For many historians, the Malleus Maleficarum is the main significant text that inspired the beginning of the witch trials in early modern Europe, and is responsible for influencing a change in the times were the issue of witchcraft went from a small matter amongst people to a driving force of mass witch hunts and trials. Michael Bailey takes a different approach by citing Johannes Nider’s Formicarius (1437) as the text that influenced this change and inspired the beginning of witch trials and witch hunts in early modern europe. In Battling Demons: Witchcraft, Heresy,, and Reform in the Late Middle Ages, Bailey claims that Nider’s Formicarius was so influential for a number of reasons, but his main argument is that it was through Nider’s desire …show more content…
to reform and the reform of the christian church itself, morally and spiritually, that inspired the shift in the increase of witch hunts and witch trials. In Formicarius, Nider includes stories that address three main concerns that he has, and with tales and stories he aims to reform the morality and the spirituality of christian society, by teaching and informing members of christian society of these concerns in the world around him. Bailey goes on in great detail to explain this, and does so in part by claiming that as part of reform, Nider, “combined his opinions of witchcraft as the same as necromancy and common maleficarum, which was not complete subjugation to satan, but there was no distinction made between the two”. (142) Bailey also goes on to say that withchart was a heresy in itself, and heresy trials commonly ended up resulting in witch trials as reformation took place. Throughout this work, Bailey explains why Formicarius was so influential, with one reason being that this work, “is a work of reform”.
(92) Formicarius was created to be used in church sermons and that it was created at the time witchcraft was emerging, and is the only work that was written at that time. (32) Formicarius is significant as it, “shaped european thought on witchcraft for centuries to come” when it was included in other works after it's time that discussed witchcraft. (91) The work itself is a collection of stories Nider was told, and the stories are up to interpretation, and it a key source in religious studies and helpful in understanding, “religious life in the fifteenth century”. (92) Bailey makes it clear that Nider was a reformist who was not interested in trying to encourage people to, “return to strict observance”, but a reformist who was concerned about the morality and spirituality of christian society. Nider had a desire to reform a basic level of, “moral and spiritual regeneration among the faithful at all levels of christian society” (92) Nider wanted to reform christian society as a whole, and had a major concern for threats to christian society. These threats included, “visionary and demonic experiences”, and his focus on these threats came to be through his concerns for christian society and, “eventually led to the matter of witchcraft”. (95) Nider, even though he was an elite member of the clergy, did not make bold judgments or claims …show more content…
on the, “moral state of the world”, but he did focus on a few non traditional virtues, including “chastity and virginity, visionary experiences and maleficent power of demons in the world”. (102) These three virtues ultimately shaped the way people saw and understood witchcraft. The fact that Nider had a concern about women and the virtues of chastity and virginity ultimately led to women being more often classified as witches than men were. Nider, like most of those who are medieval authorities, believed that the morality of woemn was direcntly connected to their sexulaity. Nider believed that women were weaker than men, and were therefore more likely to be tempted to not remain pure and be virtuous and moral in these ways. Bailey makes a note that this view of Nider “informed his views on witchcraft” , but it did not make him want to explore witchcraft. In Formiacrus there is little written explicitly about witchcraft at all, but witchcraft went against the moral values that Nider had a concern for, and in turn Nider’s reformist work influenced and led to the increase in witch trials, witch hunts, and a fear of witchcraft amongst society. Visionary and demonic visions was another crucial part of Formicarius. In this work, Nider included stories of divine visions, positive visions, but also stories of demonic visions to show examples of demonic power, to show that it is a real power and even though it was rare,it did exist in the world . (115) Nider viewed demons as, “foes of reform and the special enemies of the reformed or observant religions orders” (115). Demonic power is a concern for Nider not only as a cleric and because of the obvious reason that demons oppose God, but to show Christian society how, “vulnerable” they were to demonic power being that even religious orders were at risk to this power. Nider addresses these concerns in Formicarius and has a desire to reform christian society to encourage people to refrain from, “improper behavior and inspire them to greater faith”. (117) In doing so, and especially by warning people about demonic power and vulnerability, he warned people about the threat of witchcraft, which led to the great increase in witch hunts, witch trials, and “pious terror” of witchcraft. (117) In addition to informing people, another purpose of Nider’s work Formicarius was to teach people how to respond when they face, “sorcerous and ultimately satanic assaults on their bodies, their worldly goods and their very souls.” (120) As a reformist, Nider also defined good and and bad behavior, to decipher between, “valid practice and vain superstition”.
