Wait a second!
More handpicked essays just for you.
More handpicked essays just for you.
Dead Poets Society analysis Essay
Rhetorical analysis of dead poets society
Criticism dead poets society
Don’t take our word for it - see why 10 million students trust us with their essay needs.
Recommended: Dead Poets Society analysis Essay
Introduction A mentorship is relationship where a mentor helps facilitate a mentee to develop and, eventually achieve, their goals (Jones, & Goble, 2012). This is through the mentor applying their own skills to give guidance and support to the mentee until the mentor is not required, due to the mentees confidence and growth (Zachary & Fischler, 2012). A valuable mentorship follows four stages preparing, occurring before the mentoring has begun, negotiating, which develops the relationship’s ‘ground rules’, Enabling, where goals are set and learning is performed, and closure, which allows for a healthy and prepared conclusion (Zachary & Fischler, 2012). The 1989 film Dead Poets Society explores such a relationship between mentor Mr Keating and mentee Neil Perry, his student (Weir, …show more content…
Undertaking Mr Keating’s class, Neil discover Mr Keating is an unconventional teacher who encourages and inspires Neil to find meaning in his life and most importantly “carpe diem” (Weir, 1989). Although, when a mentoring relationship like Neil and Mr Keating, has a mentee with a disability the stages must be adapted and personalised in order to accommodate for a range of diverse learning needs (Curryer, Stancliffe & Drew, 2015). Preparing The first stage of an effective mentoring relationship is preparation, where the mentor and mentee ensure they have the ability, time, and compatibility to successfully undertake their roles (Zachary & Fischler, 2012). However, this phase is sometimes skipped yet it has been shown that mentoring programs which involve a formal training day produce more positive goal outcomes (Bellon, Gardner, & Riley, 2008). Mr Keating and Neil’s preparing phase can be considered unique as due to being a teacher, Mr Keating may have some formal leadership training (Weir, 1989). Although as the mentorship was formed innately, no formal training for their specific relationship was undertaken (Weir, 1989). Mr Keating’s clear intention was to inspire his students and
there would not have been a reason for it to happen in the first place.
The time is 1959, the hundredth anniversary of the founding of Welton Academy. Welton is a sort of Ivy League training school. The boys of Welton Academy are dutiful sons, their lives arranged by Mom and Dad like connecting dots. They need only move assuredly from point A, Welton, to point B, Harvard or Oxford, to point C, a prestigious law firm/corporation/band. However, that does not stop their new English teacher from encouraging them to break the pattern. With a contagious passion for verse and a lust for life, Keating exhorts his students to think for themselves. Then avocation that they strip themselves of prejudices, habits and influences.
Spencer, R., Collins, M. E., Ward, R., & Smashnaya, S. (2010). Mentoring for young people
Director Peter Weir, director of The Truman Show, presents the importance of individuality and speaking up in his movie Dead Poets Society, a fictional but realistic story that tells the story of a group of friends at the Wellington Academy prep school and their interactions with their new English teacher, John Keating (Robin Williams). Keating teaches the boys life lessons through some interesting teaching methods that end up changing his students’ approach to life’s challenging situations. Throughout watching Dead Poets Society, I found myself liking the movie more and more as it progressed.
First and most importantly, Mr. Keating’s teachings affected Neil Perry in both negative and positive ways. For example, Mr. Keating told Neil to follow his passion for acting. Although this may seem like a positive influence, it is a negative influence. By following his passion, Neil disobeys his father, which is an act a child should never do. In addition, Neil’s inspiration from Mr. Keating makes him decide to reestablish the Dead Poets Society. Again, this is might seem positive, but it is a negative influence. By reestablishing the Dead Poets Society, he is challenging the school’s authority. Furthermore, Neil tries to tell his father his true feelings about being “controlled.” This would be a positive influence because it shows that Neil has gained some courage. Courage is a good value that should be encouraged because it allows an individual to speak up for their beliefs. Summing it up, Mr. Keating had a negative and positive influence on Neil; however, he has done more harm than good.
“Set honor in one eye, and death in the other, and I will look upon both indifferently.” This quote from Brutus catches the essence of Whelton Academy. It claims the parents’ and school’s view of honor as fatal. From all the stress parents weigh upon students at Whelton, they have no choice other than to conform into what their parents want them to be. Conform to fit their parents definition of honor. For the kids at Whelton, this means adopting the humdrum realistic philosophy. In order to do so, students are forced to enroll in specific classes, pursue certain hobbies, get into an Ivy League college, and essentially, live the life their parents want them to live. Neal Perry was one to realize how such a dreadful fate truly was. Todd Anderson was another, and nearly all kids at Whelton shared this epiphany once Mr. Keating came in to teach. His teachings were based off of Romantic beliefs, beliefs that stated one could do whatever they please. Opening the idea of Romanticism to a school that had forever been realistic had set off a battle. A battle between Romanticism and Realistic beliefs. This continuous tug-a-war of philosophy was demonstrated throughout the movie Dead Poet’s Society. Hence, the progression of romanticism is perfectly shown through skepticism, distinctiveness, and self-reliance.These attributes counter three of the school’s original four pillars of character; honor, tradition, and discipline. Excellence though, is the one both have in common, in which Romanticism opens a new, appalling way to reach there.
