Wait a second!
More handpicked essays just for you.
More handpicked essays just for you.
Compare and contrast between books and movies
Narrative of Beowulf
.myth, legend and fantasy in beowulf
Don’t take our word for it - see why 10 million students trust us with their essay needs.
Recommended: Compare and contrast between books and movies
The movie stuck to the main story of Beowulf, but it still had many differences. The movie brought the poem to reality with its own twist on the story of Beowulf. From the appearance of Hrothgar and Grendel’s mom, to the journey of the dragon. There are many differences and similarities locked into one Legend.
The movie kept to the origin of how Beowulf came to help king Hrothgar. He came to defeat Grendel and pay his wergild. Grendel was also a monster who killed and incapacitated people in the hall. They both had Grendel lose an arm in the fight, but they had him lose it in different ways. They both had journey's to fight Grendel’s mom and the dragon, but both of the tales had different outcomes. Nevertheless Beowulf still became king in the two stories, it was just a matter of where he ruled, that made the
…show more content…
difference. The epic poem made Hrothgar seem like a caring, noble king. He did the best he could for his people. The movie on the other hand made him seem like a fat, drunken slob. The movie had him have an affair with Grendel’s mom, who then gave birth to Grendel. Grendel could not attack Hrothgar because he was his father, not because he was protected by God’s blessed throne, like in the poem. Hrothgar in the poem was loyal to his spouse, while in the movie he and most of the people weren’t. The poem portrayed Grendel’s mom as a monster, while the movie made her a beautiful shape shifter.
The journey to her layer in the movie was not as difficult and enduring as the poem made it out to be. There was no fight with Grendel’s mom, because she was able to get Beowulf to hook up with her. In the movie she wasn’t so much of a sea monster because she flew to the hall and killed many people, which never happened in the poem. In the movie Grendel’s mom is unscathed and not killed and lives on past Beowulf. Furthermore she gave Beowulf one thing he never had in the poem, a son.
The poem had no son of Beowulf in it, but the movie provided him one. Years after Beowulf hooked up with Grendel’s mom, his son appeared as a dragon shape shifter. Beowulf’s final battle came when he fought his son, tearing out his heart and eventually killing both of them. The poem had an unknown dragon being slayed, and Beowulf living on as an insuperable king.
The movie added a twist to give excitement to the viewers, to make Beowulf a man of flaws. The poem had him seem as a hero, a man who did no wrong. No matter what story is told, Beowulf will always remain a
legend.
Another difference in the poem and movie is the bloody battles. In the poem, Beowulf has supernatural powers when he is at battle. In the movie, Boulvine battles with human strengths and power. In the poem Beowulf fights all of his battles alone. In the movie Boulvine battles with several men. One of the famous warriors is the 13th warrior, played by Antonio Banderes. He helps Boulvine fight the Ven. In the poem Beowulf does not fight his third battle until 50 years later. In the movie Boulvine fights his third battle immediately after the second.
First of all, Beowulf came to help Hrothgar on his own free will. Hearing of the troubles that Hrothgar was having with a monster terrorizing Herot, his mead hall, Beowulf bravely offered his help not knowing what he was up against. When he arrived, Beowulf did not ask the king for either money nor fame. The only favor that he asked of Hrothgar was that he and his men were to fight the monster, Grendel. Coming away from one's homeland to help get rid of a man-eating monster and asking for nothing in return takes much courage and is an extremely brave deed.
The story begins with Grendel taking the lives of countless innocent men. It seems to all that there is no one who can face this great monster who lives down in the swamp. The king, Hrothgar, becomes concerned for the health of his country and seeks out help from someone of great strength. In hearing this, Beowulf sees it as an opportunity to increase his popularity and fame. Upon arrival, he is anxious to come face to face with the great beast. In addition, he declares that he will fight Grendel without any weapons to prove who is truly the strongest. After his victory, Beowulf gets his fame and becomes king of another land for fifty years.
Beowulf is a poem about strength and courage. This is illustrated in the eighth section of the story called “Beowulf and the Dragon.” A slave, a hero and a dragon play a big role in this section. The characters are well developed, as is the setup for the conclusion of the poem.
There are many similarities and differences between the movie "Beowulf and Grendel", to the poem. Major differences between the movie and the poem would be Grendel himself. In the poem, he is described as an evil monster born from two demons. In the movie, Grendel is actually human, but known as a troll to the warriors and Danes. The poem doesn’t give the background of Grendel or show how the Danes killed his father and the possible reason of his revenge, like in the movie. If the witch, Selma, was not included in the storyline of the movie, the audience would not have known key information that she was used to show from more flashbacks. The witch gives more of an idea about Grendel’s past life that could have been the possibility to reasons for his actions. Some major similarities are the battles. Both epics include the battles between Beowulf and Grendel, as well as Beowulf and Grendel’s mother. The end results are the same, leading to their death, but the journey and process to the two tales are different.
