Does Pip Deserve His Fate

2031 Words5 Pages

Imagine being born into a life where the likeliness of reaching success is fairly small and it seems there is no other choice but to accept that fate because everyone else has seemed to survive it. The characters, Pip, from Great Expectations by Charles Dickens, and Eliza Doolittle, from Pygmalion by George Bernard Shaw, found themselves in a life of the lower class and would not settle with the consequences living life in the lower class. After a less than perfect life, Elisa and Pip both run into opportunities to change their fate from lower class failures to upper class ladies and gentlemen. In order to give life to their dreams, Pip and Elisa have to put their fate in the hands of an upper class gentleman, and once they are no longer in …show more content…

For Pip, it seems like there is no way out and he will forever be bound to his destiny of becoming a blacksmith, and the idea of this fate is unsatisfying to the young Pip. Pip does not expect his fate to change, but he would be glad to take any opportunity to change it. After a night at the pub with Joe and Mr. Wopsle, Pip runs in to Jaggars, a well known lawyer in London, who delivers news that restores hope in the hopeless young Pip; “‘I am instructed to communicate to him,’ said Mr. Jaggers, throwing his finger at me sideways, ‘that he will come into a handsome property. Further, that it is the desire of the present possessor of that property, that he be immediately removed from his present sphere of life and from this place, and be brought up as a gentleman...’" (Dickens 18). The offer Jaggars presents to Pip would allow him to escape his destiny as a blacksmith at the forge, and become the gentleman of his dreams in London. With this new life, Pip also has to throw away his old life and have no control over what he does in London because he will sent there to become a gentleman and nothing else, but at that point, anything is satisfactory in Pip’s eyes. Much like Pip, Elisa is trapped in the lower class life and unsatisfied with the direction that her life seems to be moving. Elisa’s English is so poor that she has …show more content…

From the outside, people in the upper class are wealthy and can have anything they dream of in the blink of an eye, causing happiness to come easy to them. In reality, the more money someone has doesn’t necessarily determine that person’s happiness, and Pip and Elisa realize this once their happiness actually decreases as a member of the upper class. After returning home and talking to Biddy, Pip realizes he could marry Biddy, instead of Estella, because she has always been a good friend to Pip and would never cease make him happy; “ [i]f you can like me only half as well once more, if you can take me with all my faults and disappointments on my head, if you can receive me like a forgiven child...And now, dear Biddy, if you can tell me that you will go through the world with me, you will surely make it a better world for me, and me a better man for it..." (Dickens 57). Pip hopes that Bibby can see past how terrible he was to both her and Joe once he gained his fortune and love him for how he used to be. Pip did not control how wealthy he became, and society in the upper class causes him to see the lower class, and everyone who brought him up, in a different light, causing him to turn his back on them and in result, them turning their back on him as well. Since Pip was forced into the upper class, he failed to capture Estella’s heart and at the same time ruining his

Open Document