In addition, for some mentors, mentoring was a burden or workload issue that often went unnoticed by others. Mentees, too, were concerned by a lack of mentor interest and training and a host of problematic mentor attributes and behaviors (e.g. critical or defensive behaviors). Professional or personal incompatibility or incompatibility based on other factors such as race or gender was also seen by both mentors and mentees as impediments to the success of the relationship. Organizations, too, were confronted with difficulties arising from mentoring programs. Lack of commitment from the organization, lack of partnership and funding problems were reported in some studies, while in others, cultural or gender biases meant that some mentees’ experiences were not
After viewing a number of texts, one major theme that connects all of these together is shown through the theme of societal pressure. Growing up in such a judgemental world, we all get judged on the things we do, the clothes we wear, the way we look and the place we originate from. These aspects all blend into societal pressure and create many difficulties for some teenagers growing up in this society. The texts, Try by Colbie Caillat, Thrift Shop by Macklemore, The Kite Runner by Khaled Hosseini and Dead Poet’s Society by Peter Weir, all incorporate different ways to overcome or fight societal pressure, foreshadowing some sort of advice to the viewer or listener. This allows them to think about their actions and construct a unique
Garvey, R. Stokes, P. and Megginson, D. (2009) Coaching and Mentoring theory and Practice. London: Sage
Mentoring is a strong educational tool and is very useful especially within the New York City Department of Education. It is a great way for experience teachers to pass down information. The one and one interaction is more lasting than reading it from a book. This method will allow a smooth transition for new teachers. There are a lot of procedures that are confusing to beginners and mentors can uncoil those kinks. Beginning teacher will also get the opportunity to experience different teaching styles and also decide what will work for them and what will not. Mentoring is a valuable asset in guiding person’s development.
Keating, he taught in a different ways that other teachers thought it wasn't as appropriate. Although he didn't teach like the other teacher in the movie his students slowly understood what poems truly mean. In the Dead Poet Society there was a scene where Neil wanted to pursue his long life dream which was becoming an actor. However both of Neil's parents wanted him to become a doctor instead of him being an actor. His parents didn't let him because they thought that being a doctor would be best for his future. Until the day came where he decided to stand up for himself, what he thought was right for him even if it meant he wouldn't live to achieve it. In the most of the students that were in the club eventually understood what poems are really about in real life
The best theme I think that is presented in the dead poets society is rebellion vs tradition. I chose this theme because their were many circumstances when the students would rebel against their school rules and when they would go by tradition. One example of rebellion in the dead poets society is when Neil went and acted for the play which was going against the rules, as he should’ve been at school. Another example and by far the most rebellious situation in the entire movie was the ending when Niel as an individual stood on his desk after repeatedly told to sit down or you’ll be expelled Niel still stood on his desk. It wasn’t just Niel that rebelled against his new teacher but other classmates stood up going against his rules. No girls
Dead Poets Society, a comedic drama directed by Peter Weir, highlights the lives of the young men in Mr. Keatings english class who are inspired by their teacher’s authentic views on poetry and life. The film features Robin Williams as Mr. Keatings, Robert Sean Leonard as Neil Perry, and Ethan Hawke as Todd Anderson. The film takes place at Welton Academy, a private boarding school for boys in Vermont during the fall and winter seasons in the 1950’s. The plot begins in the beginning of the school year and the introduction of Neil and Todd, a shy and new student to the school. Both boys struggle with the wrath of their fathers, who have their lives planned out for them whether they like it or not.
It is infuriating to have a father breathing down your neck and I can relate to Neil Perry on this matter but going as far as to killing yourself to escape your father is not the way to go. In Dead Poets Society, John Keating, the teacher keeps on telling his students to seize the day (Carpe Diem). It very different then what the school, Welton Academy, would have the students do. In Welton Academy, the students are expected to study hard, get good grades, get into a prestigious University, get a well-paying job, get married, and have children who you will raise in the same way. Welton Academy has a one size fits all philosophy and John Keating shows his students the pitfalls of this philosophy in his very first class, when the students are looking at old school photos, that you are going to die one day regretting not making much of your life.
You ask me what choice is. Listen real close with a staid demeanor. Now, I am fertilizing daffodils. I am the food for worms. But, I am not going to intimidate you, my friend. I was Neil Perry, a soulless shell in Dead Poet Society (DPS), dug my grave to escape from dreary half-life. The elegiac poem, which brought everyone to tears during my funeral, symphonized the resurrection day. You say the death is the only choice for me. But you are wrong. I defined choice as a barbaric yawp in disguise, an ephemeral illusion, and a jigsaw puzzle.