Freud and C.S Lewis: Opposite Points of View on Religion

1018 Words3 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Comparing and contrasting two religions

Two great men, two exact opposite points of view, when it comes to the question of a master creator. These two men would have a profound effect on the life that we live today. Freud who was born to an orthodox Jewish family in the mid 1800’s was born into a lower class family his father was in the wool trade. The collapse of the family business moved him and his family to a Vienna, Ghetto. Freud would later become the voice of science in a logical and philosophical battle. The latter would be author, C.S Lewis; Lewis grew up in a religious home as well, being born 42 years after the birth of Freud. Lewis’s parents were both educated individuals. Lewis’s father was a lawyer and his mother a mathematician. These men would both face their own unique challenges and tribulations. One man would embrace the idea of atheism and the other would unwillingly submit to theism.

Freud was born into a family that practiced Orthodox Judaism they were above all religious to their core. In his youth, Freud read and learned from the ancient Hebrew Scriptures.

Above all, of his childhood figure his nanny the woman who would take Freud to a Catholic Church service when he was younger. The nanny lost her job because she allegedly stole from the family and this had a grave impact on the young mind of Freud, she faced accusations of stealing. However, the religion in Freud’s life would come to an abrupt halt when Freud’s family would face finical hardships. With the collapse of his father’s business, the pressure on the young boy to succeed and support the family grew immensely. Freud relocated to Vienna where his religious teaching would take a back seat to his preparation for University and a well-paying job. This job would support his family...

... middle of paper ...

... being. We also used to believe that the universe was Geocentric, when Copernicus suggested that this was wrong and our universe was heliocentric, the church ostracized him. Science is capable of explaining all things it is just a matter of time before all questions that we believe to be unanswerable find an answer through scientific research. The Large Hadron Collider is even researching the big bang. We will eventually answer all of our questions through science. C.S Lewis also had a great outlook on life, his belief in God led him onto success and happiness. Perhaps a belief religion is not believing in a God, but finding a belief that will make your life happy and answer the questions that you need. I personally believe that Freud and his path of science is correct, conversely if a person wishes to believe in a God or religion I can see their point of view.

Show More
Related

  • Freud's Attack On Christianity Essay

    782 Words  | 2 Pages

    Religion has been a controversial topic among philosophers and in this paper I am focusing

    Read More

  • The Question of God: C.S. Lewis and Sigmund Freud Debate God, Love, Sex and the Meaning of Life

    774 Words  | 2 Pages

    Both Lewis and Freud agreed that the question of god’s existence and our response must be asked. Though each man had drastically different worldviews and answers, they each sought to learn and understand the other’s worldview. Nicholi points out that Lewis may have had an advantage in the understanding of the unbeliever’s worldview due to the fact that until the age of 30, he claimed to be “even more certain of his atheism than was Freud” (2002, Pg. 81). In his adult life, Freud had no dramatic change of worldview from believer to unbeliever like Lewis had. This fact may give Lewis a slight upper hand in the understanding of the unbeliever’s worldview; however, Freud was still one of the greatest minds of his times and his work proves a strong (though negative) understanding of the believer’s worldview.

    Read More

  • Comparing Otto, Freud, And Tillich's Interpretation Of Religion

    862 Words  | 2 Pages

    Similar to Marx, Freud believes humans simply make up the idea of God in explanation to things science could not disprove. Humans take relationships from our Earthly fathers and compare it to our Heavenly father. According to Freud, “Religion is an attempt to master the sensory world in which we are situated by means of the wishful world which we have developed within us as a result of biological and psychological necessities.” (H/R,p.26) Science can neither prove or disprove religion. Freud chooses to believe science and claims religion is only comforting and hopeful thinking to our purpose after

    Read More

  • Compare And Contrast Freudis And Nietzsche

    862 Words  | 2 Pages

    ...e had thoughts of the ideal man stems coming from the anger about his society who treated humans as machines and animals. Freud was more like a therapist for giving every problem for the human’s unhappiness and frustration, solutions to have life that is more livable. Freud saw the inner struggle which was affected by the civilization and society, but believed that there’s potential ways to satisfy one’s self. Unlike Nietzsche who saw the outer struggle not the nature of the human, who focused more on what the society, religion who led to frustration

    Read More

  • Civilization and Its Discontents, by Sigmeund Freud

    851 Words  | 2 Pages

    In the first two chapter of the book, Freud explores a possible source of religious feeling. He describes an “oceanic feeling of wholeness, limitlessness, and eternity.” Freud himself is unable to experience such a feeling, but notes that there do indeed...

    Read More

  • Anna Freud: A True Child Advocate

    1550 Words  | 4 Pages

    In the summer of 1915, Anna Freud established personal success as she successfully passed her teacher's examination. (Dyer, 1983) At this time, her career path differed from that of her father, Sigmund. Anna displayed early indications of a desire to work with children, whereas her father’s work was primarily focused on psychoanalysis of adults. She began translating her father's works into German. When the Freud Family vacationed separately, Anna would write to her father asking clarifications of psychoanalytic terms. While Anna displayed the qualities of a more than apt pupil of her father’s life work, her endeavors and efforts would establish her preeminence as a child psychoanalyst, an adept researcher, and a teacher. According to Dyer, (1983) Anna’s readings and translations of her father’s works marked the beginning of her direct involvement with the work of her father.

