Wait a second!
More handpicked essays just for you.
More handpicked essays just for you.
How did Carthage become equal to Rome
Major differences between the governments of Rome and Carthage
Carthage vs rome essay
Don’t take our word for it - see why 10 million students trust us with their essay needs.
Recommended: How did Carthage become equal to Rome
1. Introduction
In studying the history of the great ancient powers, inevitably we must discuss the rise of conflict between two prominent powers: Carthage and Rome. Carthage was a powerful force in the western Mediterranean, while Rome was the ruler of Italian Peninsula at the time.
In the following sections, we will discuss how Carthage became a rivaling force to Rome.
Over the course of this discussion, we will compare the strengths of both forces, and reveal the reasons behind how Rome became a naval power.
2. Tracing the Development of Carthage as a Rival of Rome
Carthage was originally a colony of Tyre, and was settled by Phoenicians in 813 BCE
(Cartwright, 2016, para. 2). It was one of the most powerful commercial empire on the
northern
…show more content…
1).
The Carthaginian government had some outward similarities to the government of Roman
Republic. It had two chief magistrates, a council of elders, and an assembly, which could compare with the Roman consuls, senate, and comitia respectively (Morey, 1901, Carthage and Rome section, para. 3). However, in contrast to the Roman government, the real governing power in Carthage was exercised by a few wealthy families; also, the command power of the Carthaginian army was placed in the hands of one permanent leader.
The power and wealth of Carthage had grown from trade and commercial supremacy.
She had formed commercial treaties with the chief countries of the world to buy and sell the products of the East and the West (Morey, 1901, Carthage and Rome section, para. 4). Thus, in order to further expand in power, Carthage had the desires to possess the Greek cities of
4
UNIT 5 ASSIGNMENT - CARTHAGE AND ROME
Sicily as well as the cities of Italy; this possession over the cities at the western
Mediterranean Sea became the main reason for the rivalry between Carthage and
…show more content…
5).
4. Rome Becoming a Naval Power
The first conflict between Carthage and Rome broke out in the form of the first Punic
War in 264 BC (Morey, 1901, Operations of the First Punic War section, para. 1). The main reason for the war was over the possession the the island of Sicily. When the Carthaginian fleet first appeared, it gained possession of most of the coast cities that had belonged to
Romans before. The Carthaginian naval fleet ravaged the coasts of Italy, and therefore made it difficult for Rome to send more troops to Sicily; the Roman vessels could not compete with the strong Carthaginian vessels (Morey, 1901, Operations of the First Punic War section, para. 4). Hence, the Romans realized that in order to overcome the Carthaginian forces, they had to surpass Carthage both on land and upon the sea. This drove the Romans to build a new naval fleet equal to that of the Carthaginian fleet. The Romans soon constructed a hundred vessels that were modeled after the Carthaginian vessel, and trained their soldiers to become sailors. Also, in order to maintain the Roman advantage in hand-to-hand
Soon the second Punic War began because Carthage was infuriated with their treatment and torments from the Empire of Rome. This war was even worse than the first, and it shook Rome to its core. The first World War began with an accumulation of many causes, but one of the more influential problems was land hunger or imperialism. When Germany lost, it had the same treatment from the world that Carthage got from Rome. In the same case, the Second World War began because of the humiliation given to Germany with the peace treaty.
The Carthaginians and Romans fought in three different wars over the course of 118 years. Romans fought the Carthaginians to ruin their hold on a chain of islands that would let them control the Western Mediterranean. The Romans wanted to have control. They then fought over land in Italy, particularly Sicily. In the third conflict, Carthaginians tried to save their city and land from being taken over completely by Romans. In these wars, they mainly fought over trade routes in the Mediterranean. Each wanted power and more territorial possession.
The war started because of conflicting interests between the two, especially the expanding Roman Republic. At the end of the war, thousands of lives were lost, Rome ascended into power, conquering Carthage and becoming the most powerful state in the Mediterranean. During one point of the Second War, or the Hannibalic War, Carthage nearly brought Rome to her knees. With reinforcement from their Gallic allies, Carthage defeated the Roman army in the Battles of Trebia, Trasimene, and Cannae. Had Rome not defeated Carthage, the history Western civilization would be drastically altered, shaping a very different world than the one we live in today. It is said “All roads lead to Rome”. There is a lot of truth to this quote because Rome, with all its power and glory, paved the road for our modern society; it allowed Christianity to spread and flourish, the basis for democracy, and served as melting pot of cultures and customs.Rome can be considered one of the greatest influences on Western civilization, leaving us with priceless gifts that we will always
By the time of the 12th century, cities such as Milan had a government loosely based on the old Roman regime. This was a three tier system consisting of Captains - the higher nobility and clergy; the vassals- the lower nobility and an increasing middle class formed of merchants and land leasers; and the common people such as the artisans and peasants. A consul was elected to govern the commune and was re-elected every year. This consul was elected by all three orders not just the elite. This is what existed for self-government in the eleventh and twelfth century.
“Rome acquired Sicily (241 BC), the two province of sardine and Corsica (238 BC); most of the Spain (197 BC); Macedonia and parts of northern Africa (146 BC) etc.”
