Comparison of News Reports

1098 Words3 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Comparison between two newspapers

Comparison of News Reports

The idea of this assignment is to compare and contrast two newspaper

reports on the same incident. The articles concerned are taken from

The Mirror and The Times, both published on the 4th of February 1998.

The Mirror is considered a tabloid newspaper. Tabloid papers usually

cover all national and international news. They often contain more

scandalous, gossipy stories or personal news items.

The Times is considered a broadsheet newspaper. These are the largest

type of newspaper and cover all national and international news in a

serious, informative way.

The basic story found in both articles is that a US Marine Fighter Jet

sliced through a cable car wire in the Dolomites in Italy. 20 people

were killed, as the cable car fell 300 feet.

The Mirror article is aimed at a younger audience, with a lesser

intelligence needed to understand it. The Times article is aimed at an

older audience of a higher intelligence.

The language used in The Mirror is simple and easy to understand. It

tends to include shorter words and sentences to increase its

simplicity. It also uses very sensationalistic language, for example,

"no survivors amid the tangled wreckage and bloodstained snow".

Whereas the language used in The Times is very formal and complex. It

also writes from a neutral viewpoint so as to convey the story without

bias.

The vivid language used in The Mirror has a greater impact on the

reader than the plainer language used in The Times.

The Mirror article is split into 4 columns with a headline and a

sub-heading. The headline is describing the situation - "20 skiers

killed as jet slices ca...

... middle of paper ...

... about half way down the page. This

effect causes the eye to be drawn to the article.

I think that The Mirror article is more effective in conveying the

story without bias and allowing the reader to form their own opinions.

It remains impartial throughout.

However I found The Times a more compelling read as its bias makes it

personal and grabs attention. Its chatty tone also makes it more

personal and compelling to read. Also the layout is more interesting

and the use of a pull quote to separate the text makes it more

interesting to read.

Both articles are very well written and work extremely well at

attaining their individual goals. The Mirror achieves its tabloid

status and is bias and personal. The Times also achieves its goal as a

typical broadsheet and gives the reader a neutral, informative

account.

Show More
Related

  • Ronald Takaki's A Different Mirror

    247 Words  | 1 Pages

    A Different Mirror is the first chapter of the book “A Different Mirror” by Ronald Takaki. The chapter begins with the author, Ronald Takaki, describing an interaction with a cab driver. Takaki, an Asian-American, was asked by his cab driver what country he was from implying that because of his appearance there was little chance that Takaki was originally from America. This sets the tone for chapter indicating that some people do not share physical characteristics that are deemed “American,” but they very much are Americans.

    Read More

  • By George C. Edwards III, Martin P. Wattenberg, And Robert L. Lineberry

    1113 Words  | 3 Pages

    In “Reporting the News” by George C. Edwards III, Martin P. Wattenberg, and Robert L. Lineberry, the main idea is how the media determines what to air, where to get said stories that will air, how the media presents the news, and the medias effect on the general public. “Reporting The News” is a very strong and detailed article. The authors’ purpose is to inform the readers of what goes on in the news media. This can be inferred by the authors’ tone. The authors’ overall tone is critical of the topics that are covered. The tone can be determined by the authors’ strong use of transitions, specific examples, and phrases or words that indicate analysis. To summarize, first, the authors’ indicate that the media chooses its stories that will air

    Read More

  • Muckrakers

    1900 Words  | 4 Pages

    With this increase, newspaper owners and editors needed new bait to reel in its subscribers. The newspaper editors wanted to replace ordinary town gossip with gossip about the latest events in the city. Therefore, in newspapers they placed the most shocking events and kept the rural minds drooling for more. As newspaper circulation grew, the large newspaper depended much less on political parties and could now even challenge them. Newspapers played on the new human interest, the concern of the wealthy with the affairs of those below them, status-wise.

    Read More

  • Discrepancy in Media Coverage

    2534 Words  | 6 Pages

    The discrepancies in media coverage in coverage of female and children athletics have large gaps, but are gaining momentum in sharing equality. Major athletic leagues such as the NBA and FIFA World Cup have wide gaps in marketing and ratings for their male and female athletes. Children are future athletes and superstars, but as funding and coverage in athletics catering to the males, women are breaking the barriers to be in the spotlight of sport. Both gender contribute equally to athletics, and challenge the each other to accept new ideas and change. The sports world that has a single gender dominating the media is unjust. Society does not want to bored, we need change in sports entertainment to cater to all. Not all parents and teachers are available to educate our children about the concepts of sharing and teamwork, our children are growing up learning key concepts through media. I will discuss these concepts and how they intertwine.

    Read More

  • Comparing Two Sources

    4541 Words  | 10 Pages

    Comparing Two Sources There are disagreements and agreements between source A and source B. Source A was from a report written by a journalist Humphrey Tyler, who worked for a South African magazine. The report was written later on the same day that the shooting occurred. Source B was from an English newspaper, published the day after the shooting. Source A and source B both agree and disagree with each other over different things.

    Read More

  • Rhetorical Analysis Of In A Defense Of Newspapers By Jonathan Choi

    412 Words  | 1 Pages

    In Jonathan Choi’s article “In a Defense of Newspapers” Choi attempts to persuade his audience that newspapers need to be valued and protected as important news sources. Choi uses various rhetorical devices to increase the persuasiveness of his argument. Choi uses evidence in the form of data and examples, a humorous and entertaining tone, and ethos to convince his readers that newspapers need to be protected.

