Comparing Animal Farm 'And Truman Show'

681 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: The main theme of Animal Farm

Animal Farm written by George Orwell and Truman Show directed by Peter Weir are two completely different stories that explore similar themes. These themes are the good life, utopia, and power. This essay will be looking further into these topics that both Orwell and Weir have found creative ways and examples to represent the ideas.
Firstly, Truman and the animals all strive for the good life but is it actually achievable? To Truman a good life was to have freedom to travel and explore. Although Christof would deter Truman from water by instilling fears into him. No amount of fear could stop Truman from finding his ideal life. The animals fought hard to make their life full of equality and freedom but being controlled by Mr Jones the animals felt trapped and hopeless. Although getting rid of Mr Jones gave the animals a good life for a while, the animals got so caught up in maintaining their good life they let it slip away …show more content…

Peter Weir has showed us that an ideal society is not what most people would imagine it to be. In the Truman show we see this when Truman feels the need for more experiences and sensing true relationships not just neighbours who are overly excited and speak to Truman from afar. Cleverly Weir has started with the audience thinking the neighbours were friendly and just saying hello but by repeating the same thing every morning. The audience then start reacting negatively because we know that’s not what a good society is. In Animal Farm the animals all agreed a good society was order and a faithful leader. In the book the animals were happy to struggle through hard labour to have the order in the society Old Major sums this up by saying “let there be perfect unity, perfect comradeship in the struggle,” The animals sought after order and each person playing their part in society different to Truman Show which was less about order and more about true relationships and

Show More
Related

  • Similarities Between Animal Farm And The Truman Show

    601 Words  | 2 Pages

    George Owell’s Animal Farm and Peter Weirs Truman Show both have similar but different themes. This essay will explain that power of the stronger characters is fuled by the ignorance of the weaker characters. That you can only have happiness or freedom never both, that the idea of utopia is different in both texts.

    Read More

  • Compare The Truman Show And Animal Farm

    1235 Words  | 3 Pages

    The balance of utopia, power, and the good life has been challenged throughout history and been shown in different stories, such as The Truman Show and Animal Farm. This balance is tough to achieve, and this is shown numerous times throughout both The Truman Show and Animal farm. Power, which is the ability to act in a particular way, is shown to be easily corrupted, utopia, which is a perfect society, is proved to be near impossible to achieve, and the good life, which is the life someone would want to live, is shown by different people at different times.

    Read More

  • Compare Animal Farm And The Truman Show

    1421 Words  | 3 Pages

    They particularly demonstrate the negative outcomes power produces. Power can be defined as the capacity or ability to direct or influence the behaviour of others or the course of events, each text flaunts ideas that support this, and how power can often be used to benefit the leader's life, and not the society’s, demonstrating how power can corrupt those who wield it. Orwell indicates this in Animal Farm, for example Napoleon uses his capacity to change the seven commandments given to the animals at the start of the revolution, he doesn’t change the commandments to offers other freedom, but to justify his actions. Napoleon selfishly alters the original slogan “all animal are equal” to “all animal are equal, but some are more equal than others” to improve his character, and ensure others understand how superior he is. Likewise, Weir suggests that power is often abused and taken advantage of, for one's benefit. Weir displays this when he uses Truman to create a television show about his life without Truman knowing. Christof does this to become successful in his career, to have no financial worries and eventually to become a well-known person. One may argue that Christof also tries to help Truman achieve happiness, as he creates the show around Truman’s life based on living the American dream: loving wife, white picket fence house and a 9-5 job, Christof claims he “knows you [Truman] better than you know yourself”. This is in contrast to Animal Farm, due to the fact that Napoleon does not do anything to benefit his “supporters”. Both Animal Farm and The Truman Show support the idea that power is easily abused, and can quickly become

    Read More

  • Compare And Contrast Animal Farm And V For Vendetta

    1178 Words  | 3 Pages

    The purpose of any and all texts is to criticise our society, whether that criticism is found in a novel or a film. This is established in the Novella ‘Animal Farm,’ written by George Orwell and the film ‘V for Vendetta’ by James McTeigue. Both of these texts analyse the way society is managed and how the populations can permit this management.

    Read More

  • Animal Farm And Anthem Comparison Essay

    1089 Words  | 3 Pages

    Animal Farm and Anthem are based around a corrupt society, creating a sense of dystopia over the duration of the books. In Anthem, equality and selflessness are forced upon all members of society, eradicating all diversity and opposing the concept of change. People are assigned jobs based on their performance, not ability or potential. The ideals presented by the culture are a “creed of corruption” (Rand p.97), brainwashing the general public into an identical, gray mass of yes, men. In Animal Farm equality is also the belief being infused into society. The animals only know lives plagued by the corruption of their owner, Mr. Jones. He “Sets them to work, he gives back to them the bare minimum that will prevent them from starving, and the rest he keeps for himself,” (Orwell p.8). Beaten, overworked, underfed and condemned to torturous deaths, the animals have little hope. The sense of dystopia is powerful, invariably present and alters the reader’s interpretation of the text. Although there are multiple similarities between the books,

    Read More

  • Compare And Contrast The Allegory Of The Cave And The Truman Show

    1371 Words  | 3 Pages

    Therefore, creating the idea in Truman’s mind that he is crazy and this is reality. This portrays the allegory of the cave idea that we only believe what we are told. Truman has to conform to the life that these actors have created for him, and when he tries to question it, he only gets shot down. Ultimately forcing him to continue with this life of shadows. Eventually more events shine the light on these hidden shadows and reveal the truth to Truman.