The first Punic War started with a request by the locals in Messana for the Romans to aid them in defeating the Carthaginians. Messana was at the southern tip of Italy and would be a great asset to the already superior naval fleet of Carthage. Rome saw this to be a good opportunity to halt the expansion of the Carthaginian Empire and to stop the possible attack on Italy (which was controlled by Rome). Despite this fact the Roman council debated on whether to attack on these premises or not, but eventually it was decided that they would wage war on the Carthaginians. The Carthaginians were then told that they must halt their invasion or war would be waged. They did not stop and Rome declared war.
The Roman Empire was constantly expanding as the Empire gained much of its wealth through conquering,
...se they gave them the idea to conquer. If it wasn’t because of the Greeks then their tools and ideas that helped them expand would not have made them much (Main Vision). Yes, the Romans did have a lot of things already accomplished, and (change you to something else and fix this up) might say that their expansion had already been great before the introduction of the Greeks culture, but if it wasn’t for the Greek most of their wars would have been lost and not that much land would have been acquired. The Greeks because of their education and higher status of life viewed things a lot more differently than that of the Romans.
The Second Punic war, beginning in 218 BC, was the second major war between the Roman Empire and the Carthage. Around the same time, the Roman Empire deployed troops to the Northeastern peninsula of Spain to keep reinforcements, from the Carthaginian South, from getting to Hannibal’s armies in Italy to assist them. In A Histor...
Even before the war started, Hannibal knew what he was going to do. Since Carthage had no navy, there was no hope of going directly from Carthage to Italy over the Mediterranean Sea. Hannibal thought up a dangerous but ingenious plan. In order to get to Italy over land, Hannibal and his army would have to travel from Carthage-controlled Spain across the Alps and into the heart of the enemy. Hannibal left in the cold winter of 218 B.C. with 50,000 infantry, 9,000 cavalry, and 37 war elephants. While crossing the Alps, “Hannibal’s force suffered greatly from the elements and the hostility of the local tribesmen” (Beshara, 3). By the time they reached Italy, after only fourteen days, over 9,000 men had perished along with most of the elephants, but this number was soon replenished after 14,000 northern Gaul rebels joined Hannibal’s army. This group of 60,000 men proved superior to the Roman forces, and after at least three recorded major victories, the Roman senate was exasperated. An army of 80,000 Roman soldiers was sent to stop Hannibal’s army of now 50,000 once and for all. In July of 216 B.C., the Romans engaged the Carthaginians in “the neighborhood of Cannae on the Italian east coast” (Lendering, 2). Greatly outnumbered, Hannibal realized that he would have to win by strategy, and that is exactly what he did. As the two lines met, Hannibal’s cavalry gained the flanks and, moving up the sides, attacked the rear of the Roman line.
The government of Ancient Rome, the Roman Republic, has influenced American government. The Roman Republic influenced the laws, republican form of government, branches of government, and balance of power. However, the Republic was different from American government. For instance, the Romans had two leaders as consuls of the empire. What was taken from Rome to America, was the idea of a ruling senate that controlled what laws were passed. Consuls had supreme power in both civil and military matters. In the city of Rome, the consuls were the head of the Roman government. They would be the head of the senate and the assemblies. The republic was a large democratic system structured under the rule that no one could hold too much power. Also, people's assemblies were elected by the people to represent the lower classes of Rome. The military was controlled by elected officials. Their terms only lasted for one year! However, it was not a perfect democracy. The Romans did not have a sense of human rights. The city held m...
After the conclusion of the Gauls sacking Rome, Rome became obsessed with the security of their empire and acutely aware of any and all potential threats. “Following the sack by the Gauls, the Romans were frightened by strong neighbors and sometimes made preemptive strikes against peoples they believed were becoming too powerful” (Kidner, 129). Rome became a walled city that would not let any foreign soldiers through its gates from the conclusion of the sacking in 390 B.C. until 410 A.D., earning it the nickname of the Eternal City. The Roman mantra of Lex Fetiale, which prohibited Rome from going to war unless under siege or asked for assistance, was suddenly much easier to justify than before.
...s the collision on Carthage from which Rome emerged ruler of the western Mediterranean. Then there is the third the subjection of the Hellenistic states that gravitated Romans in close contact with the Greek civilization.
They believed that other areas, posed possible threats and that it was necessary “for defensive reasons” to attack first. Today, these can be viewed as possibly preventive wars. But during the time of the expansion of the Roman Empire, a preventive war wasn’t a concern. Other views were demonstrated in their actions, that although at first Romans were unable to take Carthage, they kept trying, and over time, and most likely many deaths, the Roman soldiers wore them down. Rome was like a bulldozer and used their skilled military to their advantage, to take over and destroy anything that it set its eyes on.
Carthage was founded about 100years earlier than Rome and had very fertile lands and an excellent harbor. It grew economically and politically through trading Gold from Spain, Ivory, Linen, precious stones, and other valuable minerals from different states. They had a very large number of trading vessels to load these products and carry them from pot to pot. They also had a powerful navy of warships. Like the Roman empire the Carthagean empire acquired dominion over the native races of Africa, the Lydians and the Numidians. These two great states had controls over the small states they made their allies, or members of their confederations. They were almost equal in many ways, and even their economies