Wait a second!
More handpicked essays just for you.
More handpicked essays just for you.
Is genetic engineering ethical
Is genetic engineering ethical
Is genetic engineering ethical
Don’t take our word for it - see why 10 million students trust us with their essay needs.
Recommended: Is genetic engineering ethical
Some of the advantages and disadvantages to having a society like that portrayed in GATTACA , advantages of having a society like GATTACA crimes such as murder , kidnapping , etc. it would be very easy to find and track the criminal because of all the ways to find every little hint of dna that has been left behind. Some disadvantages of having a society as in GATTACA , if you were not a perfect child then there was no chance of getting a good career. There was not a single child accepted into society that wasn’t perfect. Parents got to choose the perfect child of their dreams with genetic modification , which gave the parents full customization …show more content…
of what child they wanted to create starting with eye color all the way to personality . In a society like GATTACA you couldn’t get a good job that you are happy with without having your dna tested or some kind of test to tell if you qualify just based on your genes. Society should not be judged on the way you were born and the genes you inherited by your parents. If was in a world where anything you want to do is based on your dna I probably wouldn’t last in the world if society was like that. Yes , it would be nice to change how your child was going to live his or her life . Having a job based on how you were born would be hard to have a well good career and family . Some injustices I noticed during the film was that they didn’t look at Vincent as a smart human being they looked at how long he was going to live and his medical conditions .
Vincent was forced to steal another man’s identity under the name of Jerome. Although Jerome was paralyzed waist down Jerome was a nobody till Vincent gave his life a new meaning . He proved himself to be very good at his work and was selected to be part of a prestigious mission to a moon in Saturn. Stealing Jerome’s identity did not change Vincent’s abilities He was always capable of doing well in this field , but his genes would never have given him that chance to prove that he can be better than most. If the world was to become a world where any job is based on how perfect you are it will become very corrupt because nobody is perfect parents will start to look at alternatives and see their new perfect child will take up the parents time as did Vincent’s parents. I don’t believe dna should evaluate an employee or any human being in general , to me it seems as if they are favoriting the perfect people and leaving the imperfect people to have the bad jobs and mistreat them …show more content…
. To me people are perfect in their own worlds and shouldn’t be looked at for who they aren’t .
In GATTACA yes the technology is nice but basing people on how their genes are wouldn’t be good in reality . As Vincent and his brother played chicken at the beach Anton wasn’t exactly perfect as everyone had thought he was. As they were swimming out in the ocean Anton’s body gave out and Vincent had to save him but even though Vincent had medical problems he was able to swim save his brother and still have to swim back while holding his brother. To me although Anton may have been the “perfect” child Vincent seemed to have no issues with all the medical issues he seemed to have had . Anton ended up having issues swimming out , but nobody is perfect . If we had a society like GATTACA had there wouldn’t be a perfect person like people would think because Anton was suppose to be perfect but couldn’t swim back at the beach .
A good thing about it is that people would have a less likely chance of getting a disease cause when they are modifying the genes they can change the percentage of the child getting cancer . Scientists could increase peoples immunity to diseases Vincent is born without gene specialization after the race with his
brother he felt as if he didn’t belong in the family because in the world of GATTACA everybody’s perfect and since Vincent had a lot of medical issues he felt useless to his family . Honestly, I think the world of GATTACA could someday happen to America it would be unfair . If everybody was made to be perfect there would be no sense of variety amongst one another . The world would be very plain and strict if it came down to that .To me modifying how a baby is and making it to your perfect ruins the surprise of the baby and taking care of a baby’s issues is what makes having a baby so special experiencing what it feels like to be a parent is all the process of life . I don’t want my child to pretend to be someone he or she doesn’t want to be I want them to see the world as who they truly are . As usual the law would have a big effect on this change it would be very organized and it would make it easy to keep track of who committed what and why . If I was Vincent I probably would have left my family to because I would feel like they weren’t happy enough with me so they had to go make another child just perfect . Towards the end the doctor knew about Vincent and his fake identity yet he gave him a chance to do what his son wasn’t able to do . Vincent showed that you don’t have to be perfect to achieve your dreams yet Jerome gave Vincent a chance to make his dreams come true his brother knew as well but still was unable to beat his brother in a swim. The world could become just like GATTACA and possibly even better and fair . Using the same dna scanners , but wouldn’t evaluate the employee’s using their dna to see if they qualify. Everybody could qualify they just think that since they may not be the strongest they still are really smart . Anton was perfect but wasn’t able to last long swimming because no matter what everybody is gonna have their flaws . Nobody’s perfect and nobody’s ever gonna be perfect . The doctor let him achieve it to because his son has the same problems and looks up to Vincent ( Jerome Marrow ) the doctor wanted nothing but the best for his son . It would be tough living in a society where it all matters if you are perfect or not . All in all GATTACA could become a reality but it wouldn’t be as tough as seen in the movie . It would be fair and people would start to look at it as a fresh start in a new world .