    Read More

  • Compare and Contrast a News Story From Two Different Sources

    2224 Words  | 5 Pages

    News stories are covered several times and most of us do not even realize it. Although more recently many people get news in more similar mediums such as on the Internet because of the decline of newspapers. “Since 1940, the total number of daily newspapers has dropped more than 21 percent” (McIntosh and Pavlik, 119). Many times we do not realize the same story we read online was covered on our local news station and in our local newspaper, even further than that this same story is being covered in many different news stations, newspapers, and news sites all over the country and even the world. So what makes these stories different? Each time you read a news story from a different source something different happens to it. The different views and frames used by the source gives the reader a different take every time. I saw that first hand in my two stories. In my project I compared the same story of Mya Lyons, a nine year old girl who was stabbed to death.

    Read More

  • Comparing Newspaper Articles

    1424 Words  | 3 Pages

    the front page, it also has 1 or 2 images on the front page and

    Read More

  • Comparing Two Newspaper Articles

    1019 Words  | 3 Pages

    Comparing Two Newspaper Articles I'll be comparing the front page story of two newspapers. One is from a tabloid newspaper, as the other is from a broadsheet. I'll put across the. the diverse techniques that tabloids and broadsheets portray in their front page story. Newspaper media is designated to notify, and aim an.

    Read More

  • Sensationalism in the News

    1391 Words  | 3 Pages

    During these difficult economic times sensationalism has become more prevalent in the media. Stories involving sex scandals and child murders have taken over our T.V and internet screens as well as the front pages of our newspapers. The media bias of sensationalism has been used as a sort of escapism for readers. Although it may seem that sensationalism has just started making waves, it has been around for decades. Sensationalism has been influencing viewers and contributing to media bias since the days of the penny press. Sensationalisms long history has been turbulent, self-serving, and influential to today’s reporting practices. With the influence over readers’ sensationalism’s media bias have and will continue to affect media reporting for years to come.

    Read More

  • Comparing Two Newspaper Articles

    2067 Words  | 5 Pages

    Comparing two newspaper articles, one from a tabloid and one from a broadsheet will convey the different techniques that tabloids and broadsheets use to present stories. Media in general, aim to inform and interest the audience which consist of many different types. Diverse emotions and ideas are created by the media; foremost tabloids. Tabloids are papers like ‘The Sun’, ‘The Mirror’, ‘The Daily Mail’, ‘The Express’ and ‘The Star’. In contrast to these are broadsheets like ‘The Times’, ‘The Guardian’ and ‘The Daily Telegraph’. Broadsheets are often known as the ‘quality press’ being more informing and formal in the manner they convey information and news stories.

    Read More

  • Front Page News

    869 Words  | 2 Pages

    Every story that makes the front page a paper has to go through a “test” where the editor of that newspaper company decides whether the story is good enough for the front page. The editor makes the decision of whether or not the story is news worthy. The editor uses various different values to help him/her in their decision of what actually goes on the front page. Sometimes this judgment by the editor can be based solely on whether or not the story is going to grasp a lot of readers’ attention which would then boost newspaper sales. Other times the value system that is used is not so vague and meaningless. Some of these values that make stories news worthy are: its news values, prominence of the person or issue being reported on, the amount of impact the story has, whether or not there’s conflict, the novelty of the story, the timeliness, the proximity to the main area of circulation for that newspaper and the relevance and usefulness of the story. One key note is that these values have no hierarchic order and are based on the personal judgment of the editor of that paper. I will analyze three of the major newspapers in New York and point out the values that the editor of these particular newspapers used to decide which story was going to be the top story on Saturday, September 5th. The three newspapers are: The Journal News, New York Post and the Daily News.

    Read More

  • A Comparison of Two Different Newspapers

    1156 Words  | 3 Pages

    ways as I have explained in this essay. It is a fact that The Mirror

    Read More

  • Analysis of News Channels

    1232 Words  | 3 Pages

    In recent years, the importance of news broadcasts has increased. More people need to access the news to stay in touch with the rest of the world’s affairs. More TV channels have developed to give viewers more news. Both commercial and government networks are used to present the news to the general public. However, because of the different fundings and target audiences, different networks will focus on different aspects of the news, to make as many people of their target audience watch their particular broadcast. Therefore the separate channels can bring in a far larger audience, and take away another channels audience, therefore reducing competition.

    Read More

  • The Importance of Accuracy in Journalism

    1913 Words  | 4 Pages

    The introduction of the internet to modern society has brought about a new age of information relation. Since there is no longer a need to wait until the next print day, news from all over the world is available at a person’s fingertips within hours or even minutes of the event. With this advent of such easily accessible information, new problems for the news media have also arisen. Aside from potentially losing good economic standing because newspapers are no longer being purchased in the quantities they used to be, the credibility of the information itself is also put into question. No one would argue that credibility of news sources is unimportant, but there is a discrepancy in what takes precedence; economy and speed or getting the information out correctly at the first publishing by taking the time to make sure all facts are checked. The importance of having a system of checks on all information submitted is paramount. People trust what they read and believe it to be so without always questioning. If all information were to not be checked thoroughly, there would be instances where people read an article only for information included to be wrong and they go on believing such information. This can be very dangerous as misinformed people make misinformed decisions. With an increase in errors being made by citizen bloggers and even major publications, many are worried that journalistic ethics and credibility in the news media are being sacrificed in order to maintain swiftness in the news circuit and to retain personal profits. Though getting information to the masses quickly is a major part of the media’s importance, this should not mean that the credibility of that information being presented should be sacrificed for it...

    Read More

More about Comparison of News Reports

Open Document