Compare and Contrast

767 Words2 Pages

Personal writing can take several forms, descriptive and narrative being two examples. The two essays, "I Want a Wife" by Judy Brady and "Sister Flowers" by Maya Angelou are prime examples of such writing. Both stories were able to capture my attention and entertain me throughout their entirety. Choosing a preference is always going to be subjective; it is all a matter of how you like to take in information. In fact, personal choice is what inclines you towards a certain title as opposed to another. Some may like to envision their own details, while some rather the images chronicled for them. In fact, the crystal clear details given in a descriptive essay as compared to a narrative, set the two far apart. Although narrative essays can give details without as much wording, the vivid pictures painted by a descriptive essay such as "Sister Flowers" is a superior read since the details make the story come alive.
The story “I Want a Wife”, is a narrative essay signifying the demand placed on females during the 1970's. The author goes on to demonstrate the expectations that our male counterparts placed on women during that era. The way in which the author brought this issue to the surface was enthralling. As described by the author, a wife was to be seen and not heard, she is to cater to every impulse her husband has.Written out in sequence, a woman's duties were overwhelming and needed to be brought to the light. Men were treated like royalty by their wives, while showing little appreciation. A wife was expected to take care of the family while nothing was required of the husband. In addition, a wife was expected to look her best while tackling all of life's problems. The essay does not provide a notable amount of detail, yet the s...

... middle of paper ...

...ed product. "I Want a Wife" is an excellent story with just enough revealed to get the main point across. There was no need for overly expressive language, as used in a descriptive essay. "Sister Flowers" got its point across, however, the use of elucidating language is heavily apparent. I love to read, yet it is most amusing when the words carry you away into a new world. A world where what you read comes to life and you never want to put the story down for fear of missing out on what happens next. In my opinion, that is exactly what a descriptive essay does and is why I find it superior to a narrative essay.

Works Cited

Angelou, M. (1969). Sister flowers. Retrieved from http://ux1.eiu.edu/~madwiggins/sister_flowers.htm
Brady, J. (1971). I want a wife. Retrieved from http://bcs.bedfordstmartins.com/everythingsanargument4e/content/cat_020/Brady_I_Want_a_Wife.pdf

Open Document