Deconstruction of Thank You, Ma’am

710 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Implications of moral development in teaching

Deconstruction of Thank You, Ma’am

There are a million acts of kindness each day. Some young man gives a stranger a compliment, or a teacher brightens a students morning. But, in the world we live in today, these acts are rare to come by. In this short story Thank You, Ma’am, the boy, out of mysterious luck, gets taken in by the woman whom he was trying to steal a purse from. Her actions, following the incident towards the boy, may have seemed very kind and understanding, but the boy needs a more solid way of punishment. He requires discipline that will show him that as complicated as life is, there will not always be someone for you to lean and depend on.
The first and most foremost thing that would come to mind when reading this story is how caring Mrs. Luella Bates Washington Jones was, that she took in the boy and nurtured him; she tried to teach him between right and wrong. She gave him food, a nice conversation, and even a chance of escape, which he chose not to take, but these methods are still an immoral way of handling the situation. If a boy were to come up to an everyday woman on the streets, that victim would not be as sensitive as Mrs. Jones was to the boy she caught. To teach a young man that if you steal and you are going to get special treatment is not an effective method of punishment.
First of all, the boy told Mrs. Jones that he tried to steal her purse for one reason, to buy blue suede shoes for himself. She then replies, “Well you didn’t have to snatch my pocketbook to get some blue suede shoes... You could have just asked me.” There are many faulty choices of judgments made in this comment, mainly because the outcome of the situation would almost never happen in the real world. The boy will now, after being told he should just ask for the shoes, believe that anything he ever wants will come to his possession if would just ask. To “trick” a child into being convinced that if you just ask a woman for money or anything that she will give it to you is morally wrong, and it is not fair for the boy to go through life having and accepting this state of mind.

Show More
Related

  • A Stolen Life by Jaycee Lee Dugard

    893 Words  | 2 Pages

    A Stolen Life by Jaycee Lee Dugard is an autobiography recounting the chilling memories that make up the author’s past. She abducted when she was eleven years old by a man named Phillip Garrido with the help of his wife Nancy. “I was kept in a backyard and not allowed to say my own name,” (Dugard ix). She began her life relatively normally. She had a wonderful loving mother, a beautiful baby sister,, and some really good friends at school. Her outlook on life was bright until June 10th, 1991, the day of her abduction. The story was published a little while after her liberation from the backyard nightmare. She attended multiple therapy sessions to help her cope before she had the courage to share her amazing story. For example she says, “My growth has not been an overnight phenomenon…it has slowly and surely come about,” (D 261). She finally began to put the pieces of her life back together and decided to go a leap further and reach out to other families in similar situations. She has founded the J A Y C Foundation or Just Ask Yourself to Care. One of her goals was, amazingly, to ensure that other families have the help that they need. Another motive for writing the book may have also been to become a concrete form of closure for Miss Dugard and her family. It shows her amazing recovery while also retelling of all of the hardships she had to endure and overcome. She also writes the memoir in a very powerful and curious way. She writes with very simple language and sentence structures. This becomes a constant reminder for the reader that she was a very young girl when she was taken. She was stripped of the knowledge many people take for granted. She writes for her last level of education. She also describes all of the even...

    Read More

  • Summary Response 17: The Rights To The Streets Of Memphis

    287 Words  | 1 Pages

    Mrs. Wright made the narrator get the groceries, even with the chance of being beaten up. She stated, “Go now! If you come back into this house without those groceries, I’ll whip you!” I believe that she was wrong to do this because although it did teach him to stand up for himself, it got the message across through violence. Children should not learn that violence is the answer to get their way, which I believe this lesson taught the narrator. This experience also made the narrator extremely frightened both in the home environment and the outside environment. The narrator exclaims, “[Mrs. Wright] slammed the door and I heard the key turn in the lock. I shook with fright. I was alone upon

    Read More

  • Frederick Augustus Washington Bailey's Life

    677 Words  | 2 Pages

    Growing up, Frederick Bailey dealt with a harsh slave life. His grandmother raised him, and he rarely saw his mother. All slaves slept on the ground with no extra comforts, like blankets or pillows. Frederick was only entitled to one t-shirt yearly and he witnessed lashings of other slaves. Most slaves on the plantation pick cotton and worked from dawn to dusk. All slaves were fed small corn oriented meals. At the age of eight, Frederick was sold to a slave-owner by the name of Master Auld. Master Auld owned a house in the city of Balitmore. Although he was still separated from most of his family, he was given a full set of clothes and a bed to sleep on. Slaves in the cities were treated different from slaves of the plantations. While the slaves of the plantations were treated with little respect, city slaves were seen as show dogs. You had to make your slave look the best in your neighbor’s view. Here, Frederick Bailey learned to read from poor white boys whose payment for a lesson was a piece of bread or any other food. At age twenty, Frederick ran away to New York City, New York. Many slaves, at the time, ran away t...