    Read More

  • Animal Farm Comparison

    1443 Words  | 3 Pages

    greater part of the members are poor and miserable.” The characters in George Orwell's Animal

    Read More

  • Critique of Communism in Animal Farm by George Orwell

    1289 Words  | 3 Pages

    ...re breaking every rule that they themselves had put forth in accordance with Old Major’s revolutionary vision. Animal Farm was a mirror image of communism gone awry in the Soviet Union. It also shows Marx’s naivety of the fact that there will always be the clever that take advantage of the ignorant. By keeping the population ignorant, the clever gain even more power, which is was happened in the Soviet Union and Animal Farm. The ones that took part in the revolutions would never realize that they were holding the short end of the stick, just as they were in their previous state of affairs. They were cold, miserable, and starving. In their brainwashed state they still believed that the dismal state they were in was better than their situation before the revolution. George Orwell finished his book on a somber note, the state in which Joseph Stalin left the Soviet Union.

    Read More

  • Animal Farm And The Russian Revolution

    863 Words  | 2 Pages

    George Orwell’s novel Animal Farm is a great example of allegory and political satire. The novel was written to criticize totalitarian regimes and particularly Stalin's corrupt rule in Russia. In the first chapter, Orwell gives his reasons for writing the story and what he hopes it will accomplish. It also gives reference to the farm and how it relates to the conflicts of the Russian revolution. The characters, settings, and the plot were written to describe the social upheaval during that period of time and also to prove that the good nature of true communism can be turned into something atrocious by an idea as simple as greed.

    Read More

  • Animal Farm Comparison

    958 Words  | 2 Pages

    Most directly one would say that Animal Farm is an allegory of Stalinism, growing out from the Russian Revolution in 1917. Because it is cast as an animal fable it gives the reader/viewer, some distance from the specific political events. The use of the fable form helps one to examine the certain elements of human nature which can produce a Stalin and enable him to seize power. Orwell, does however, set his fable in familiar events of current history.

    Read More

  • Themes In Animal Farm

    1043 Words  | 3 Pages

    The novel “Animal Farm” was written by the author name George Orwell. Animal Farm is a novel based upon the lives of a society of animals wanting a better life for themselves living on the Manor Farm. The setting of the book is a farm called “Manor Farm”. The theme of this book is that the animals should make a stand; if they continue doing the same thing they will continue getting the same results. It is better to be free and starving, than to be fed and enslaved.

    Read More

  • Use Of Syntax In Animal Farm By George Orwell

    865 Words  | 2 Pages

    Animal Farm is not only a novel about rebellious animals; it is a study of the corruption of society and humanity in an enclosed environment. The actions of the anthropomorphic animals that now rule Manor Farm represent the human society as a whole. Animal Farm by George Orwell is a novel which contains syntax that exemplifies power and hierarchies and diction that portrays character’s will and intention.

    Read More

  • Animal Farm Theme Essay

    1275 Words  | 3 Pages

    Theme Essay If a seven year old read Animal Farm he/she would have thought that it was a sad story about a farm in England. If an older person reads it, however, he/she realizes that this story has much more meaning to it. The story is filled with themes that help us understand the world around us. In this essay, I am going to talk about four themes that Orwell discussed in this story.

    Read More

  • Exploration Of The Main Themes In "Animal Farm"

    595 Words  | 2 Pages

    Animal Farm, A novella by George Orwell, tells the tale of the downtrodden animals of Manor Farm, who after much oppression from their master, take over the farm for themselves. In the beginning it seems like the start of a life of freedom and plenty, but ruthless and cunning elite emerges and begins to take control of the farm. The animals find themselves ensnared once again as one form of tyranny gradually replaces the other. The novella is a critique of revolutionary Russia and idealism betrayed by power and corruption. Orwell uses allegory between Animal Farm and the Soviet Union to highlight the corruption of socialist ideals in the soviet union, the power of language and propaganda, and the dangers of a naive working class.

    Read More

  • Animal Farm as a Fable

    955 Words  | 2 Pages

    Fables are meant to have a moral, and the moral of Animal Farm is that all revolutions fail in the end. Orwell could have written a long essay expressing such ideas but it is doubtful that many people would now be reading it. The success of Animal Farm is that it tells the sad tale of a group of creatures we care about, and how their hopes and dreams were dashed. Beyond the surface story, however, is the message that for ordinary people revolutions simply change one set of rulers for another. It is a depressing message but people are prepared to listen to it because it is told in a simple and entertaining way like all the best fables.

    Read More

More about Comparing Animal Farm 'And Truman Show'

Open Document