Cold War Revisionism

Discussions of the causes of the Cold War are often divisive, creating disparate ideological camps that focus the blame in different directions depending on the academic’s political disposition. One popular argument places the blame largely on the American people, whose emphasis of “strength over compromise” and their deployment of the atomic bomb in the Second World War’s Pacific theatre apparently functioned as two key catalysts to the conflict between US and Soviet powers. This revisionist approach minimizes Stalin’s forceful approach and history of violent leadership throughout World War 2, and focusing instead on President Harry Truman’s apparent insensitivity to “reasonable Soviet security anxieties” in his quest to impose “American interests on the world.” Revisionist historians depict President Truman as a “Cold War monger,” whose unjustified political use of the atomic bomb and ornery diplomatic style forced Russia into the Cold War to oppose the spread of a looming capitalist democratic monopoly. In reality, Truman’s responsibility for the Cold War and the atomic bomb drop should be minimized. Criticisms of Truman’s actions fail to consider that he entered a leadership position set on an ideological collision course, being forced to further an established plan for an atomic monopoly, and deal with a legacy of US-Russian tensions mobilized by Roosevelt prior to his death, all while being influenced by an alarmist and aggressive cabinet. Upon reviewing criticisms of Truman’s negotiations with Soviet diplomat Vyacheslav Molotov and his involvement in the atomic bomb drop, the influence of Roosevelt’s legacy and Truman’s cabinet will be discussed in order to minimize his blame for starting the Cold War.

History does not ...

... middle of paper ...

... Review, 41(2): 225-230.

9. Pearson, D. (1955, June 29). Truman Once Bawled Out Molotov. The Washing Post and Times Herald, p. 55.

10. Roberts, G. (2004). Sexing up the Cold War: New evidence on the Molotov-Truman talks of April 1945. Cold War History, 4(3): 105-125.

11. Sherwin, M. (1973). The atomic bomb and the origins of the cold war. American Historical Review, 78: 1-7.

12. Suri, J. (2012). Anxieties of empire and the Truman administration. A Companion to Harry S. Truman: Blackwell Publishing.

13. The New York Times (1946, February 10). Text of Premier Stalin's Election Speech Broadcast by Moscow Radio: HAS NEW FIVE-YEAR PLAN FOR RUSSIA. New York Times, p. 30.

14. Truman, H. S. (1965). Molotov in Washington. Memoirs (pp. 200-204). New York: The New American Library.

15. Yalta Papers Bare Seeds of Cold War. (1955, December 30). Chicago Daily Tribune, pp. 1-2.