    Read More

  • Blood Types And Carbohydrates Essay

    873 Words  | 2 Pages

    According to Karen C. Timberlake, “every individual’s blood can be typed as one of four blood groups” (556). The differences in blood is what makes every human body different from the next. Studies have shown that “people have either blood group A, B, AB, or O, with each type occurring at different frequencies in populations around the world” (Ananthaswamy 15). An individual with one type of blood cannot share blood or organs with an individual of a different blood type. Failure to distinguish different blood types can cause reject when a patient receives the wrong type from a donor. Certain methods are used in determining what type of blood a patient has. However, there are certain blood types that can accept any type of blood, and there are also blood types that can be used for any type of patient. There are many different characteristics used for categorizing blood, such as blood types, agglutination, carbohydrates, antigens and antibodies.

    Read More

  • Cultural Criticism of Barn Burning by William Faulkner

    825 Words  | 2 Pages

    the most important literary elements in the story. He takes a young black boy and puts

    Read More

  • Analysis Of Black Boy By Richard Wright

    1068 Words  | 3 Pages

    Richard is defining himself as a black boy in the Jim Crow South, but he is also open to the ideas and separate interpretations to further his knowledge on what exactly that means for him. Richard’s writing reflects his experiences, direct or indirect, like Bigger with his incarceration, and himself on discovering true segregation and unequal rights. The theme of Black Boy is paradoxical because is it unknown as to whether he will ever discover the secrets behind becoming a black man, and not only a black man, but a black man who had grown in the middle of the entire dispute. The book share violence but in the most informative way; without the violence the true South would not have been expressed in the novel, and as a reader you could not grasp his emotions on the topics he presents on himself like how he had suffered but his suffrage was caused by his own mothers suffrage and so on. A man is not born a slave, but a man is made a slave. Richard had become a slave to society in trying to do all things right, but also trying to flee the South and head North as if the South has still been a branch of slavery and

    Read More

  • To Kill A Mockingbird Growing Up Analysis

    541 Words  | 2 Pages

    Tom Robison is a Negro male that gets hand caught in a cotton gin. Tom is being accused of raping a young female named Mayella.Tom Robison is a Negro male that gets hand caught in a cotton gin. Tom passed by Mayella’s house everyday, she seemed to always have something for Tom to do. He claims that he is just being nice to her because nobody else would. Mayella seems to be a lonely girl ,with no friends her age ,she stays to her self. In court Mayella is easily angerd by Atticus questions she even got mad when he referd to her as ma’am and Ms. The town knows whats goin on but refuse to believe it, simpily because of there hatred towards

    Read More

  • Kindred

    397 Words  | 1 Pages

    In the middle of the night, four white men storm into a cabin in the woods while four others wait outside. The cabin belongs to Alice and her mom. The four men pull out Alice’s father along with her mom, both are naked. Alice manages to scramble away. The men question Alice’s father about a pass, which allows him to visit his wife. Her father tries to explain the men about the loss of the pass but the men do not pay any attention to him. Instead they tie him to a tree and one of the white man starts to whip him for visiting his wife without the permission of Tom Weylin, the “owner” of Alice’s father. Tom Weylin forbid him to see his wife, he ordered him to choose a new wife at the plantation, so he could own their children. Since Alice’s mother is a free woman, her babies would be free as well and would be save from slavery. But her freedom “status” does not stop one of the patroller to punch her in the face and cause her to collapse to the ground.

    Read More

  • Angels in America

    2053 Words  | 5 Pages

    Angels in America is one of the most powerful plays written in the twentieth century. The play explores themes such as AIDs, homosexuality, drug addiction, spirituality, politics and identity specifically during the 1980’s. This ground breaking piece of work is not only entertaining, but also thought provoking. Angels creates dreamlike envisions of scenes and yet maintains a form of realism in the plots and characters. Tony Kushner is both the author of the play and the screen writer for the brilliant rendition of the HBO mini series with the same name. Angels in America Part 1: The Millennium Approaches is a phenomenal piece of work to read as well as to watch! The story follows a variety of characters in New York City between 1985-1986 dealing with issues of homosexuality, sexual disease, addiction, and denial.

