Baldassare Castiglione Vs. John Shearman

987 Words2 Pages

The Mannerist aesthetic is widely ambiguous as to what qualities fall under this category. Baldassare Castiglione and John Shearman take different angles as to what constitutes as mannerist tendencies. Giulio Romanos Madonna and Child with a Young St. John the Baptist embodies the idea of the Maniera described by Shearman rather than Castigliones idea of sprezzatura through the style deviated from the high Renaissance represented by the figures in the painting.
Castiglione articulates the importance of nonchalance in a painting that heightens its value. He coins the term, sprezzatura, or the avoidance of “affectation at all costs” which “conceals all artistry and makes whatever one says or does seem uncontrived or effortless”. But anyone who …show more content…

John the Baptist, the main figures of Madonna, child and young St. John have strikingly unrealistic “perfection in the art of painting as a richness of invention, absolute familiarity with anatomy, and the reduction of difficulty to facility”. Every feature, especially in the faces of the child and St. John are abnormally pronounced for young children. The eyes of all three seem empty and sunken in, due to the heavy shading around the eyes. All their facial features are that of a human, but not quite: noses more elongated, lips fuller, chins rounded and eyebrows perfectly crescent moon shaped. The figures proportions in general have a muscular yet, rounded quality to them, symbolic to the human figure almost like a masking of artificiality. St John’s back and shoulder muscles are well defined, not with the sharp angles that toned muscles possess but shaded with soft edges blended seamlessly together in a way muscles under skin aren’t naturally occurrent. Romano clearly is aware of the natural state of figures and yet choses to invent a new faceting of human musculature to fit the art form. All the illusionism of high renaissance was to distort and to transform the body, extenuating the extreme elegance. The gestures each figure makes aren’t wholly gestural. There isn’t a specific intent of any movement, especially in the Madonnas actions, both hands are placed casually on the child and the lamb with her face placid and

Open Document