Character Analysis: The Contrast By Royall Tyler

427 Words1 Page

Henry Schimmel ENGL 2000 107 Literature, History, Culture
Rev. Ronald Bieganowski, S.J. 28 January 2015

Royall Tyler’s The Contrast presents many conflicts, and each character’s story demonstrates an American crisis of cultural identity. The Contrast focuses on this internal conflict that befell the United States following the Revolution, and Tyler particularly emphasizes the importance for Americans to depart from the past with the intent of “starting over.” He challenges the ideals of the old world in favor of the ideals of the new. The Contrast is not merely patriotic, but also a subtle critique of the social duplicity of the old European culture and the new, emerging culture of the United States. The Contrast makes a clear …show more content…

However, she is chained to old-world conventions. Billy Dimple, to whom Maria is betrothed, after returning from abroad, became the very persona of Europe, England, and the old ways, and his trip transformed him into a foppish dandy, an Anglophile, and a lothario. Maria even compares Billy’s wickedness to Robert Lovelace, the “dashing villain” from the 1748 English novel, Clarissa (799). Maria’s character, on the other hand, is virtuous and dutiful, and she holds her filial duty in higher regard than her own desires. Contemptuous of Mr. Dimple, but honor bound by her filial duty, Maria falls in love with Henry Manly, who starkly contrasts Billy Dimple in every manner. Colonel Manly, as a war hero, sincere gentleman, and loyal patriot, is the very persona of America itself. Billy Dimple and Colonel Manly personify the two conflicting and contrasting cultures, and Maria personifies the American cultural identity crisis because she finds her heart split between her desire for happiness and love and her expected cultural duties. Therefore, Royall Tyler expresses the social conflict of

Open Document