(120) Reformers were the first to persecute heretics and witches, as both heretics and witches opposed morality and religious practices, however for Nider prosecution was only one way to combat abuses and he prefered positive ways of correction, such as “stressing the value of the lay religious mode of life over the potential dangers of single beguines or the heresy of the free spirit” (122) The prosecution of witches was of course a common practice lter on, which in part has to do with the fact that “witchcraft was more than a form of heresy” (122) as they are more threatening because they can they not only oppose religious teachings but they can cause “very real harm”. (122) Nider was very concerned with the fear of real harm, the concern of witches being agents of satan, and what could be done to handle the effect of witches, but was not in his writings concerned with protecting them. (122) Witches were considered demons, and not all heretics were witches, such as the Hussites. With witchcraft considered as a heresy, heresy trials often resulted in witch trials. However, the connection between witchcraft and
heresy that was forged in the fifteenth century was is the idea that Nider’s desire to reform led people who were now more informed to to have a greater fear of the concerns that Nider included in Formicarius, especially a greater fear of demonic power, and as fear spread and increased so did the number of trials for hersey, which resulted to witch trials. This is not the case and Bailey describes this a red herring. Instead, Bailey tells readers that Nider was a reformist who was not looking to eliminate abuses or threats, but to encourage people to rejuvenate their faith and to impose positive morals. (144) In conclusion, Johannes Nider’s Formicarius is influential, in Bailey’s view, because this work was a work of reform used to reform the morality and spirituality of christian society. Furthermore, this work informed christian society of the concerns that Nider saw in the world and with more people being informed of the risks around them and their vulnerabilities, such as the threat of demonic power, people's faith was rejuvenated, and even more importantly, it inevitably led to the “pious terror” of witchcraft as the concerns that Midler had coincided with witchcraft and witches, or workers of satan with demonic power. The essential connection between heresy and witchcraft is that witchcraft in itself was a heresy, but it was so much more as it is a more serious matter because not only were witches going against religion, but they were doing and performing harmful acts. I think Nidler was very wise to write Formicarius by including stories of witches and stories that expressed Nider's concerns, because in doing so it in a way validates what he was aying. However, I think it is important to realize that Nidler is only one person, and his work of course is based off of his word and experiences alone. This being the case, I think it's important to remember that there is a chance of bias, especially as an elite cleric.
Were the witch-hunts in pre-modern Europe misogynistic? Anne Llewellyn Barstow seems to think so in her article, “On Studying Witchcraft as Women’s History: A Historiography of the European Witch Persecutions”. On the contrary, Robin Briggs disagrees that witch-hunts were not solely based on hatred for women as stated in his article, “Women as Victims? Witches, Judges and the Community”. The witch craze that once rapidly swept through Europe may have been because of misconstrued circumstances. The evaluation of European witch-hunts serves as an opportunity to delve deeper into the issue of misogyny.
In Exodus 22:18, it says “Thou shalt not suffer a witch to live.” It was chaos In Salem, Massachusetts, during 1692, 19 people were accused and hanged and one brutally pressed. this is because the puritans believed almost everything the bible said. One subject that the bible covers, is that the Devil is real and really clever, and is able to enter a normal person's body and turn them into a witch. There are three interconnected causes that might have caused the drama, and panic that was the Salem witch trial hysteria, which are: age, gender, and marital status, lying girls and they’re folk tales they made up, and a divided town.
Many accuse John Proctor being the cause of the Salem Witch Trials. If he did not cheat on his wife then Abigail would not have such an anger towards the world. But, if it was not for Tituba those girls would have never been in the forest, she would not have been accused, and Tituba would not have confessed to a lie. Tituba is the “Gas to the Fire”, she may not be the cause of the witch trials, although, she is a large contributor to all of the problems. She wanted nothing more than to save her own life but she did not realize that all of the deaths that were to come all began with her.
(Ray p.32). However, as more fragments of textual evidence occur, historians are making new evaluations of how the witch trials were exaggerated by recent literature. Some historians like Richard Godbeer,
Woodward, Walter “New England’s other Witch-hunt: The Hartford Witch-hunt of the 1660s and Changing Patterns in Witchcraft Prosecution” OAH Magazine of History, 2003. 8. Cavendish, Richard. The. “A History of Magic” New York, 1977 pg 69-79 9.
Throughout the late 17th century and into the early 18th century witchcraft prosecutions had been declining. This trend was the result of a multitude of social developments which altered the mentality of society. One of the predominant factors in this decline was the Scientific Revolution, the most important effect of these advances was making society question concepts of witchcraft. Along with this new mental outlook, we see that the Reformation had a similar effect on social opinion concerning witchcraft and magic. These two developments changed societies view on the occult and this led to a wider scepticism concerning witchcraft, this favoured those who had been accused and therefore caused a decline in prosecutions. Beyond the two trends mentioned however, it is important to consider judicial reforms and an improved socio-economic situation which reduced tensions within society. These two changes were certainly not as influential as the Scientific Revolution and the Reformation but heavily altered the circumstances in which accusations were normally made. With the altered social attitudes and mental outlook these changes in living situations all contributed to bring about the decline in witchcraft prosecutions.
Once the accusations began, many innocent people in the community were taken away. They were then either forced to admit that they were witches, to free themselves from a public hanging, or deny that they were witches, saving their integrity, but subjecting themselves to an unjust public hanging.
