Have you ever seen a Utopian society? if one thought so they are wrong! In the book The Giver by, Lois Lowry, a future society tries to become Utopian. Their failures begin to unfold with the event called the Ceremony Of the Twelves. This is when the elevens become adults. Their assignments are chosen for them by the chief elder. The elders make rules for the rest of the society,but how could this be viewed as a Utopian society? Jonas’s society is dystopian because they abuse kids, no one has freedom of choice, and there is no joy in the society. The civilization abuses kids in Jonas’s society because they want to be a utopian society. The chief elder conveys to the audience “‘Especially” she says chuckling “the difference between snack and …show more content…
smack. Remember, Asher?’ (54). That means when Asher was little his instructor smacks Asher with a punishment wand when he says a wrong word. Also Jonas’s society is dystopian because they also release babies,although they release babies they will release the lighter one,but they have to release the lighter one because and they can’t have two of the same person or else the society will get jealous and the society will want a person like them as well, and the society will break out into a big argument, after there will be war also it will be dystopian just because of the jealousy of the twin babies, therefore that leads to freedom of choice, because the twins didn’t have any freedom or choice but to force one getting put in the chamber for release. Their is no freedom of choice in Jonas's society. The society has no freedom of choice because it is ruled over one monarchy, and that monarch is the chief elder. The chief elder makes all of the decisions like what job to put each kid in, when the holidays are, and she also decides which elder should be released on what day. She also chooses which kid gets what job, She explains “‘Jonas has not been assigned,” she informed the crowd, and his heart sank. Then she went on “Jonas has been selected’” (60). There is also no freedom of choice in Jonas’s society because there isn't any real feelings in the society, which means that they can’t choose to feel feelings freely usually they never experienced real emotions in the society. One of the big emotions that aren’t experienced in Jonas’s society is joy. There is no joy in Jonas’s society because there is Sameness in the society.
The chief elder thinks Sameness is better because she thinks it makes the society more Utopian than joy. Sameness is bad for the society because what Sameness does is that it makes everyone's life miserable because everything is always the same there is no fun and happiness in Sameness. Jonas explained, “‘But now I can see colors,at least sometimes, I was just thinking: what if we could hold up things that were bright red, or bright yellow, and he could choose? Instead of the Sameness” (98). That means that Sameness takes away all of the glorious colors,however with joy there is happiness and fun in joy because with joy you get to experience new possessions, explore the world, be yourself, moreover there is endless limits with joy. But they have Sameness instead which limits your exploration in life, also you get to experience the same old boring trappings in Sameness, and finally with Sameness you can never really find your true inner colors. To sum it up Jonas's society is dystopian because They have no freedom to choose what they say or do in life,but it is already chosen for them. They abuse kids with rulers for saying an improper word. Finally they don’t have joy in the society, but instead they have Sameness which isn’t fun and is boring. The actual real world is dystopian, but can you help make the world a little more
utopian?
Living in a perfect world is like living in an anthill. An ant does not think on it’s own, make it’s own decisions, and doesn't really have any own identity, just like the utopians. It is not worth living in a perfect world. The utopian society we are introduced to in the book, The Giver, has many different characteristics that make the perfect life unbearable. Examples of these things are The Receiver, the community, and the chief elders.
He starts to believe that a world of sameness where no one can decide or make choices for themselves is boring. Lois Lowry is warning readers that living in a world of sameness is not something to create as it is boring and dull, but if the world follows conformity and does not value diversity and difference enough, society could become that of Jonas’s. When he turns twelve, his job for the rest of his life is decided as the Receiver. His job is to receive all the memories the previous Receiver has held on to. While this is beneficial for Jonas as he is able to leave the society and his job of the Receiver behind and get freedom, the community is left without someone to take the memories from The Giver.
