George Fitzhugh's Narrative The Life Of Frederick Douglass

563 Words2 Pages

“Those who deny freedom to others, deserve it not for themselves” Abraham Lincoln, unlike Lincoln, George Fitzhugh supported slavery and saw it as a beneficial thing for everyone. Fitzhugh became well known through his writings defending slavery. The autobiography, Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, is written from the perspective of a slave, demonstrating the suffering slaves went through for generations. Fitzhugh is wrong for justifying slavery because slavery robbed slaves from their freedom and dehumanized them. Douglass’ autobiography serves as an example that contradicts Fitzhugh arguments in his essay. He argues that slaves are happy with the condition they live in, that slaves are fairly cared for by the masters, and that …show more content…

He says that slaves are dependent of the master and that the master cares for a slave like he would for a child. Fitzhugh writes, “the slave-holder is better than others...His whole life is spent in providing for the minutest wants of others, in taking care of them in sickness and in health” (3). Fitzhugh argument is weaken because he presented a fallacious argument. Hiding information/half truth is the fallacy Fitzhugh used because he claimed the masters provided for his slaves but that wasn't always true for all masters. Douglass in the beginning of his autobiography explains the way in which slaves were given their monthly allowance of food and yearly clothing. At the beginning of chapter two Douglass writes, “The children unable to work in the field have neither shoes, stockings, jackets, nor trouser...There were no beds given to the slaves” (26-27). Although slaveowners might have provided minimal food to the slaves didn’t make them better or good people. Giving a miserable portion of food that wasn’t enough for slaves to live a healthy live didn’t mean the masters cared about the slaves.

Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass also proves that Fitzhugh statement that slavery prevents rivalry between the master and slave is wrong. Fitzhugh explains that with equality among men they all aspire for self-promotion and self-elevation. In “Slavery Justified” Fitzhugh writes, “A state of independence always begets more or less jealousy rivalry and hostility”

Open Document