Durkheim's Theory Of Anomie Tell Us About Immigration And Crime

1179 Words3 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Essays on cause and effects of homelessness on the individual and society

What does Durkheim’s Theory of Anomie Tell Us about Immigration and Crime?
This paper analyzes the relationship between immigration and crime using Emile Durkheim’s theory of anomie. The research shows that rapid cultural and social changes lead to the destabilization of traditional societies and norms become influx which leads to social disorganization. Immigrants are often identified as the architect of social breakdown especially increases in crime. Through organic solidarity, modern societies can learn to tolerate differences and restore social order. The paper uses evidence of immigration and crime research to explain the reasons why immigration is linked to crime even though empirical evidence tells a different story. The disintegration …show more content…

It is from the concept of anomie that Merton developed his social theory of order. According to Merton, “aberrant conduct may be viewed as a symptom of disassociation between culturally defined aspirations and socially structured means… certain aspects of the social structure may generate countermores and antisocial behavior precisely because of differential emphases on goals and regulations”(674). Merton’s contention was that human beings live in a world whose resources are greatly limited. The process of the distribution of resources is not usually equitable and leads to contentious social relations. Limitations in resources is manifest in all societies even the most affluent which can lead to conflict when new members join a particular culture and makes claims to the new society’s resources. Merton observed that the route to achieving social cohesiveness and desirability leads to anomie and …show more content…

The promise of free markets and liberal democracy pushes individuals to migrate to industrialized Western nations like the United States and in some cases with very limited means of copying with the new cultural and economic realities. It is important to note that social disorganization does not just happen within the group of immigrants. Dissatisfaction can also lead to the anomic state in the native groups. The failure to realize economic goals is a recipe for social upheaval and to a larger extent contributes to deviance which manifests itself in crime. Thus we observe in the promise of liberal democracy inconsistences that can lead to social problems like

Show More
Related

  • Nothing Like It in the World by Stephen E. Ambrose

    1220 Words  | 3 Pages

    Bucerius, Sandra and Tonry, Michael. The Oxford Handbook of Ethnicity, Crime, and Immigration. New York: Oxford University Press, 2013. Print.

    Read More

  • Criminological Movie Fargo

    1459 Words  | 3 Pages

    Merton recognised that individuals receive messages from society, which set acceptable behaviours to follow. He noted that a majority of citizens abide the acceptable behaviours, though there are numerous pressures that associate with the American Dream and the importance of the economy, which leads individuals to participate in deviant behaviours. Merton associated criminality and deviance with the American Dream goals, and how people attempt to achieve them, particularly the wealth component (Murphy & Robertson, 2008). Merton argued in 1938 that within unbalanced societies, the discrepancy between success goals and the endorsement of the means to achieve the goals, combined with limited opportunities manufactured the state of anomie. Further, Merton suggested that the anomic conditions in society were likely to tempt strain upon individuals, forming criminal behaviour adaptations. Particularly, the strain theory emphasised that those with high monetary aspirations are likely to innovate, resorting to unlawful activities, with the desire to channel success (Antonaccio, Gostjev & Smith, 2014). The strain theory connects to social causes, linking criminality with selfishness and egoism as the desire to

    Read More

  • The Devil's Highway Chapter Summary

    946 Words  | 2 Pages

    Immigration and crime can often time combine due to the laws that are continuously created. The membership theory presented by Juliet Stumpf in chapter 2 of Governing Immigration Through Crime. Membership theory proposes that a person’s rights and privileges are only obtainable to those who are a part of a social contract with the government (Dowling & Inda, 2013, p. 60). It is believed that positive actions can occur when this takes place. Now, the membership theory uses two tools of the sovereign state for this to be achieved: the power to punish and the power to express moral condemnation (Dowling & Inda,2013, p. 60). When applying this belief to immigration law, legal and illegal have stringent explanations between them. As stated

