Comparing The Opening Scenes of the Two Romeo and Juliet Films

1163 Words3 Pages

Comparing The Opening Scenes of the Two Romeo and Juliet Films

In this essay I will be comparing two Romeo and Juliet films done by

different directors at different times. The first film I will be

comparing was directed by Franco Zeffirelli in 1968, which is

considered the older version and the other film I will be comparing

was directed by Baz Luhrmann in 1996 and this is considered the more

recent version of Romeo and Juliet. For each film I will be comparing

the opening prologue and opening scene, which lasts about 10 minutes,

and both films differ in the way the scenes are set out and shown to

the audience.

In the more recent film of Romeo and Juliet the prologue is presented

in many different ways. The first image to appear on the screen is a

television with a newsreader, reading out the prologue, as if it is a

piece of news, the prologue is still in its original text so I think

it doesn't really work very well as newsreaders tend to be more

modern. The prologue is then shown in a form of a male voice over

which is very powerful and dominant whilst the prologue is being read

flashes of the film later on in the play are appearing on the screen,

I think this good because it is showing you visually what the prologue

is telling you orally, part of what is going to happen later on in the

play that has a great effect and sets the scene a bit. Also after the

flashes of the play still while the prologue is being read flashes of

bold white gothic writing against a dark black background appear which

are the lines written as the voiceover is saying them which draws you

attention very much to the screen. Parts of the prologue also app...

... middle of paper ...

...arket

square, which is very featureless compared to the newer film, which

has lots of decoration, and there is also no music in the fight of

this film.

The two versions of Romeo and Juliet are very different as they are

both set in different places and at different times but they both show

the basic comparisons as they are both based from the same script, as

they both have opening prologues and a fight in the opening scene. I

preferred the more recent film of Romeo and Juliet as I thought it was

more dramatic and had a lot more character to the film which would

make me want to watch it again where as the other film was very

lifeless and boring. I also thought the actors made the film more

noticeable and watch able as most of the actors were well known by the

public so that would make more people want to watch it.

Open Document