Compare And Contrast Go Set A Watchmen And To Kill A Mockingbird

896 Words2 Pages

Viewed as a progressive hero in To Kill a Mockingbird, Harper Lee shocked her readers as Atticus Finch grew and changed his indication of African Americans around the time of the Civil Rights movement in America. As evident in Go Set a Watchmen, Atticus is not a racist, but a victim to change. Progressive ideas of the north and the outcome of Brown v the Board of Education in 1954 scare the south as they see the ideas as a means to an end in their status quo of a hierarchal society. While both Jean Louise and Atticus have strong opinions about differences of their ways of life as they age, Atticus worries more about his changing role in society, while Jean Louise has uncertainties with the changes of her childhood town, her friends, and her …show more content…

While Jean Louise goes against the norms of society by her taboo clothes and unmarried lifestyle, Atticus rebels his decaying traditions by attending Citizens Council meetings. Which, according to his brother, Jack, is just as their ancestors did during the Civil War, “all over the South your father and men like your father are fighting a sort of rearguard, delaying action to preserve a certain kind of philosophy that’s almost gone down the drain” (188). Jean Louise embodies the opposite of what the old south wants out of a young lady just as Atticus positions himself against young progressive ideas and tries to save the old ways of living. Friends and family of Jean Louise agree with Atticus and she is afraid of the change in her father especially. The interaction with Atticus the morning after she discovers him at the Citizens Council meeting proves the change, “Now, isn’t it better for us to stand up with him in court than to have him fall into wrong hands?”(148). In To Kill a …show more content…

Even though African Americans suffered, Jean Louise and Atticus both use their suffering as a means to be victimized. Atticus blames his troubling change in society on the want for equal rights, which in turn would weaken his power. Likewise, Jean Louise faults the change of her nostalgic thoughts on a split created by racial differences; the struggle for equality has turned Jean Louise’s mother figure Calpurnia against the family she cared for, revealing that she had hated them, “I’ve got to know. Did you hate us?” “Calpurnia shook her head.”(160). Neither Atticus nor Jean Louise agreed about the Supreme Court decision of Brown v the Board of Education even though Jean Louise wants equality. Atticus spots her hypocritical views during their argument, “You are inconsistent… You slang the Supreme Court within an inch of its life, then you turn around and talk like the NAACP.”(243). Jean Louise claims to care more about the right of the states 10th Amendment rather than the rights of African Americans,” Good Lord, I didn’t get mad with the Court because of the Negros…I was ravin’ at what they were doing to the Tenth Amendment and all the fuzzy thinking.”(243). While Jean Louise agrees with Atticus by disagreeing with the NAACP and the Supreme Court’s decision, they still believe they are each bigots by not admitting that they agree on the subject. According to Uncle Jack, Jean Louise

Open Document