More handpicked essays just for you.
Discrepancies between the original text of a Christmas carol and the film
Discrepancies between the original text of a Christmas carol and the film
Discrepancies between the original text of a Christmas carol and the film
Don’t take our word for it - see why 10 million students trust us with their essay needs.
There are many versions of “A Christmas Carol”, play versions, book versions, and even movie versions. All versions have a different sort of “style” to them, or they are performed in a different kind of way. The movie version that was created in 2009 starring Jim Carrey and the original version created by Charles Dickens are two very different, but similar versions. The movie version that was created in 2009 is performed in a creepy way. There is a blizzard and the spirits all are big and not exactly how they are described in the book. In the book, Ebenezer Scrooge ends up back at his place by the spirit of christmas future shrinking down and dwindling into a bedpost, in the movie that is different. Despite the movie and the books differences they are very alike in some ways. In the movie and the book, Ebenezer Scrooge and the spirits review the same things. By review, I mean that Scrooge and the spirits go through the same things. They review his past, his present and his future.
In the movie “A Christmas Carol” that was created in 2009, starring JIm Carrey and the book “A Christmas Carol” by Charles Dickens are very different, even though they are both about the same thing. In the movie, “A Christmas Carol”, the movie is put into a different sense of style than the book. “A Christmas Carol” starring Jim Carrey is
…show more content…
performed in an eerie kind of way. The movie includes many scene that could potentially freak people out including when many ghosts came into his home and freaked him out, when the two little children came from the spirit of christmas’ future’s robe, and at the ending, in the graveyard. The book is performed in more of calm manner. It does not describe any kind of snow storm in the graveyard and Ebenezer Scrooge does not sound scared of the spirit of christmas future. In the book, “A Christmas Carol” by Charles Dickens, Ebenezer Scrooge ends up back at his house in a different way. In the movie, “A Christmas Carol” that was created in 2009 ends with him falling into a pit that is supposed to be falling into his coffin and ending up hanging from a curtain that is attached to his bed. In the book, “A Christmas Carol” by Charles Dickens he ends up back at his by holding onto the spirits finger and then it ends up being his bedpost. Also in the stories the person directing the movie/play would choose a different medium because they would not want the play to be performed in the exact same way as the original. They effect that that has on the audience is that they might enjoy it more if it is performed in a different sense of style so they are not seeing the same thing over and over again. In the movie and the book “A Christmas Carol” they both have the Spirits of Christmas past, present and future and they all review the same things.
With the spirit of the past it shows him everything that has happened in his past such as him going to school and the love of his life dying, the movie and the book both show that. With the present the movie and the book both show how a man that works for him is poor and that his son is going to die if Scrooge’s behavior doesn’t change. Finally, in the future it shows that if Scrooge doesn’t change that he is going to die and it show him looking at the gravestone that says “Ebenezer Scrooge” on
it. There are many versions of “A Christmas Carol” by Charles Dickens. All versions are different in a way and all versions are alike in a way, In the movie version it is performed in a different sense of style than the book version. In the book it is a bit more calm. Also, in the movie version Scrooge falls into a pit and lands hanging down from a curtain that was attached to his bed. But even though they are different they are very much alike. In the movie and the book they have the same spirits and Scrooge and the spirits review the same things. Such as Scrooge’s past, present, and future.
On Christmas Eve , Scrooge is gone by a progression of ghosts,starting with his old business accomplice, Jacob Marley. The three spirits follow,the Ghosts of Past , Christmas present and Christmas future ,show how his ,mean conduct has influenced everyone around him. Toward the finish of the story ,he is soothed to find that there is still time for him to change and we see him changed into a liberal and kind hearted person.
How do we know when or how to change ourselves as people? Sometimes, we all need a shove from something or someone to help us better ourselves. The most dominant factors are kindness, fear, and regret. These three things can make us willing to go through the hassle and hard work of breaking out of a habit, whether it be putting your feet on the couch, or your attitude.
In the play, A Christmas Carol, it started out with Marley speaking out to the audience, unlike the movie, where it just started out with Mr. Scrooge trudging through the snow. (Dickens 1) Another minor difference was in the play, the spirit of Christmas Past was a man, yet in the movie being a woman. (Dickens 11) During the visit of Christmas Past, Mr. Scrooge traveled through the past as another’s perspective, instead of his own. (Video
Little did Ebenezer Scrooge know, this was going to be the kickoff to a substantial journey on his night of Christmas Eve. The ghost of Christmas past had the appearance similar to a child, yet it had some characteristics comparable to a lit candle. This ghost took Scrooge to all of his most painful memories leading up to his present day position. After brief reminders of these incidents, Scrooge started to get melancholy. Events from his schooldays, his engagement, and even his happy apprenticeship with his former boss Fezziwig provided enough insight for the main character to visit his childhood. Scrooge then got an unexpected visit from the ghost of Christmas Present. He took the display of a gigantic man, dressed in a green robe. This ghost helped provide an insight for Scrooge on what his acquaintances were doing on Christmas Eve night. Bob Cratchit, had a dinner with his family and could barely afford any food due to his low wage from Scrooge. Lastly, Ebenezer received a visitation from the ghost of Christmas yet to come. The ghost was strictly straightforward with Scrooge’s future if he kept acting similar to what he did. The three ghosts provided a prolonged climax to the story, giving Ebenezer a direct turning point in his actions and beliefs. He had adjusted to not making
Just like the play, Ebenezer Scrooge is the main character in the story. He is a mean, cold-hearted man that has no Christmas spirit whatsoever. All that Scrooge cares about and will ever care about is his wealth until he is taken on a journey. He is lead by 3 ghosts of his past, present, and future as he was in the play. These ghosts show him what Christmas spirit is and try to force it upon him. All of this finally hits him once he is taken to the future and witnesses his own grave. Scrooge pleads for a second chance to change his bad ways. Once he wakes up in his bedroom after all of this craziness, he jumps for joy and makes many new friends while mending with some old friends. He fixes many of his wrongs and lives out the rest of his life as a happier, friendlier, and a generous
A Christmas Carol and It’s A Wonderful Life are classic works of art that have aged well over time and are some of the most popular stories during Christmas. Both stories remain very popular to this day because of the themes being relatable to almost everyone making it relevant. Though, these stories, if taken into context, are quite serious compared to other less thought provoking tales. The main character of It’s A Wonderful Life is George Bailey a generous man that helps people with their problems and finances. The main character of A Christmas Carol is Ebenezer Scrooge a grouchy old man that is wealthy but doesn’t care about anyone but himself. George and Scrooge are two very different characters, but go through similar life processes that change them for better..