Despite people have more choice and freedom, for those who do not have a protected society, valuing individual needs, would result a negative effect for the people. So, did the society that Jonas lives in, produce more positive or more negative results? In Lois Lowry’s, The Giver, Jonas’s community has a well-organized society with a very structured and safe life. “I knew that there had been times in the past-terrible times-when people had destroyed others in haste,in fear, and had brought about their own destruction” (48). In the old days, when people in Jonas’s community valued individual needs, there were lots of terrible happenings: violence; and then the society ended up by having general welfare by having safety. It is difficult for us to think of a world without color, freedom, music and love, but in The Giver, the society denounces these things in order to make room for peace and safety. In The Giver, by having a society based on general welfare they gave safety to their people. No violence, no criminal activities nor homicides. In Jonas’s community, everyone has the sameness. Therefore, General welfare leads a society into an outstanding democratic society by giving all the qualities from the
What determines a society to be either a utopia or a dystopia? Would it be everyone following the rules? In the book The Giver, by Lois Lowry, a new “Utopian” culture blossoms from the previously failed society. The Giver’s nation starts out with the intention of creating a utopian society; however, the strict limitations turn it into a dystopia where there are receivers, like Jonas, that hold the good and bad memories from the past culture. Jonas will experience great pain and great joy through his job as the Receiver instead of the whole community sharing the burden. The Giver’s world is a dystopia because of the following three reasons: they kill people that disobey the rules, they do not get to pick their own jobs, and, above all, they beat children if they do not use precise language.
Think about a community where you can’t marry someone of your choice, you can’t choose your own job, and you can’t have your own kids. This sounds like a unbearable place to live, but there is one like this and it’s in the book The Giver by Lowis Lowry. This type of community would be considered a dystopia, even though some of the citizens think it is a utopia because they don’t need to worry about a lot of regular-to us - things in their lives. The people of the controlled community in The Giver get harsh punishments for small errors, the citizens don’t get to experience any emotions, and they kill or release innocent newchildren.
Jonas and his family take care of Gabe, a new child that the council of elders are undecided to release. When Lily is watching Gabe play with his comfort object, she wants to become a birthmother, but her mother scolds her since “There’s very little honor in that assignment” (21). Both of the populations are based on the kind of job somebody else has. His community is dystopian, along with modern day society, in choosing jobs that increase or decrease the citizen’s status. Ryanair airlines’ employees are backlashing because of unparalleled ideals. Avinash Bhunjun, a writer for the Metro UK, states that “Around half of Ryanair pilots based in Ireland are due to strike in a dispute over worker’s rights” (https://www.metro.co.uk ). The majority of workers are finding the inhospitality of their society. Civilians in modern communities are fighting for freedom as a result of poor treatment. In modern day and Jonas’ dystopian nations, a laborer has been stripped from the standard ideology that they should be equally paid and respected in any
The story in The Giver by Lois Lowry takes place in a community that is not normal. People cannot see color, it is an offense for somebody to touch others, and the community assigns people jobs and children. This unnamed community shown through Jonas’ eye, the main character in this novel, is a perfect society. There is no war, crime, and hunger. Most readers might take it for granted that the community in The Giver differs from the real society. However, there are several affinities between the society in present day and that in this fiction: estrangement of elderly people, suffering of surrogate mothers, and wanting of euthanasia.
On the surface, Jonas is like any other eleven-year-old boy living in his community. He seems more intelligent and perceptive than many of his peers, and he thinks more seriously than they do about life, worrying about his own future as well as his friend Asher’s. He enjoys learning and experiencing new things: he chooses to volunteer at a variety of different centers rather than focusing on one, because he enjoys the freedom of choice that volunteer hours provide. He also enjoys learning about and connecting with other people, and he craves more warmth and human contact than his society permits or encourages. The things that really set him apart from his peers—his unusual eyes, his ability to see things change in a way that he cannot explain—trouble him, but he does not let them bother him too much, since the community’s emphasis on politeness makes it easy for Jonas to conceal or ignore these little differences. Like any child in the community, Jonas is uncomfortable with the attention he receives when he is singled out as the new Receiver, preferring to blend in with his friends.
Throughout history, people had made numerous futile attempts to create an Utopian society. The term "Utopia" depicts on an imaginary ideal state. Such a state is describe in The Giver. In The Giver, Jonas's community believes in the renunciation of personal properties, rights, one's unique characteristics and of binding personal relationships (such as marriage). This society is believed to be perfect, free of pain and sorrow; everything is under control and "same". This serene society greatly contradict with the one we live in. Our society is furnished with hatred and warfare, yet in return, we are given freedom and the privilege of having distinctive characters. Given the nature of human beings, our society is more idealistic to live in.
