Commercial Recuperation

1936 Words4 Pages

Commercial Recuperation

Essentially what Hebdige is saying with his statement is that

eventually a subcultures generic trademarks will cross over into the

mainstream. This will in tern render the original intentions of

subversion diluted pastiches of there former representations.

The validity of this statement is interesting in two ways. Firstly are

subcultures subversive qualities diluted through popularisation? And

secondly and perhaps more importantly in terms of more contemporary

subcultural representations; how valid is the statement that what

might be considered subcultures are actually subversive in terms of

attempted displacement of a dominant ideology.

It is these two areas with particular reference to the Punk movement

of the nineteen seventies which I intend to discuss within this

Essay/Exam. Looking at the work of Hebdige himself and other writers

and theorists in comparison, and also contrasting areas.

Punk is perhaps the most obvious musical form which has been linked to

subculture. Even Hebdige himself is of the opinion that music and

subcultures are part of the same “expressive circle” (Quoted in

Middleton, 1990:165). It is for many the archetypal musical subculture

as Jeff Pike writes with reference to The Sex Pistols in ‘the death of

rock and roll’ “the fury was undeniable, and so was the vision”

(1993:268).

The punk movement was spawned in and around 1976. It was a reaction

initially against the what many saw as the grandiose ageing hippies

who then dominated the charts under the banner of ‘progressive rock’

Which highlights a point made by Ted Polhemus that one of the key

aspects of musical subcu...

... middle of paper ...

...as ‘Girl Power’ or Grunge where either to superficial or self

referential respectively to be considered subcultures adequate enough

for idealistic subversion.

Bibliography

Hall, S (ed) 1997. Representation:Cultural Representations and

Signifying Practices. Sage/The Open University:London.

Jameson, F. 1991. Postmodernism or, The Cultural Logic Of Capitalism.

Verso:London.

Middleton, R. 1990. Studying Popular Music. Open University Press.

Buckingham.

Pike, J. 1993. The Death Of Rock ‘n’Roll: Untimely Demises, Morbid

Preoccupations, and Premature Forecasts of Doom in Pop Music. Faber &

Faber:

London.

Polhemus,T. 1994. Street Style:From Sidewalk To Catwalk. Thames &

Hudson:London.

Storey, J (ed) 1994. Cultural Theory And popular Culture:A Reader

(Second Addition). Prentice Hall:London.

Open Document