Although Holden’s rather cynical language, negative attitude, and troubled past are all aggravating, the majority of readers are bothered most by the fact that Holden is not a reliable narrator. Because Holden does not wish to look beyond one’s physical appearance, he sees no difference in anyone but himself, as he is convinced he is the only person with complexities. In the novel, the reader is only allowed Holden’s end of the story; therefore, every event is based on his thoughts and experiences, and thus, the audience must form conclusions based on these particular opinions and ideas alone. Furthermore, Holden often seems to be at odds with other characters in addition to being extremely incapable of making correct judgements about his …show more content…
own behavior throughout The Catcher in the Rye. "Because of this inconsistency between what Holden wants other people to be and what he is himself, many readers find the boy a far from a sympathetic character and declare that he is no model for our young people to emulate” (Bloom 57 Salinger). While Holden’s thoughts and actions are unquestionably misleading, it is his inconsistencies that make him a compelling and captivating character all throughout The Catcher in the Rye. While Holden’s inconsistencies remains significant, perhaps his greatest flaw is his inability to openly be honest and tell the entire truth.
In elaboration, it is because Holden is in a crisis throughout the duration of the book that he seems to always feel the need to create a lie rather than tell the truth. He even proclaims himself untruthful at the beginning of the novel, admitting, “I'm the most terrific liar you ever saw in you life” (Salinger 16). Holden even gets so comfortable with the act of lying that he sometimes does it for fun and pure entertainment. There are dozens of examples which illustrate his compulsion to lie to the people around him. One such instance of this prolific lying is when Holden meets his school mate’s mother on the train into New York City. He first introduces himself under a fictitious name and then proceeds to tell Mrs. Morrow what a wonderful son she has, despite the fact he actually despises him because he is a bully. As Engel says, "Although Holden does not seem to think that the sort of lie he tells is destructive, he is quick to pounce on institutional lies" (56). In elaboration, these impersonal and coherent fibs are completely unnecessary and ineffective. Additionally, Holden lies to everyone about the actual reasons he was kicked out of school, including his little sister, Phoebe. However, the most important aspect of the novel is the fact that Holden compulsively lies to himself. He consistently tells himself he can run away from his problems and avoid confrontation with his parents; however, this ultimately damages him much more than any lie he could tell to another human possibly could. Overall, Holden’s continuous lying undoubtedly damages his credibility and the reader’s ability to trust what he is saying. However, it is not until the end up the novel that Holden reveals he has been hospitalized, calling to attention his serious unstable state of mind which forces the reader to ask themself if their
perception on Holden Caulfield has been a complete misunderstanding the whole time. When evaluating Holden Caulfield more thoroughly and on a deeper level, one’s perspective of him suddenly shifts from an annoying pessimist to a simply misunderstood teen. Holden is able to view society more objectively since he is certainly alienated from it. Nevertheless, Holden genuinely wants to make friends throughout the entire novel, as his human nature, but he simultaneously refuses to conform in many cases throughout the story because he sees no rational reason behind the majority of social activities. Due to the lack of this nonconformity, he is frequently misunderstood as “rude”, “lazy”, or “disrespectful.” As Engel points out, "He alienates himself by choice, sometimes because he cannot stand the company of others, sometimes because he becomes disappointed with their company, and sometimes because his actions seem calculated to drive others away” (45). Holden is more than aware of his own growing faults, which is exactly why he tends to isolate himself from those who have expectations of him. Some critics may say Holden only avoids situations involving girls because of his lack of self confidence, however, “Holden Caulfield does not merely avoid members of the opposite sex, he avoids most social contacts” (Huber 1); this includes his parents, friends, and also former teachers. Furthermore, although Holden remains extraordinarily introverted, he is obviously desperate for companionship and affection. Another common misconception about Holden is that he acts and behaves the way he does merely for attention, but this could not be farther from the truth. In reality, "Holden Caulfield is too troubled a young man to honestly enjoy feeling superior to others, but many readers only see the brashness and none of the humility” (Engel 54). Furthermore, Holden Caulfield is an adolescent teen struggling to discover his own identity and independence; the last component he would be searching for is scrutiny from his fellow peers. As Bloom explains, "Many people who read too much of themselves into the novel do not seem to realize that Holden is not seeking admiration, but the understanding that will help him through a difficult period" (58 Holden), just as most teens are, not only back then, but in today’s society as well. Not only do people and readers have a total misunderstanding of Holden, but Holden is likewise confused by his actions and by his true purpose is in this world. Mr. Antolini tells Holden later in the novel, "I have a feeling that you're riding for some kind of terrible, terrible fall.... The whole arrangement designed for men who, at some time or other in their lives, were looking for something their own environment couldn't supply them with... So they gave up looking” (Salinger 187); implying that he believes Holden cannot find exactly what he is looking for, even though, with Holden, he is not even sure what that is. Mr. Antolini is one of the last people Holden feels he can confide in, but his paranoia gets the best of him even when, "Though he is readily welcomed by Mr. Antolini, Holden is left traumatized by what he considers a homosexual advance by his former teacher. The last bastions of refuge, having unraveled before his eyes, lead tragically to a nervous breakdown and his institutionalization in a mental health facility” (Bloom 187 Holden). It is at this point in the novel when the open-minded reader cannot help but to empathize with Holden and all he is struggling with, and subsequently, only desire the best for him. Overall, "Both Holden's nihilistic view of life as it is and his notion of what life ought to be are based on a misunderstanding of man's place in the universe” (Engel 45), and until Holden can find his place he will feel equally as confused and lost as the person attempting to evaluate his character.
