Elizabeth Barrett-Browning’s ‘Sonnets from the Portuguese’ and F. Scott Fitzgerald’s ‘The Great Gatsby’ reflect the values, attitudes, and ideas of their context. This is explored in Browning’s collection of poems from the Victorian era where she transforms her attitude towards love and conforms to the Christian ideologies of death, prominent in the Victorian epoch. Moreover, Fitzgerald’s 1920s modernist novel portrays the Jazz Age’s sexist values through Gatsby’s relationship with Daisy, while also highlighting the materialistic nature of the time through their perspective of death. Thus, composers manifest the context of their time through their texts in order to comment on their social and personal concerns. The idea of gender roles being …show more content…
innate to every society is represented by the patriarchal values and attitudes of the Victorian era, however Elizabeth Barrett-Browning’s feminism challenges this notion through her transformed attitude towards love. This is displayed in ‘Sonnets from the Portuguese’ whereby Barrett-Browning deposes the Victorian idea of ‘courtly love’, stemmed from her strong feministic character. In this, Barret-Browning transforms her attitude towards love. The metaphor in “more like an out of tune/worn viol” reflects her feelings of uncertainty regarding love. This is later juxtaposed to her experience of love with Robert, where she is decisive in shaping her future expectation. Furthermore, “out of tune” reinforces her rejection of the Victorian patriarchy, illustrating Browning’s determination of achieving a pure love, which in turn highlights the transformational power of love. Therefore, the patriarchal values and attitudes of the Victorian era are explored through the text’s representation of love and romantic relationships. Furthermore, ‘The Great Gatsby’ confirms the contextual sexist values and attitudes towards women in the Jazz Age, largely evident in Gatsby’s obsession with Daisy.
After a party, Gatsby laments to Nick and walks along a “desolate path of fruit rinds and discarded favours and crushed flowers.” This represents his “crushed” and “desolate” feelings of love for Daisy. His language and tone convey that he is determining what Daisy wants, falling into traditional gender roles and suggesting she has no agency in their affair, “I’m going to fix everything just the way it was before...She’ll see.” This also indicates that Gatsby is falling into the courtly love tradition and attempting to prove his love. However, unlike Barrett-Browning, who is uncertain about love, Gatsby believes he is not only worthy, but entitled to Daisy’s love due to their past history. A flashback is also employed, in which it reveals that when he and Daisy first kissed, “she blossomed for him like a flower”. The possessive language exposes Gatsby’s attitudes that Daisy exists and grows “for him”, revealing the patriarchal values of the context. This highlights the persistence of gender roles throughout varying epochs. Hence, the social context’s patriarchal values and attitudes are expressed through a text’s representation of love and romantic …show more content…
relationships. The idea of death is inherent in all individuals, yet society’s attitude towards this alters over time. ‘Sonnet 22’ explores how Barrett-Browning’s attitude towards death is hopeful, believing that she and Robert’s love will continue in heaven after death, “With darkness and the death-hour rounding it”. The alliteration presents Barrett-Browning’s inevitable death, but the symbolism of “rounding” displays a circular attitude towards life and demonstrates the completion of their love after death. Rather than being content with death, she actively anticipates it. The enjambment of “...where the unfit/contrarious moods of men recoil away/ and isolate pure spirits” reinforces the idea of life continuing after death and also suggests that only after death can Barrett-Browning be emancipated from the constraints of Victorian society and love freely. The religious imagery and ghostly language of “pure spirits” also indicates that their love will purify once dead. Hence, death is innate in all humans, however context reshapes a text’s attitudes and ideas surrounding it. Elizabeth Barrett-Browning’s attitudes towards death starkly contrast those seen in ‘The Great Gatsby’, who view life as finite.
This is espoused through Myrtle’s death, who claimed “You can’t live forever, you can’t live forever.” The anaphora exposes the contextual idea that death is final, thus it is imperative to spend life in search of pleasurable experiences. There is no sense of being rewarded in heaven. When she is killed, the simile “her left breast swinging loose like a flap” conveys the detached, dehumanising, views of mortality. The 1920’s materialism is also apparent, as the description focuses on her appearance and suggests that rather than mourning the loss of life, they are emphasising her loss of beauty and appeal. The “death car” is a metaphor for the dangers of living in a reckless society and warns against perceiving life to be finite. The absence of a belief in heaven presents the context in a nihilistic way and alters the peaceful representation of mortality in Barrett-Browning’s works. Thus, death is intrinsic in all individuals, but context alters a text’s attitudes and ideas surrounding
it. Texts are constructed according to the values, ideas and attitudes of their composer and context, and comment on the social and historical concerns espoused. ‘Sonnets from the Portuguese’ and ‘The Great Gatsby’ reflect the contextual perspectives and criticise the societies in which they are composed.
