandoning medicine is bad for ones wellbeing. Precautionary signs of illness in infants must be treated immediately. Medicine alongside faith is the ideal situation in which many lives will be saved. Holding faith has proven to be positive for many people but one must take cautionary action when treating illnesses with faith healing as their only medicine. Faith healing and medicine collectively used with one another can yield the highest rates of recovery and general wellbeing, through reducing stress, relieving pain and anxiety, and increasing the desire to live. When the human body is able to release these stressors, one’s health has an increased rate of being cured.

    Read More

  • Informative Speech Outline

    893 Words  | 2 Pages

    The creator of our body is God. Therefore, it is important to acknowledge that He is in control of our body and patients. II. Motive for Listening This topic can be relevant to everyone in here not only nurses or future nurses, but as Christians, who have a duty or mission to love another as Jesus loved us (John 15:12).

    Read More

  • Mama Might Be Better Off Dead Analysis

    1969 Words  | 4 Pages

    When pressed about the tendency of her family to fall ill, Jackie bursts out that it just happens, not ascribing it to any outside force. This passivity manifests itself in other ways, most notably in Jackie’s refusal to learn to perform a number of home health functions in order to provide more specialized care for her grandmother. Mrs. Jackson herself struggled also to feel control over her life, especially after her first amputation confined her to the house, cutting her off from the church community that provided her with a weekly excursion, social engagement, and a sense of fulfillment. The conditions of poverty and illness combined can even preclude the possibility of self-efficacy, as demonstrated by the struggle of dialysis patients to gain or keep employment. Dialysis requires a regular time commitment and saps a great deal of energy from the people who undergo it, but dialysis centers still attempt to coax and prod patients towards the workforce. Abraham illuminates how in many cases, to do so would mean giving up the disability checks that patients rely on in favor of an uncertain job that can just as easily be lost if their health worsens, leaving them in an even more precarious situation than before. The inferior living conditions of poverty also work as a strong deterrent for any patients considering home dialysis, which requires a fair amount of medical know-how, the willingness to take charge of one’s own care, and a sterile environment, but may boost independence by giving the patient control over their schedule. For many patients, the sterile environment is impossible and they are unwilling or unable to consider taking charge of such a vital procedure. The requirements of illness and the need for governmental assistance often outweigh the ability to direct one’s own

    Read More

  • Essay On The Placebo Effect

    3121 Words  | 7 Pages

    Relying exclusively on faith healing and avoiding or delaying conventional treatment for a serious illness like cancer may have serious consequences. Death, disability or other unpleasant outcomes have occurred when faith healing was selected instead of conventional care for serious injuries or illnesses.

    Read More

  • Paternalism In Health Care Essay

    1363 Words  | 3 Pages

    There can be circumstances where an adolescent does not fully express themselves because of their family’s religion. When it comes to religion and medicine things can get really difficult. Some adolescents are taught by religious parents that healing is done by Christ not by concurrent

    Read More

  • Dialysis Essay

    804 Words  | 2 Pages

    Dialysis is a pretty expensive procedure and is required to be done regularly. The patients have to follow a strict schedule. Some patients that have to undergo regular dialysis are already very old and most of their other body parts are also not properly working. For example consider a situation in which a patient is in comma and is not responding , and patient is going through regular dialysis cycles, questions may arise that should the patient be given the treatment of dialysis. Not only it is putting burden on the resources and equipment of the hospital but it is also a financial burden on the person and the family of the patient. The dialysis machine could be used for another patient who is young has a lot of responsibilities like supporting the family needs etc, also the money that is spent on the procedure of dialysis for the comma patient that might have been used for someone’s help in the family. This is where we see the ethical dilemma. These are very di...