Again, this is one of the few people that Holden likes and doesn’t consider a phony like everyone else. He talks highly of her and he sees himself in her in the way that she alternates between behaving like an adult and behaving like a child, the way he says he also does. It bothered him greatly when she asks him if he “got the ax again,” referring to his expulsion. She starts asking him questions about his future and what he likes (if he likes anything at all) and it forces him to wake up. Everyone has been telling Holden to realize his situation and put more effort into schoolwork and relationships and to start caring. Holden’s reality is very simple: he wants to be the catcher in the rye to protect children’s innocence and stop them from growing up because all adults are phonies. Again and again, being told that that isn’t plausible annoys him. He feels betrayed, when his own sister, someone who he thought would understand him, joins everyone else in telling him to put forth more
The origins of Holden’s disillusionment and the reason that it all started is the death of his younger brother which he was very fond of and admired, Allie, three years ago. The death of Allie is very significant in Holden’s mind since it is an event which he remembers quite clearly at multiple occasions during the book. For example, when Holden is writing a descriptive composition for his roommate Stradlater, he decides to write about Allie’s baseball mitt since it is the only thing on his mind. “My brother Allie had this left-handed fielder’s mitt. He was
Compulsive lying is another characteristic that Holden exhibits. Holden would tell people lies just so they could not become closer to the real Holden. Holden tells lies on numerous occasions to gain. Holden pathetically tells Mrs. Morrow, " I have to have a tiny operation… it isn't very serious. I have this tiny little tumor on my brain" (58). She tells Holden that she is very sorry and she is hopeful that he shall be well soon. Holden then catches him self in a lie and he remarkes, "Once I get started, I can go on for hours if I feel like it," (58). This compulsive lying shows that Holden is not satisfied with himself and that he feels that people will judge him critically.
Holden experiences both alienation and disillusionment when meeting with people like Sally Hayes, Sunny and Ackley. Holden is so desperate to have human connection yet, when he starts to talk to them, he experiences them as ‘phonies’. This makes him more depressed, continuing his downward spiral. Holden is caught in a trap of his own making.
In the novel Holden is what you would call an unreliable narrator. The definition of unreliable is - a person or thing that cannot be counted on or trusted. You cannot trust Holden if you know that he lies all the time. Since the reader knows that he is a habitual liar you may never know the difference from when he is telling the truth or when he is telling another one of his stories. Holden goes in and out of mental lapses throughout the novel that affected his mind and psychological state greatly.
... is apparent that he is a troubled young man through not only what is said and done, but what is also left as unspoken thoughts inside his mind. Holden Caulfield is, beyond a shadow of a doubt, mentally unstable. He is not classified as a "crazy person" or a "loon" but he is a young man who, as a child, had innocence and purity ripped away with no warning or mercy. Instead of reacting more positively and growing older at a young age, the tragedies caused him to year for the innocence of childhood that he knew in some dark corner of his mind had been long gone and was never returning regardless of how much faith and stubbornness he had.
Thesis: Holden Caufield is a hostile, negatively charged character that suffers from depression which stems from a desire not to grow up and a lack of closure in his brothers death."If you really want to hear about it, the first thing you'll probably want to know is where I was born, and what my lousy childhood was like . . . "(pg. 1) These first words that Holden Caufield communicates during his tell of events that brought him to his breakdown, show the pent up hostility that still lingers. This pattern of speech, the constant expression of negativity, is a character trait of Holden that shows his inner anguish.