The play “A Christmas Carol – A ghost story of Christmas” by Charles Dickson, directed by James Black in Houston, TX was performed in a similar way in “A Christmas Carol” by Charles Dickson, directed by Michael Wilson in Washington, D.C. The both plays had similarities and differences throughout the play in which demonstrated different creativity from the different directors. The rating that was given by the reviewer of the play in Washington gave a 5 out of 5 star rating. For the play that I went to watch the rating I would give it would be a 5 star rating.
In the beginning, some might say that the ghost of Jacob Marley is what caused the change. Well it couldn’t have been Jacob Marley because when Jacob first visits Scrooge and tells him that three ghosts will come to haunt him Scrooge has no change and just says “ I think I’d rather not,”. This shows that he didn’t change because if he had changed than he would he would have said something like, “ Oh, Marley, my old friend I’m so glad you came to see me. Even if you’re a ghost, I’m still delighted to have you here. Merry Christmas Jacob, Merry Christmas.” Jacob visiting Scrooge didn’t make any difference at all.
The Ghost of Christmas Past is a very important symbol in order to find out about Scrooge’s childhood. The Ghost of Christmas Past is described as a child, but also like an old man. Its hair was long and white with age, but its face had no wrinkles. Its arms were long and muscular and its hands seemed
“They owe me money, and I will collect. I will have them jailed, if I have to. They owe me money and I will collect what is due to me.”( Dickens 1 ) Ebenezer Scrooge is a very rich, and selfish person. Because of his old partner Jacob Marley, (who died) Ebenezer has three ghosts of Christmas come to help him remember his Christmas Spirit. When they let him see his past, present, and future, it changes his whole life. The movie, and drama had many similarities, and differences.
In Conclusion, in the 1st Stave Dickens presents Scrooge as an evil, aged, prosperous man. As you read the Staves 2, 3 and 4, Scrooge’s behaviour, thoughts and attitude changes gradually. In Stave 2 a quote to show how shrude Scrooge is 'All he could make out was that it was still very foggy and extremely cold' this shows that Scrooge is an unpleasant ‘a covetous sinner’. This has an effect upon the reader as it shows how the cold weather can hurt and be distasteful to people just like Scrooge. Scrooge is described as the weather as he is like it; he hurts the people around him. Finally, in the 4th Stave he changes and he admits it, here is a quote “Spirit!'' he cried, tight clutching at its robe, “hear me! I am not the man I was.” This shows Scrooge is pleading that he has changed. I think he has transformed because of the experience he had by the four spirits.
A Christmas Carol, by Charles Dickens is a tale of the morality changes of a man. The uncharitable, cold heart of the main character, Ebenezer Scrooge, melts with ardent love as he receives visitations from three Christmas spirits who enlighten his soul with wise lessons and bring a warm change to his heart. In the beginning of the novel, Scrooge expresses his vices of greed and cold heartedness by his words and actions, but as the story unfolds, his life is renewed by these Spirits who shed light and truth upon him, resulting in making him become a better man, portraying the virtue of charity.
Throughout A Christmas Carol and The Divine Comedy, the similarities consist of Christian holidays, the use of threes, and the repercussions of greed. Along with the similarities, there are also several differences such as the point of view of each story, where the characters travel, and the ghost that come to Scrooge and Dante.
One similarity is that in both of the stories have three ghost that visit the main character and transport them by touch. In the book, three ghosts come to Scrooge to show him his past, present, and future in hopes of changing his perspective. They teleported him to the times by Scrooge touching the them. In the movie, the main character, Cindy, is startled by three ghosts also looking to change her view on Christmas by showing her the past, present, and future. Grazing their hands together took them both to one of the times. Another key point is the next paragraph about differences.
Meeting the Ghost of Christmas Past begins the first stage of Scrooge’s transformation: regretting his actions. When Scrooge is shown his younger self alone in his classroom on Christmas, he regrets chasing a Christmas caroler away from his door. The Spirit skips ahead a few years to show him a happier time. His sweet little sister Fan arrives to take him home, and this is his first Christmas in a long time that is spent with family. Unfortunately, Scrooge doesn’t see it that way; seeing this scene makes him “uneasy in his mind” as he thinks about the way he treats his nephew Fred. Instead of treating him like his only family member, Scrooge denies invitations to Christmas dinner every year and is rude whenever Fred speaks to him. He doesn’t have time to dwell on this for long, however; Scrooge has many other important things to think...