Gender roles are society’s concept on how men and woman should behave. In The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald and Hamlet by William Shakespeare, gender roles are evident in how characters act and distinguish each other.
The Great Gatsby is an emotional tale of hope of love and “romantic readiness”(1.2) that is both admirable and meritorious .Yet, the question of Daisy ever being able to measure up to Gatsby’s expectations is one that reverberates throughout the course of the novel. Be that as it may, Daisy is never truly able to measure up to Gatsby’s expectations because the image of Daisy in Gatsby’s mind is entirely different from who she actually is. Even during his younger years, Gatsby had always had a vision of himself “as a son of God”(6.98) and that “he must be about his fathers business, the service of a vast, vulgar and meretricious beauty”(6.98). Gatsby’s desire for aristocracy, wealth, and luxury is exactly what drives him to pursue Daisy who embodies everything that that Gatsby desires and worked towards achieving. Therefore, Gatsby sees Daisy as the final piece to his puzzle in order realize his vision. Gatsby’s hyperbolized expectation of Daisy throws light on the notion if our dreams as individuals are actually limited by reality. Since our dreams as human beings are never truly realized, because they may be lacking a specific element. Daisy proves to be that element that lingers in Gatsby’s dreams but eludes his reality.
The Great Gatsby is often referred to as the great American novel; a timeless commentary on the American Dream. A dream that defines success, power, love, social status, and recreation for the American public. It should be mentioned that this novel was published in 1925, which is a time when the American public had recently experienced some significant changes, including women’s suffrage, which had only taken place 6 years prior to the publication of this novel May of 1919. The women of this era had recently acquired a voice in politics, however, the social world does not always take the same pace as the political world. F. Scott Fitzgerald developed female characters that represented both women in their typical gender roles and their modern counterparts. I will be analyzing gender roles within the context of this novel, comparing and contrasting Myrtle Wilson, Jordan Baker, and Daisy Buchanan alongside one another, as well as comparing and contrasting their interactions with the men in the novel.
The twentieth century was filled with many advances which brought a variety of changes to the world. However, these rapid advances brought confusion to almost all realms of life; including gender roles, a topic which was previously untouched became a topic of discourse. Many authors of the time chose to weigh in on the colloquy. In F. Scott Fitzgerald’s The Great Gatsby and Kate Chopin’s The Awakening, gender role confusion, characteristic of modernist literature, is seen in Nick Carraway and Edna Pontillier as they are the focal points in the exploration of what it means to be a man or a woman, their purpose, place, and behavior in society.
The exploring Fitzgerald's use of gender roles in the novel requires a certain amount of scholarly research. Including text searches throughout the book, reading scholarly criticisms about the novel and reading articles that present new ideas about Fitzgerald's work. Gender definition and patriarchal values is the main topic of Bethany Klassen's article entitled, "Under Control: Patriarchal Gender construction in the Great Gatsby." The quotes and ideas in this article are profound and bring on a whole new meaning to events, conversations and actions that take place in the book. For example she notes, " To place Daisy and Myrtle in the passive position necessary to Tom's ego, Fitzgerald employs imagery that denies them their humanity and transforms them into objects defined by their purpose to display Tom's wealth and power"( Klassen ). This passage in the article refers to the way in which Tom puts value on women not by personality or his love but as a material trapping. Not showing emotion towards his wife adds to Tom's persona. The article also includes opinions about the female roles in the novel. Daisy and Myrtle personify the typical female who is basically living to fulfill her husband's needs instead of getting a degree and making a living. The article continues to explain how during that time period, there was even a consequence for not fitting into gender roles. Referring to the tragic car accident, Klassen writes, " Because Daisy's affair with Gatsby places her in the car with him that night and because Myrtle's rebellion against her husband leads her to run into the road, both incidences of female empowerment structurally precipitates the disaster" ( Klassen ). This quote is extremely interesting because it claims that when women try to overcome being trapped by feminine stereo-types, it ends in disaster. This article is obviously beneficial to any person who is exploring gender roles in the novel.