    Read More

  • Life-Course Perspective And Strain Theory In Boyz N The Hood

    1210 Words  | 3 Pages

    Merton’s theory consists of five things. Conformity is when one accepts conventional goals and strive to earn those goals through socially accepted means. The kids in the neighborhood, their shared beginning, could most likely not afford to attend college at USC. So some of them could apply for a community college. But realistically college was not a common goal for the kids, completing high school and going was even struggle. In their shared beginning we see innovation the most. The people accepting cultural goals, but rejecting the accepting way of achieving them. Instead of getting a job to have these means, they often resort to selling jobs or living off of robberies. They want money and items money can buy, but they do not want to have a job or work. This relates to all of the gang activity we see. Parents in the neighborhoods however, can be applied to ritualism. Single mother’s working one or two minimum wage jobs to support their families. They gave up on achieving the goal, but they still continue to practice the socially accepted practices for obtaining jobs. They are working these minimum wage, under-paid jobs forever to support their family. While some parents ae resulting to ritualism, even more result to retreatism in these communities. They are completely rejecting the accepted ways of achieving goals. Drug addicts and alcoholics are a common scene in the movie, those people fit into this category. Gangs which are the most common theme and factor in the movie is compared to rebellion. These people reject accepted goal and means, while replacing them with new ones. Gang activity in the movie in a sense of family and acceptance by creating their own goals and

    Read More

  • Immigrants in Upton Sinclair 's The Jungle

    779 Words  | 2 Pages

    A well-discussed debate among today’s economy is the issues concerning immigrants and their yearning desire to become American citizens. As displayed in The Jungle, a rather perturbing novel about the trials and ruthless temptations early America presents to a Lithuanian family, adjusting to new surrounding and a new way of life is quite difficult. To make matters worse, language barriers and lack of domestic knowledge only seems to entice starvation and poverty among newly acquired citizens, who simply wish to change their social and economic lives to better themselves and their families.

    Read More

  • Satire Essay About Immigration

    1390 Words  | 3 Pages

    Natives who oppose the entrance of immigrants into their nation offer several reasons in favor of the abolishment of immigrants. They argue that immigrants are the reasons for drug trafficking, when over 80% of drug traffickers are natives. They argue that immigration increases crime rate, yet most studies comparing crime rates and

    Read More

  • The Transformation of Immigrant Parents and Children

    1789 Words  | 4 Pages

    Immigrants are defined as people who permanently move to a forgiven country from their origin country. Immigrants can move for the purposes of seeking better living, better education, or in order to avoid any sort of issues in their origin country. Despite the reasoning behind the decision of the movement, an immigrant will be affected by the change of culture, way of life, social system and community. The process of the movement effects each individual differently depending on their, age, gender and their level of connection to their past culture. Having that said, the younger the age of the individual, the more venerable and easily they become to changing their way of life in order to feel a part of a community. Gender however is also related to the race of the person. To elaborate, females and black males are more open to the idea of changing any of their factors to adjust to their ‘new society’. An individual’s connection with their past culture, has a great impact on their personality and their standing and belief in their values, morals and culture. Therefore, the stronger and deeper the connection with their original culture and way of life, the more satisfied the individual becomes. Therefore, they don’t feel the urge to compete with another culture. Therefore, their current standing with their own culture has a strong impact on their future judgment on other culture. The weaker the connection the more prone they are to changing their current culture. Thus, an individual’s stability level towards their culture depends on other factors that are concerned with them. [Different age groups are faced with different situation that leads them to deal with different issues and therefore they are exposed to different kinds of expe...

    Read More

  • The Relationship Between Race and Crime

    659 Words  | 2 Pages

    Crime has always been a hot topic in sociology. There are many different reasons for people to commit criminal acts. There is no way to pinpoint the source of crime. I am going to show the relationship between race and crime. More specifically, I will be discussing the higher chances of minorities being involved in the criminal justice system than the majority population, discrimination, racial profiling and the environment criminals live in.

    Read More

  • Assimilation into the United States

    1819 Words  | 4 Pages

    Immigrants leave their countries in search for a better life and improvement of their situation. There is no singular reason for immigration; motivations range from better economic prospects to political safety. As of late, the number of immigrants living in the United States is an estimated 11 million. Those who immigrate are expected to contribute to the United States culturally, politically, and economically. Yet, full assimilation becomes difficult to achieve when the immigrant is made into “the other” by the country of reception.