Is it good to have? I believe that humans will eventually have to cross this bridge of interfering with nature or not. I see the positives and negatives on boths sides of the argument. However, collectively, I believe that genetically engineering children to the extent of that in the movie is a bad. I believe this for several reasons, one being that there, as seen in the movie, would be very little excitement about anything and everything would lack passion. Everyone who works at Gattaca is very bleak and shows no emotion for fear of being judged by other people. Another reason is that no one would really succeed at anything, and it would not be impressive if they did because they were only fulfilling their potential predicted at birth. If someone were to be faster than others, it would be expected because of their genes, and have nothing to do with personal training or effort. The only thing one could do is fail. Jerome had one of the best possible genetic codes and he only managed to win second place after being guaranteed first. If they do not live up to what has been decided about them, they only see themselves as failure. The biggest reason though, not to engineer your children, is the same as we see in the movie, discrimination because they lack a preferred genotype. Vincent was looked down upon, and was only ever expected to mop the floors superior people worked on. Not everyone
...e the quality of life of children. A big consequence to the use of genetic modification, shown in the movie Gattaca, is the prejudice that can be against those without genetic modifications. To create an idea of what the consequences of genetic modification will look like, a real world example would be racism and the use of eugenics to justify the prejudice against those who were not light-skinned or of caucasian descent. Neo eugenics is a very controversial topic that has a lot of possible benefits and consequences and will affect many generations to come.
To begin, there are several concepts about compulsory education that aggravates John Gatto and he explains his concerns in his essay “Against School.” Gatto’s first concern is everything is about school is boring. “Boredom is the common condition of schoolteachers (Gatto 608).” If the teachers are bored, they will create a dull and boring environment for the students. “Boredom and childishness were the natural state of affairs in the classroom (Gatto 608).” Lack of creativity and freedom is another concern of Gatto. “An educational system deliberately designed to produce mediocre intellects (Gatto 611).” Also, Gatto thinks school is unnecessary. “George Washington, Benjamin
When one thinks of a society of genetically advanced individuals at first glance it might seem like an advantage, but upon taking a closer look you can see the flaws in these perfect people. The world of Gattaca is superficial and judgmental; the only way to measure the worth of a person is by the wholesomeness of one's blood. They do not know for sure that someone will die or develop a heart condition all they have to work with is a percentage of the chance of it happening. This brands the world of Gattaca as an unfit and inferior world than our own. When a society discriminates against a group of people they lose valuable and productive members of society. In Gattaca the hardest working, most driven person was someone that they thought should
The film Gattaca directed by Andrew Niccol is a science fiction that discovers the overall effects of genetic engineering. This is shown through the idea of a imminent society compelled by eugenics, where hypothetical children are conceived within a world of genetic manipulation. By doing this, it ensures that the upcoming generation posses the finest hereditary traits to benefit the future.
In 1997, Andrew Niccol produced the movie GATTACA. The movie described a world with genetically modified humans, modified at birth to be the perfect child their parents always wanted. In the 1990s, the movie seemed like a science fiction fantasy, but recent advances in biomedical procedure have started to make it a reality. While a future full of genetic engineering may be an intriguing notion, the human genome should be left alone. Humans should not be tampered with.
Firstly, a concerning issues related with the enhancement of characteristics through genetic means is discrimination in society. The text “Flowers for Algernon” epitomizes discrimination, where the protagonist Charlie Gordon undergoes a revolutionary change from his mental disability to a genius through an experimental surgery. Following the experiment, his intelligence escalates to a degree such that he progressively becomes isolated from the rest of society. Furthermore, Gordon explains his new intelligence to have “driven a wedge between [him] and all the people [he] once knew and loved” and expresses that “people don’t talk to [him] anymore and it makes [his] job lonely” (insert reference). This reveals a form of discrimination between the upper class and lower class individuals. Likewise, the film “Gattaca” depicts discrimination through the contrast of individual characters. The protagonist Vincent Freeman, is a naturally conceived baby who inherits a “99% probability [of developing] a heart disorder and a subsequent life expectancy of 30.2 years” (insert reference). In contrast, Vincent’s younger brother Anton has been artificially conceived providing him with physical advantages complemented with remarkable ...