With the increasing popularity of female-oriented post-secondary education, the growing number of women working outside the home in professional occupations and the newly granted right to suffrage, women directly challenged the traditional notions of American Womanhood in the 1920’s. In just seventy one years since the Seneca Falls Convention, feminists in America accomplished sweeping changes for women politically, economically, and socially. Attempting to reconcile the changing concept of womanhood with more traditional female roles, male writers often included depictions of this “New Woman” in their novels. Frequently, the male writers of the Progressive Era saw the New Woman as challenging the very fabric of society and, subsequently, included
Tom Buchanan and George Wilson have plenty in common with their attitude pertaining towards women in F. Scott Fitzgerald’s novel The Great Gatsby. Fitzgerald throughout the entire novel gives the audience an insight on his thoughts about the nature of man. Fitzgerald portrays men often treating women harshly throughout his novel. For example, there are many violent acts towards women, a constant presence of dominance, and also ironically Tom and Georges over reactions to being cheated on.
Daisy Buchanan is the most significant female character in The Great Gatsby. F Scott Fitzgerald writes her as the most significant female because she is most like his wife, Zelda (Donaldson). Daisy is Gatsby’s motivation for wealth and why he wants to accomplish so much. He has longed for her because she has always been unattainable. Fitzgerald, like Gatsby was often rejected by women in a class higher than him (Donaldson). Zelda was Fitzgerald’s motivation for writing The Great Gatsby and many other works (Donaldson). It was a way for him to express his frustration and love for his wife. Zelda was the main female role in Fitzgerald’s life, much like Daisy is for Gatsby. Fitzgerald writes his relationship in order to cope with what is happening
A woman’s need to pursue society’s expectations of her can corrupt her entire view on relationships and human interactions. In the novel The Great Gatsby by Scott Fitzgerald, suggests that an individuals desire to achieve a standard of perfection in society can demoralize them into engrossing only what is best for themselves during conflict. Daisy is the epitome of a woman during the 1920’s, she wants nothing more than the appearance of a perfect family life, so when her future is indefinite she hides behind Tom’s wealth, and certainty to achieve her desires.
During the 1920’s, the role women had under men was making a drastic change, and it is shown in The Great Gatsby by two of the main female characters: Daisy and Jordan. One was domesticated and immobile while the other was not. Both of them portray different and important characteristics of the normal woman growing up in the 1920’s. The image of the woman was changing along with morals. Females began to challenge the government and the society. Things like this upset people, especially the men. The men were upset because this showed that they were losing their long-term dominance over the female society.
Throughout time women have been written as the lesser sex weaker, secondary characters. They are portrayed as dumb, stupid, and nothing more that their fading beauty. They are written as if they need to be saved or helped because they cannot help themselves. Women, such as Daisy Buchanan who believes all a women can be is a “beautiful little fool”, Mrs Mallard who quite died when she lost her freedom from her husband, Eliza Perkins who rights the main character a woman who is a mental health patient who happens to be a woman being locked up by her husband, and then Carlos Andres Gomez who recognizes the sexism problem and wants to change it. Women in The Great Gatsby, “The Story of an Hour,” “The Yellow Wall Paper” and the poem “When” are
Gender Roles: In some respects, Fitzgerald writes about gender roles in a quite conservative manner. In his novel, men work to earn money for the maintenance of the women. Men are dominant over women, especially in the case of Tom, who asserts his physical strength to subdue them. The only hint of a role reversal is in the pair of Nick and Jordan. Jordan's androgynous name and cool, collected style masculinize her more than any other female character. However, in the end, Nick does exert his dominance over her by ending the relationship. The women in the novel are an interesting group, because they do not divide into the traditional groups of Mary Magdalene and Madonna figures, instead, none of them are pure. Myrtle is the most obviously sensual, but the fact that Jordan and Daisy wear white dresses only highlights their corruption.
From the start of the book we can see that women in the book are
“I hope she’ll be a fool - that’s the best thing a girl can be in this world, a beautiful little fool” (Fitzgerald 20). This quote is as true now as it was when Daisy Buchanan said it about her daughter in The Great Gatsby. Women grow up in a box of expectations. They are told to act a certain way and do certain things. Daisy knew that this was the world that her daughter was going to be growing up in, and that if she grew up to be a fool then she would fit into the world very nicely. If she grew up and became someone who noticed inequality, or who wanted independence, she would struggle in the world. While woman are no longer put in such a black and white box, there are still many expectations and limitations that woman have to face in their
‘’I would be quite satisfied if my novels did no more than teach my readers that their past was not one long night of savagery from which the first Europeans acting on God’s behalf delivered them’’. ( Morning yet) Chinua Achebe wrote stories so that people would get knowledge out of it. That being said him making Things Fall Apart was not for entertainment, but it showed us the gender-role of males in females at the time. Males are the focus of my research, there is two great protagonists that will be discussed in this paper Okonkwo and Jay Gatsby. How does the characterization of men and their role in society in the Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald compare to Things Fall Apart by Chinua Achebe in terms of success, failure and mindset.