...common in human beings, and the demonstrations that have been considered in this term paper are not the only examples that live in the novel that call up the difficulty of considering with change. believe about Holden lowering out of yet another school, Holden departing Pencey Prep and, for a while, dwelling life in the cold streets of New York town all by his lonesome. The book ends abruptly, and gathering condemnation of it is not rare. It's an odd cliffhanger, not because of the way it's in writing, but because of a individual desire to glimpse what Holden finishes up doing with his life. Perhaps, as he augments up, he'll learn to contend better through change. Imagine the death of Phoebe, decisively an event that would be similar to Allie's tragic demise. if an older Holden would reply the identical as did a junior one, is a inquiry still searching for an answer.
Holden Caulfield can be analyzed through his thoughts, actions and circumstances which surround his everyday life. Holden acts like a careless teenager. Holden has been to several prep-schools, all of which he got kicked out of for failing classes. After being kicked out of the latest, Pency Prep, he went off to New York on his own. Holden seems to have a motivation problem which apparently affects his reasoning. The basis of his reasoning comes from his thoughts. Holden thinks the world is full of a bunch of phonies. All his toughs about people he meets are negative. The only good thoughts he has are about his sister Phoebe and his dead brother Alley. Holden, perhaps, wishes that everyone, including himself, should be like his brother and sister. That is to be intelligent, real and loving. Holden’s problem is with his heart. It was broken when his brother died. Now Holden goes around the world as his fake self, wearing his mask. Holden is looking for love, peace and understanding. He is scared to love because he is afraid he might lose it like he did with his brother. That is the reason for Holden's love of the museum, he feels safe because it never changes it always stays the same. Holden is troubled with the pain of death, it effects every aspect of his life causing him to not care about the future, himself or anyone, except Phoebe and Alley.
...one of us faces the struggles of growing up. We can either complain and rant and blame everyone else, or we can stay positive and try our best to rise above the challenges. Holden showed me how we can keep grumbling and keep whining, but that is not going to make the situation better. We should not let our hardships and challenges defeat us, but rather we should conquer our challenges. It is so much better if we stay positive in facing our challenges than if we just complain and whine about our hardships. Holden, despite his bitterness, is a character that has surprisingly inspired me to be more positive in facing my life’s challenges. After reading this novel, I really hope that the ‘Holdens’ of today will realize that being pessimistic and isolated is not cool; I hope they will be able to grow up someday and face their challenges in a more hopeful, positive way;
that he is trying to hide his true identity. He does not want people to know who he really is or that he was kicked out of his fourth school. Holden is always using fake names and tries speaking in a tone to persuade someone to think a cretin way. He does this when he talks to women. While he is talking to the psychiatrist he explains peoples reactions to his lies like they really believe him, when it is very possible that he is a horrible liar and they are looking at him with a “what are you talking a bout?” expression. Holden often lies to the point where he is lying to him self.
Some critics have argued that Holden’s character is erratic and unreliable, as he has many of the middle-class values that he claims to reject. Later on critics began to have praised the twisted humor of the main character. These critics have commented that the structure of the novel helps you understand Holden’s unstable state of mind. Alastair best remarked: "There is a hard, almost classical structure underneath Holden’s rambling narrativ. The style, too, appears effortless; yet one wonders how much labor went into those artfully rough-hewn sentences" (qtd. in Davis 318)
Upon introduction, Holden Caulfield gives the impression of being a textbook teenage boy. He argues that Pencey Prep, the all-boys academy at which he studied, is no greater than any other school and is “full of crooks.”(Salinger, 7) His harsh language only further argues that he is situated in an all-male environment and has no apparent filter for when swearing is inappropriate. Despite all of the indications that Holden is typical, it soon becomes evident that Holden’s personality does not conform to the teenage stereotype. Although he appears to have some friends, namely, his roommate, Stradlater, and ‘Ackley kid’, it is clear that he does not integrate well with his peer group. Holden’s inability to read social cues leaves him in the dust when all of his “friends” have matured enough to recognize his need for improvement. He is constantly making jokes out of everything without any thought as to how h...
...’s habitual lying relates back to times where he is hypocritical about his environment being full of phonies. Salinger provides these small details of deceitfulness in order to further advance Holden’s character and the work as a whole.
Holden doesn’t like the complexity of life and relationships. This is why he distances himself from his family and friends. After Holden is expelled from his school, he tries to stay away from his parents for fear of their reaction, even though learning of his expulsion is inevitable. He visits his sister Phoebe in their home multiple times throughout the novel because due to her young age, his sister and his relationship is simple. "For instance, within Holden, the desire to reject others conflicts with the desire to be accepted by others: he doesn't want to lend Stradlater his coat, but his overt actions belie this covert, warring want: he despises Ackley, but he invites him to see a movie; he hates movies, believing them to foster phoniness in society” (Mitchell). Holden struggles to “catch” others because he believes he is not accepted by others.