    Read More

  • Noise Induced Hearing Loss Essay

    452 Words  | 1 Pages

    Noise is ubiquitous in our environment. (Pediatrics , 1997) It is undesirable sound, unwanted sound. Sound is what we hear. It is vibration in a medium, usually air. Sound has intensity, frequency and duration. The ability to hear sounds at certain frequencies is more readily lost in response to noise. (Pediatrics , 1997). The further you are from sound the less effect you hear it but the more closer you are to sound the louder it is.

    Read More

  • The Human Blood Transfusion

    1588 Words  | 4 Pages

    The Mayo Clinic defines a blood transfusion as “a routine medical procedure in which donated blood is provided to you through a narrow tube placed within a vein in your arm”. The first human blood transfusion on record was conducted by Dr. Jean-Baptiste Denys, a French physician during the late 1600’s. Although Denys’ transfusions weren’t sound proof and often written off as unorthodox, he unknowingly ushered in a new era of medicine and laid the foundation for modern advances in Hematology. I choose this topic because I volunteer to donate blood four times a year alongside thousands of other people. On average these donations help save 4.5 million Americans that would die in a years’ time without a blood transfusion. These generous people

    Read More

  • Death of The American Dream

    761 Words  | 2 Pages

    Most of the story takes place in flashbacks that Willy experiences. Willy believed that he would’ve been able to achieve the American dream, which to him was to become a salesman, specifically similar to Dave Singleman, that could easily sell anything to anybody, if he worked hard enough for it. In the end this proved to not be a successful endeavor, and he dwells on the idea that if in the past he went with his brother to Alaska, he may have come out as successful and rich as he supposedly had. As stated in Cardullo’s reproduction of an essay written by David Mamet, some of Willy’s flashbacks may be inaccurate accounts of the past, as Willy seems to contradict himself, even immediately following something that he says, "I'm very well liked in Hartford. You know, the trouble is, people don't seem to take to me" (Cardullo). This demonstrates that perhaps Willy had no chance of ever reaching the American dream, as he may not have ever had the opportunity to go with his brother, he just thinks that he did.

    Read More

  • Frederick Douglass Reflection

    227 Words  | 1 Pages

    The book titled, “Incidents in the Life of a Slave Girl” has opened my eyes to the history of slavery and the conditions slaves had to endure during that time. Before reading this book, I learned about the encounters of slaves through few books or narratives written by people who had experienced slavery firsthand. One narrative I read was titled “Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass”. The narrative accounts the life of Frederick Douglass and the hardships he had to face as a slave such as watching his own family member being flogged. This narrative portrayed the many aspects of his life working on the plantation and how he successfully escaped to freedom. This narrative and the other books commonly talked about the violence that slaves

    Read More

  • Childhood Trauma: The Tragic Story of Jürgen Bartsch

    851 Words  | 2 Pages

    Till he was six years old he was allowed to go out only in the company of his grandmother and even then he was not allowed to play with other children or get dirty. In other words the boy grew up without the contact to other peers and friends. This also had consequences on the beginning of school. Because he did not know anybody, he did not have any friends and therefore he was the whipping boy of the first classes. At home he was pushed from one corner to the other. His parents did not have any time for him and they have beaten him for no reason. Once his mother threw even a meat knife at him. As he barely avoided the knife, his mother starts to yell at him and says: “This is a bad boy who lets that someone throws a knife at him and then simply avoids

    Read More

  • Blood Transfusion Essay

    2222 Words  | 5 Pages

    Blood transfusions have become a common part of medical care with nearly 5 million Americans a year receiving a transfusion. Blood transfusions are used in the treatment of many different conditions, from replacing blood lost in surgeries or injuries to fighting diseases like liver disease, anemia, and bleeding disorders like hemophilia (Nglbi.nih.gov, 2014). Blood collection and transfusion are overseen by many different agencies including the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). Through these agencies work in donor screening and surveillance, blood transfusions usually cause no adverse reactions in the recipient and are considered a safe medical procedure. Despite this, blood safety remains an important public health matter both due to the seriousness of some adverse reactions when they do occur and the need for preparedness in reacting to future blood safety issues that can suddenly arise when new bloodborne diseases emerge. It is for these reasons that Healthy People 2020 has made reducing the proportion of averse reactions from the medical use of blood and blood products one of their objectives.

    Read More

More about Deconstruction of Thank You, Ma’am

Open Document