Early in the poem, Beowulf hears accounts of Grendel’s destruction of Herot, Hrothgar’s majestic mead hall. Knowing his strength and military prowess, Beowulf immediately devises a plan, recruits men, and orders boats, thrusting himself into a battle that was not necessarily his to fight. Beowulf felt obligated to end Grendel’s reign of terror. Though he knew the death of Grendel would bring him fame and honor, the idealized Beowulf was able to set aside personal ambition in order to end the suffering of the Danes. Shortly after slaying Grendel, Beowulf again displays an awareness of duty when Grendel’s mother extracts revenge upon Herot, killing one of Hrothgar’s best men, Aeshere. Instead of leaving Herot in a state of frenzy, Beowulf comes to King Hrothgar’s side, pledging allegiance and service. Bolstering the defeated king’s moral, Beowulf boldly addresses the older King Hrothgar saying, “So arise, my lord, and let us immediately set forth on the trail of this troll-dam. I guarantee you: she will not get away, not to dens under ground nor upland groves nor the ocean floor. She’ll have nowhere to fall to. Endure your troubles to-day. Bear up and be the man I expect you to be.” Beowulf could not set aside his duty and obligation, though he knew full well the suffering and pain that might result from his actions. Thus, Beowulf is a portrait of
Knowing that the sword is powerful enough to cut the skin of Grendel’s mother, Beowulf slays her and brings the sword and the head of the mother to Hrothgar, and he rewards Beowulf with more gifts and another feast. Once Beowulf returns home, he then tells his lord about his adventures and gives him all of the rewards that he received from Hrothgar for successfully defeating Grendel and his mother. His lord, then gave him rewards such as a new golden sword that belonged to Beowulf's father and grandfather, and some land and houses. In addition, Beowulf was to have the crown after the death of his lord and the lord’s son. Fifty years after Beowulf first became king, in Geatland a dragon was awakened by a slave who discovered the path to his tower by accident.
Beowulf’s characteristics seen on screen are very different compared to Beowulf’s characteristics in the Anglo-Saxon poem. Beowulf in the film Beowulf
...The film version makes a lot more sense than the poem as to why Grendel was a curse to the Danes. In the poem, we only know Grendel attacks the Danes, because he does not like the loud noises they make from rejoicing and celebrating. It is not mentioned why Grendel is there, only that he is decedent from Cain and evil. The film gives more of an explanational background story as to why the creatures are there in the first place. The dragon only attacked them in the first place, because someone had taken the golden horn that Beowulf gave her. Which broke the pact she and Beowulf had. I liked Beowulf in the film better, because he was portrayed more as a epic hero. In the film he kills the dragon all by himself, without any help, and he sacrifices his arm in order to reach the dragons heart to kill him. Rather than in the poem, he gets hurt and Wiglaf kills the dragon.
In the beginning of the novel, Beowulf takes interest in the plight of Hrothgar, King of Denmark, and wants to help him fight Grendel. Grendel is a large monster that has been harassing members in the mead-hall of the Heorot. Beowulf owes Hrothgar a favor, due to the fact that Hrothgar saved his father in years past. Hrothgar is honored to have Beowulf attempt to fight the swamp monster, and decides to hold a feast in his name. When Grendel shows up to the feast, Beowulf illustrates his bravery by fighting Grendel without any armor. When Beowulf wins the battle by ripping Grendel’s arm off, everyone in the mead-hall praises Beowulf for his acts of courage. In this scene, Beowulf proves that he is a hero by fighting off a monster that everyone else was afraid of. This made him look
Fighting monsters is one of the things that both the poem and the movie have in common. “Heard how Grendel filled the nights with horror and quickly commanded a boat fitted out…,” in the poem it states that Grendel was the only monster Beowulf was fighting against and incompatibly in the movie there were more creatures whom they wanted to defeat. Another similarity is that in both they kill the mothers, Beowulf kills Grendel’s mother in Beowulf and in The 13th Warrior Buliwf kills the Wendol Warlord. On the other hand in The 13th Warrior they were building/ setting a wall that could sort of protect them from the monsters and could use it as shields, Beowulf didn’t do that.
...le, the movie can offend some of the students, and it is possible that the movie could be ridiculing the actual poem. Because of these factors, it distorts the seniors’ perspectives of what Beowulf’s true story line is. Students are not likely to go and research what Beowulf is about due to how they view this movie, which, in turns, restrains their views on epic poetry now and maybe even in the future.
While this was an amazing story to the people of the past culture, it doesn't appeal to our culture of today. This change in the Beowulf character shows that our culture demands more from stories. Instead of flat characters that are simply good or evil, we want to be able to decide for ourselves the nobility, or lack thereof, in each character. The movie is a perfect example of the shift in tastes of the modern audience compared to that of the past
The movie Beowulf is an old ancient story based on the Anglo Saxons and Monks based on their time.The movie and the text have a lot of differences between the movie and the text, people have to completely pay attention to the movie to understand each and every moment and to get the whole point across. Beowulf is supposed to be the great hero in this movie/story.
Beowulf is the single greatest story of Old English literature and one of the greatest epics of all time. Ironically, no one can lay claim to being the author of this amazing example of literature. The creator of this poem was said to be alive around 600 A.D. and the story was, since then, been passed down orally from generation to generation. When the first English monks heard the story, they took it upon themselves to write it down and add a bit of their own thoughts. Thus, a great epic and the beginning to English literature was born.