Critical Analysis Of Sherlock Holme

951 Words2 Pages

Sherlock Holmes is the most recognized figure in mystery novels. Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s famous novels rocked the world at the time of their release and that fame has stood the test of time. Holmes was renowned for two things: his incredible aptitude for deduction and his aloof attitude. However, his ability to solve seemingly impossible mysteries was constantly being hindered by his drug addiction and lack of social skills. It is largely due to this constant battle of talent and self-destruction that has made the stories so popular for so long. Since the release of the Holmes stories, countless altered versions have been written; of all these renditions, only one casts a girl as the “Sherlock” of the story. A Study in Charlotte by Brittany Cavallaro …show more content…

While attending boarding school, she meets Jamie Watson, the great great grandson of Sherlock’s trusted companion Dr. John Watson. The two find themselves being forced companions after being jointly framed for a murder that occurs on their campus. Charlotte’s sharp mind, apparent lack of social skills and battle with addiction issues (her particular vices being alcohol, oxycodone, and gambling) make her outwardly seem to be the perfect female embodiment of Sherlock Holmes. However, she is far more than a modern female rendition of her great-great-grandfather. Charlotte is compassionate and empathetic although she may not outwardly express it, she also is constantly trying to make herself into a better person; something that Sherlock himself never did. The resemblance between Charlotte and Sherlock Holmes is distinct. Her quick deductions and ability to gather intimate details about a person from a simple glance are almost identical to the marvelous cognitive capabilities of the original Sherlock Holmes. Jamie Watson says, “It was hard to hear Holmes talk, to learn that every one of my

Open Document