George Gmelch Baseball Magic Analysis

541 Words2 Pages

Baseball Magic, by George Gmelch, revised pages 25-46 of "Superstition and ritual in American Baseball" is a great example of traditions that players repetitively do, believing that it will give them luck or help them perform better. Anthropologist
Bronislaw Malinowski compared Trobrianders open sea fishing, and their traditions to help ensure a safe journey and increase their catch, to America's national pastime, Baseball, in which professional athletes battle day in and day out to be crowned at the end of the year the World Champions. After retiring from baseball and taking an anthropology course called “Magic, Religion, and Witchcraft.” Gmelch realized that his old traditions and his teammate's traditions for luck weren't so different from …show more content…

Humans naturally try to control everything around them, and when something is so uncontrollable such as baseball where there are only three primary activities- pitching, hitting, and fielding, and each of these have many uncontrollable aspects, in which almost every player on the field has a ritual or tradition they will follow before the game or during the game. I especially like this because I played baseball and was a pitcher and has many rituals when I was doing well, and even had more when I was doing worse because the pitcher has the least control on the field because after they throw the ball they have usually no impact on the rest of the play, and their best pitch can be hit for a home run or get a called third strike on the outside corner. The worst part is that the pitcher can be having an amazing game, but your team has no run support and you still lose. For example in 1990 when Sir Fernandez lost twice as many games as Dwight Gooden his teammate who allowed more runs per game then Fernandez. Unfortunately, the pitcher can't rely on himself, he relies on his entire team, his coaches, and even the other

Open Document