    Read More

  • Comparing Wolff And C. S. Lewis's Mere Christianity

    1268 Words  | 3 Pages

    The purpose behind a writer’s work is as diverse as the writer themselves. It is safe to assume that a writer of a fictional novel has a different purpose than a writer of a nonfiction book. This is the case with Tobias Wolff and C.S. Lewis. Both well known authors, Wolff and Lewis have completely different styles of writing, and therefore, different purposes behind their writing. Wolff’s memoir,

    Read More

  • Erich Fromm: Psychoanalysis and Religion

    562 Words  | 2 Pages

    Erich Fromm in his psychoanalytical approach to religion is distinct from the earlier works of Sigmund Freud. Fromm defines religion as “any system of thought and action shared by a group which gives the individual a frame of orientation and an object of devotion.” Fromm argues that irreligious systems including all the different kinds of idealism and “private” religions deserve being defined as a “religion.” Based on Fromm’s theory, it is explained that there is no human being who does not have a “religious need,” almost every part of human life reflects religious need and its fulfillment, in fact he states it to be “inherent” in man.

    Read More

  • Religion In T. S. Lewis Till We Have Faces

    643 Words  | 2 Pages

    “Religion is regarded by the common people as true, by the wise as false, and by the rulers as useful.” In the novel, Till We Have Faces, Lewis contrasts religion based on the “gods and goddess” and religion that the different characters believe in. He does this by comparing the “gods and goddess” to the religion. He contrasts the two by having the characters switch opinions within the novel. Gods and goddesses actions vs the view that society has of them.

    Read More

  • Sigmund Freud and Psychoanalysis

    2351 Words  | 5 Pages

    Sigmund Freud was born in 1856 in Moravia, which was then part of the Austrian Empire and is now in the Czech Republic. He spent most of his life in Vienna, from where he fled, in 1937, when the Nazis invaded. Neither Freud (being Jewish) or his theories were very popular with the Nazis and he escaped to London where he died in 1939.

    Read More

  • How Did Freud's View Of The Changes During The Enlightenment

    1009 Words  | 3 Pages

    Sigmund Freud was born in the Austro-Hungarian Empire. He was born into a Jewish family in 1856. As a child growing up, Freud wanted to attend medical school to become a neurologist. His object of study and his entire life's work was destined to be the exploration of man's unconscious mind. Freud believed that our conscious thoughts are determined by something hidden know as our unconscious impulses. Freud recognized the irrational as a potential danger. He believed irrationality was a "comprehensible object of science." Man was said not to be a rational being, guided by inner forces. Sigmund Freud's philosophy was that a man's actions are not always rational. And such an idea flew in the face of the ideals of the Enlightenment in no less a way than had Nietzsche's notion that "God is dead." Sigmund also concluded that people are not good by nature. Humans are people that's instincts provoke aggressiveness. Influenced by World War I and its aftermath, Freud broke away from the Enlightenment era and his philosophy that stated that man was inherently good. Along with Freud, many artist and writers followed as they rebelled against traditional artistic and literary ways. With this movement, it created what is now known as Modernism.

    Read More

  • Freud and Darwin

    723 Words  | 2 Pages

    Between the mid-19th century and the mid-20th century scientific progress was growing steadily. Two scientists, Darwin and Freud, made significant contributions to their field. Both scientists developed theories which altered the way people thought in many ways. Between 1850 and 1950, traditional ways of thinking about religion, morality, and human behavior were changed by both Charles Darwin and Sigmund Freud.

    Read More

  • A Brief Biography of Sigmund Freud

    667 Words  | 2 Pages

    Sigmund Freud was born on May 6, 1856 in Freiberg, Moravia. His father, Jacob Freud who was a skilled wool merchant married Amalia Freud who is Sigmund’s mother. Amalia was twenty years younger when she and Jacob married. Sigmund was the first child of eight children, but Jacob his father had two children in his first marriage. Sigmund’s father was born into a Jewish family and left home to get away from the normal Jewish tradition. When Sigmund was four, they moved away from Freiberg to Vienna where he lived most of the rest of his life at. In 1865 when Sigmund was only nine years old he entered high school. He excelled especially well and graduated with honors. While he was in high school he learned and was proficient in German, French, Italian, Spanish, English, Hebrew, Latin, and Greek.

    Read More

  • Sigmund Freud Case Study

    1159 Words  | 3 Pages

    The life of Sigmund Freud was a very interesting one, when he was four years old, his family had moved from Pribor, Czech Republic to Vienna and he lived there until he had died. Sigmund was the first of seven children in his family and out of the seven children his mother favorites him the most. Freud later on explains knowing that he was his mothers favorite that, a man who is the absolute favorite of his mother has a feeling for his entire life, that he is a conqueror and has confidence of success that often leads to real success in life. Basically, stating the point that, because his mother throughout his childhood loved and cherished him the most, this feeling or drive motivated him to think that he could be successful, which he did accomplish

    Read More

  • Sigmund Freud Essay

    666 Words  | 2 Pages

    Freud was born in May 6, 1856 in the Czech Republic. He attended Spurling Gymnasium. At Spurling, he was first in his class and graduated Summa Cum Laude. After studying medicine at the University of Vienna, he gained respect while working as a physician. Freud and a friend were introduced to a case study that resulted in no cause, but they found that having the patient talk about her experiences had a calming effect on the symptoms. That was considered to be the beginning of the study of psychology.

    Read More

More about Freud and C.S Lewis: Opposite Points of View on Religion

Open Document