Gedali By Isaac Babel

681 Words2 Pages

The temptation to stray from one’s belief is quintessential to the evolution and modernization of religion. The desire to preserve religious traditions is preferred by many, however, as times progress, yearnings change. In Isaac Babel’s short story “Gedali,” the tension between tradition and modernity is evident in the Russian city of Zhitomir. Nostalgia for the past demonstrates an aspiration for maintaining customary practices. Unfortunately, though, matters do not always pan out the way in which one hopes. Because of Babel’s use of literary diction, the narrator highlights the significance of Gedali’s shop in addition to investing in certain objects with meaning. Gedali, a poor old shopkeeper, yearns to continue his practice of Judaism) …show more content…

One cannot always know where life will take them, hence the feeling of confusion because what is next is yet to come. Optimism is evident, in the context of the Revolution, in regard to the depiction of good versus bad. Additionally, before it died, the butterfly served as a joyous creature of life. When observing a butterfly, it is hard not to notice its beauty, its strength and its ability to fly high, all of which should be considered qualities of optimism. Furthermore, the narrator describes the positivity and the negativity through a relatively balanced comparison, stating, “A good man does good deeds. The Revolution is the good deed done by good men. But good men do not kill. Hence the Revolution is done by bad men. But the Poles are also bad men” (Babel 228-9). Understanding that there are favorable and opposing aspects of the revolution is key. Situations in life are not always black and white; sometimes there is a little bit of color. For example, a gramophone can spin either way it does not mean that it will not sound right, it will just be different. Lastly, poverty is inevitable. In regard to Gedali, frankly, he is living in poverty. However, such as a cockerel keeps busy roaming a farm, Gedali keeps busy strolling about his

Open Document