    Read More

  • The Latino Paradox Case Study

    1156 Words  | 3 Pages

    The notion that recent Latino immigrants are harbingers of crime and adverse social behaviors has no basis in truth, and in fact, it has been shown that immigrants may in fact have an opposite effect on neighborhood crime. In his article, Sampson (2008) considers the concept of the “Latino Paradox” – the fact that Hispanic Americans often score higher on a wide range of social indicators than expected (including those related to crime), given their socioeconomic disadvantages – comparing and contrasting it with his research collected on Latino immigrant populations in Chicago. Through a case study in 180 Chicago neighborhoods, Sampson suggested that higher rates of immigration in a neighborhood effectively reduces crime rates. The researchers found a significantly lower rate of violent crime among Mexican-Americans compared to Blacks and Whites in the same areas.

    Read More

  • Immigration Sociology Essay

    1052 Words  | 3 Pages

    Immigration has been a topic that has caused multiple discussions on why people migrate from one country to another, also how it affects both the migraters and the lands they go. Immigration is the movement from one location to another to live there permanently. This topic has been usually been associated with sociology to better explain how it affects people, cultures and societies. Sociology has three forms of thinking that are used to describe and analyze this topic. There are three forms of thinking that are used to tell and describe immigration to society; structural functionalist, symbolic interactionist, and conflict theory. Each of these theories uses different forms of thinking and rationality to describe and explain socio topics.

    Read More

  • Immigrants Into America

    3181 Words  | 7 Pages

    Since the creation of the United States of America, immigrants from all backgrounds have sought refuge, a home and a life in this country of prosperity and opportunity. The opportunity of freedom to exercise natural rights is a large pull factor that causes many people to come to America. Others come because it is a country where one can prosper. Prosperity of people in a country, however, is a more challenging phenomenon to explain than opportunity. Immigrants seek economic, social and educational as well as cultural prosperity. The question of how to gain such prosperity is a difficult one to answer. Some immigrants come to America, cast off their past identity and attempt to find a new, less foreign one. By assimilating to American culture with this new identity, they start a long and treacherous journey to seek prosperity in a land vastly different from the one they once called home. Many will gain educational, economic and social prosperity, but never gain cultural prosperity. Assimilating to American culture so hastily, some immigrants are never able to explore and keep up with their cultural backgrounds. Their families grow up and became Americans, never cognizant of their given up ethnic identities. Those immigrants, however, who are able to gain cultural prosperity through the help of other immigrants of their respective background, become integrated into American society while keeping their ethnic identity. This is the sort of opportunity that the United States of America has provided new arrivals since its founding. Although many immigrants become overwhelmed with American culture and assimilate into it, those who contribute to a working ethnic society are able to dela...

    Read More

  • Immigrants Do NOT Increase Crime Rates

    2225 Words  | 5 Pages

    The thought of arriving immigrants in any host country has been accompanied by reactions of exclusion, and continues to expand throughout the years. During any social illness, immigrants tend to be the first to be held responsible by their recipient societies. Most crimes are associated with immigrants due to the fact that they may not posses the same socio-economics status as natives. Another contributing factor is the media that conducts numerous stories that highlight the image of immigrant crimes to recall the alleged difference between native and foreign born. Undoubtedly, the correlation between immigration and crime has become one of the most controversial discussions in current society. As we enter a new era, immigrants will have more impact on society than ever before (Feldmeyer, 2009).

    Read More

  • Emotivism Essay

    1128 Words  | 3 Pages

    It is well known among both immigrants and Americans that there is an immigration problem in the United States of America. Where the problem lies with most Americans is that there is a right way to enter the country and a wrong way, most individual draw their conclusion of immigration with emotivism. There is "About 11.7 million immigrants are living in the United States illegally, a population that has not varied much over the last three years but may recently be increasing again, according to new estimates published Monday by the Pew Research Center Hispanic Trends Project." Preston, (2013). We will approach this from a variety of aspects. We will look at how immigration stated in America, When immigration became a problem, some of the negatives and positives illegal immigrants bring to America, and finally what looks like the best way to move forward in the future with immigration.

    Read More

  • Strain Theories of Criminal Behaviour

    2001 Words  | 5 Pages

    Featherstone, R., & Deflem, M. (2003). Anomie and strain: Context and consequences of Merton’s two theories. Sociological Inquiry, 73(4), 471-489.

    Read More

More about Durkheim's Theory Of Anomie Tell Us About Immigration And Crime

Open Document