This is the natural fallacy genetic engineering creates in the new world seen in Gattaca. We know this because in the film the main character, Vincent, who uses another man named Jerome Morrow’s D.N.A and identity to rise up the ranks within Gattaca’s staff. He does this because genetic engineering pre-determines every aspect of one’s life that is scientifically possible. This would include diseases, life expectancy, cause of death, jobs/careers you can have and even who you should marry all from a sample of blood given when first born. Vincent’s D.N.A to others deemed him chronically ill, making him invalid, meaning that there would be very little opportunities for him in life; though he felt he can do things just as well as anyone. It is in Gattaca that we can look at genetic engineering as determining one’s instrumental worth to
GATTACA (1997) is a science fiction movie where one’s capabilities are determined by their genes since birth. Vincent Freeman is displayed as the main character where he needs to overcome his weaknesses through hard work and consistent determination to achieve his goals at Gattaca Space Academy. Alterations of genetics play a major role in the movie where only ones with flawless genes can achieve their dream career and ‘genoism’ became a new form of inequity. Society looks down upon Vincent including his parents because he was born naturally with physical limitations known as an ‘invalid’ whereas his younger brother Anton was genetically modified before his birth. Anton was born as ‘valid’ and was held highly by everyone due to his perfect genes chosen by his parents. As a result of discrimination down to...
In the movie Gattaca, DNA plays a significant role in determining the social class. When a child is born, the biometric analysis instantly identifies those conceived by genetic manipulation as “valid” and those naturally conceived and susceptible to genetic disorders as “in-valid”. In the movie, the genetic manipulation and biometric analysis are de facto over everyone’s life. Even though it is forbidden by law to discriminate based on “valid” and “in-valid” status, “valid” is likely to get a professional job whereas “in-valid” ends up with menial jobs.
Matt Bird explains “Genetic engineering can eliminate age barriers,” but he also states, “Genetic engineering’s ability to expand life has a drawback in that it can cause overpopulation.” This shows that the genetic engineering that Jonas’s community can have good things, but it may also have bad aspects to it. Matt Bird says that genetically modified babies can be made stronger, faster, tougher, and smarter, but his article also claims that doing so would have a larger chance for a mutant. In Jonas’s community they genetically modify the babies so they can’t see colors, but there is a chance that they could create a
In the movie Gattaca, the label was described with the two words Invalid or valid. Those words will define the social level of each one and that person will need to live with that label for the whole life. In the movie, Vincent was told that he will have a heart condition that he will not be capable to do things that the genetically perfect were capable to do, and he act like that in the beginner, when he could not follow his brother into the sea, but he surpass the label and showed that he could go further than his brother into the
Rather than leave genetics up to chance, technology offers expectant parents the opportunity to genetically enhance their children before they’re born. These genetically superior offspring are known as “valids” and are given the best opportunity in Gattaca’s society. For example, when Vincent, an invalid, borrows the identity of the valid Jerome Morrow, an interview to work for Gattaca consists only of a urine test. It’s assumed that his genes carry all his potential. There’s no need for him to answer questions his DNA can answer for him.
Today's advances in genetic engineering allow therapy to replace the defective gene in a cell with a more refined gene that does not have this defect. Although these methods are available, they are still in the experimental stage. It allows anyone to be able to change the reality. Methods are possible to create an ideal society without any flaws and with a high level of intelligence. Of course, if the gene develops without further negative consequences - it is ideal. Nevertheless, if there is a defect associated with the replacement of the gene - it poses a great threat to the future of our planet.
As a species we’ve always looked for ways to be faster, stronger, smarter, and live longer. Many enhancements we take for granted today; blood transfusions, vaccinations, and birth control, seemed unnatural or immoral when first introduced. Yet over time we’ve become accustomed to these controls over our minds and bodies, and have used them to better ourselves and our world. Imagine a society without disease, cancers, or heredity disorders. Life span would increase and IQ raised. Mental illness eliminated. Alzheimer’s gone. Hereditary problems, like baldness eradicated. Technology exists to diagnose flawed DNA in pre-implantation embryos, empowering humans to create a stronger, healthier child. Scientists place a new/modified gene into a virus like organism that enters the cell and inserts the new gene. Genetic modification is utilized to correct defective genes that lead to disease or genetic disorders; in simple terms, manipulating human genes to provide a brighter genetic future for humanity. In the future we may also be able to "cure" genetic diseases in embryos by replacing faulty sections of DNA with healthy DNA, in a process called germ line therapy. This has been performed on animal embryos but is currently illegal for humans.