    Read More

  • Cardiovascular Disease Essay

    1424 Words  | 3 Pages

    Throughout history, it seems that medicine and spirituality have been linked in many circumstances. In a study looking at the use of complementary and alternative therapies in cardiac patients, spiritual healing was one of many practices patient sought to utilize. In another study, 29% of participants chose to use prayer or premeditation as a way to cope with their chronic illness. In both studies, prayer or meditation was more likely to be used by individuals who had a large social network, as well as support from another person in the same health situation. Based on these studies, it seems that many individuals (not just cardiovascular patients) turn to their spirituality in times of health distress.

    Read More

  • The Healing Hospital Paradigm

    1102 Words  | 3 Pages

    “A healing hospital is built on the ancient tradition that love is at the center of healing. Within that framework, the Golden Thread – a symbol of our faith in God – requires that we strike a balance between the latest scientific advancements and the demands of the human spirit. As healthcare providers, we are called upon to tend to our patient’s heart and head. For a hospital to truly be healing, the Golden Thread must be continuous. As both healers and patients, it is the Golden Thread that connects us all” (Mercy Gilbert Medical Center, n.d.).

    Read More

  • Wellbeing Essay

    1715 Words  | 4 Pages

    Then again, the hadith additionally pushes other profound elements of the ailment. These capacities may involve purgation, discipline for sins, or positive prizes. In Islamic custom, it is extremely normal to express one 's sensitivity for a sickness by saying "It happened with God 's consent or God 's will. Muslims were among the first on the planet to construct healing facilities to guarantee more viable therapeutic watch over the wiped out. Despite the fact that the Qur 'an does not talk unequivocally about restorative treatment, it does put a high esteem on wellbeing. The Qur 'an accentuates physical also, profound cleanliness and calls itself a cure (Oyewole, Dopamu & University of Ilorin, 2010). Get yourself treated when you are debilitated, for each ailment God has sent a treatment as well. After the execution of essential religious obligations, there is no more prominent administration to God than to mend individuals. For Muslims, this form of treatment was initially uncovered to particular prophets and after that created by human experience and reason. Contemporary Islamic pharmaceutical keeps on stating the Qur 'an 's connection between physical and otherworldly areas (Ellison & Hummer, 2010). In like manner, Muslim patients trust that they are better ready to withstand physical enduring in the event that they have an in number association with God, submit themselves to following to Qur 'anic decrees, and model the teachings of the Prophet Muhammad. These directives likewise apply to ordinary life. Case in point, substantial health is developed using dietary confinements, for example, precautions against pork, liquor, sedates that can conceivably hinder regular working or extreme sexual action. Likewise with the act of solution, are guided by sacred writing and are in this way seen as celestial orders identified with physical

    Read More

  • Daily Mail: The True Love Story Of Lure

    229 Words  | 1 Pages

    In an article by “Daily Mail,” readers she the true love story of a couple who struggle with love and hope when they are in need. A man named Larry Swilling has been married to his wife, Jimmie Sue, for over 57 years (Daily Mail). Jimmie was born with one kidney and had relied on the one kidney for her whole life. The organ began to have problems and the doctors told the couple she would be needing a new kidney. The husband, with all his love, instantly got tested to see if he could give Jimmie his kidney. Unfortunately, they were not in luck. Their hope was close to being lost at the thought of the test being negative (Daily Mail). Luckily for Jimmie his husband was determined to have more years with her. To make the goal into a reality, Larry

    Read More

  • Healthcare and Religious Beliefs

    890 Words  | 2 Pages

    In healthcare organizations, medical staff must conform to their hospital and their country’s code of conduct. Not only do they have to meet set standards, they must also take their patient into consideration. When making a decision upon a patient, medical staff must recognize religious backgrounds and spiritual beliefs. By understanding a patients’ beliefs and their belief system, a medical worker can give the patient their deserved medical assistance without overstepping boundaries or coming off as offensive. The practices and beliefs of four religions will be articulated throughout this essay to fully understand how religion can either help or hinder the healing process.

    Read More

More about Healing And Autonomy Case Study

Open Document