Lowry writes The Giver in the dystopian genre to convey a worst-case scenario as to how modern society functions. A dystopia is an “illusion of a perfect society” under some form of control which makes criticism about a “societal norm” (Wright). Characteristics of a dystopian include restricted freedoms, society is under constant surveillance, and the citizens live in a dehumanized state and conform to uniform expectations (Wright). In The Giver, the community functions as a dystopian because everyone in the community conforms to the same rules and expectations. One would think that a community living with set rules and expectations would be better off, but in reality, it only limits what life has to offer. Instead, the community in the novel is a dystopian disguised as a utopian, and this is proven to the audience by the protagonist, Jonas. Jonas is just a norma...
The book The Giver is a Dystopia because the people in their community have no choices, release and because the people don't know or understand what life is. The world in the beginning of the book seems like a utopia because how smoothly it runs but it actually is a dystopia because no world or place ever is perfect. This place or the givers world still has many flaws.
...s us to celebrate our differences. We also realise that we live with the same kind of memories that Jonas struggles to carry, every day of our lives. Although the fact that the memories are new to him makes it harder for Jonas to bear the pain, it also makes it easier for him to appreciate the beauty of the little things. We, on the other hand, being familiar with the sensations, do not cherish them as much as we should. None of us savors the warmth of sunshine or the beauty of snow the way Jonas does. Perhaps we need the darkness of the night to appreciate the brightness of the moon.
The government wants everybody to be the same. In order to do this they eliminated knowledge so they don’t know what they are feeling. People can’t have feelings or show emotion. In the beginning Montague said “I am very much in love, he trued to conjure up a face to fit the words” (Bradbury, 20). People don’t feel any emotion but they attempt to show it, usually it doesn’t turn out rite. The people in the book feel like they are married to a stranger, they couldn’t even remember where they met! Additionally Betty states, “We must all be alike. Not everyone born free like the constitution says”(Bradbury, 55). In this part Betty is talking about how if everyone feels the same and is basically the same then the happier they will be. There wont be any racial tensions or heart breaks, because they are all the exact same. This is only one small problem in a dystopian society.
Jonas’ community chooses Sameness rather than valuing individual expression. Although the possibility of individual choice sometimes involves risk, it also exposes Jonas to a wide range of joyful experiences from which his community has been shut away. Sameness may not be the best thing in the community because Jonas expresses how much he feels like Sameness is not right and wants there to be more individuality. Giver leads him to understand both the advantages and the disadvantages of personal choice, and in the end, he considers the risks worth the benefits. “Memories are forever.”
Louis Lowry’s The Giver uses a dystopian society as a metaphor to show how one lives without pain and lacks knowledge of other places in order to give the reader a warring that society will never be perfect. “The Giver offers experiences that enhance readers levels of inquiry and reflection.” (Friedman & Cataldo pp102-112) At First glance the novel's setting seems to be a utopia, where all possible steps are taken to eliminate pain and anguish. Often the difference between a Utopia and a Dystopia is the author’s point of view. The difference between dystopia society and a utopian society is that a “dystopia is a world that should be perfect but ends up being horrible. Imagine dystopia as a world where the government gives everything to everyone for free. You would think it would be perfect, but imagine if that government oppressed everyone. Essentially a Dystopia is a utopia that has been corrupted.” (Levitas p1) A dystopian society is “Any society considered to be a undesirable, for any number of reasons. The term was coined as a converse to a Utopia, and is most used to refer to a fictional (often near-future) society where social trends are taken to a nightmarish extreme. Dystopias are frequently frequently written as warnings, or satires, showing current trends extrapolated to a nightmarish conclusion. A dystopia is all too closely connected to current day society.” As defined in The Giver (Telgan pp162-182). This is why I believe that Lowery is giving the reader a warring about how our world is changing. We have the power to stop it before it happens if we listen to warring signs and act accordingly. If we don’t listen to those signs our society will become a nightmarish environment, to live in. “ The Giver demonstrates how conflict can force us to examine our most important beliefs about what is right and true. Conflicts can change our worldly view of thing.” (Freidmane & Catadlo pp102-112)