Hinds, Maurene J. Witchcraft on Trial: From the Salem Witch Hunts to the Crucible. Library ed. Berkeley Heights, NJ: Enslow, 2009. Print.
Religious influence, the manipulation of fear, and the frightening aspects of witchcraft all are very influential to the popular belief of witchcraft during this time period. The popularity of witchcraft in this time period is important because it has shown how in the past when there is no logical explanation they would automatically blame Satan and say it was Satan’s doing. It also shows that history repeats itself because during the Cold War many individuals were accused of being communist even though there was no hard evidence proving this accusation; however, out of fear people will still be convicted, just like during the witch trials. Moreover, witch trials were not only influenced by many things but they have been influential; therefore, showing that they influenced things in our time
The term witchcraft is defines as the practice of magic intended to influence nature. It is believed that only people associated with the devil can perform such acts. The Salem Witch Trials was much more than just America’s history, it’s also part of the history of women. The story of witchcraft is first and foremost the story of women. Especially in its western life, Karlsen (1989) noted that “witchcraft challenges us with ideas about women, with fears about women, with the place of women in society and with women themselves”. Witchcraft also confronts us too with violence against women. Even through some men were executed as witches during the witch hunts, the numbers were far less then women. Witches were generally thought to be women and most of those who were accused and executed for being witches were women. Why were women there so many women accused of witchcraft compared to men? Were woman accused of witchcraft because men thought it was a way to control these women? It all happened in 1692, in an era where women were expected to behave a certain way, and women were punished if they threatened what was considered the right way of life. The emphasis of this paper is the explanation of Salem proceedings in view of the role and the position of women in Colonial America.
The Salem Witch Trials were a time in history where people were wrongly accused of being witches. In the spring of 1692 the Salem witch trials began. During the trials women were wrongly accused of being witches. When accused of being a witch they were tortured, tested, put on trial, and most of the time executed if not put in jail. The townspeople tortured the accused witches in the most inhumane ways. This was a very dark and eerie time for the Puritans in Salem, Massachusetts (P., Shaunak).
The Salem Witchcraft was a series of undesirable events, which was powered by paranoia and fear. Though several witch trials occurred before the Salem Witch Trial, this was the most well known of all. Many innocent people were accused of witchcraft which resulted to 19 men and women that were hanged, 17 innocents that died in unsanitary prisons, and an 80-year old man that was crushed to death by putting stones on top of his stomach until he confesses (movie: The Crucible). In some accounts, it was reported that two dogs were stoned to death for cooperating with the Devil. Why did the Salem Witch trial occur? Were these trials appropriate? Or were they truly a Devil's work? The Salem Witch Trials might have occurred for a variety of reasons such as people's ignorance that led to superstitions. It might have also occurred because people's crave for power, or it might also be because of fear.
The epoch of Medieval European history concerning the vast and complicated witch hunts spanning from 1450 to 1750 is demonstrative of the socioeconomic, religious, and cultural changes that were occurring within a population that was unprepared for the reconstruction of society. Though numerous conclusions concerning the witch trials, why they occurred, and who was prosecuted have been found within agreement, there remain interpretations that expand on the central beliefs. Through examining multiple arguments, a greater understanding of this period can be observed as there remains a staggering amount of catalysts and consequences that emerged. In the pursuit of a greater understanding, three different interpretations will be presented. These interpretations, which involve Brian Levack’s “The Witch-Hunt in Early Modern Europe,” Eric Boss’s “Syphilis, Misogyny, and Witchcraft in 16th-Century Europe,” and Nachman Ben-Yehuda’s “The European Witch Craze of the 14th to 17th centuries:
For many centuries to the present day, Christians have lived in fear of witches. They were known as to be the devils child who only practiced black magic and thought of as the Christians “persecution”. Witches have been known to mankind since the 1200’s. Throughout the 1400’s, the examination of witches was more focus and moved from the Jews. In the church’s law, it was stated that the belief of existence and practices of witchcraft was “heresy”. Because of what the Christians believed, churches would then torture and hunt down anyone who they thought were witches and killed the many women and only a few of the men. They even made them make the confession of flying through the midnight sky, being in love with the devil himself, practicing black magic and even turning into animals.
Witchcraft persecution peaked in intensity between 1560 and 1630 however the large scale witch hysteria began in the 14th century, at the end of the Middle Ages and were most intense during the Renaissance and continued until the 18th century, an era often referred to as the Enlightenment or Age of Reason. Representation of witches, nay, representation in general is a political issue. Without the power ot define the female voice and participate in decisions that affect women -similar to other marginalised groups in society- will be subject to the definitions and decisions of those in power. In this context, the power base lay with men. It can be said that the oppression of women may not have been deliberate, it is merely a common sense approach to the natural order of things: women have babies, women are weak, women are dispensable. However the natural order of things, the social constructs reflect the enduring success of patriarchal ideology. As such, ideology is a powerful source of inequality as well as a rationalisation of it. This essay will examine the nature of witchcraft and why it was threatening to Christianity.