In 1945 on August 6 and 9 the United States army air force under the orders of President Truman dropped two atomic bombs one on the city of Hiroshima and the other on the city of Nagasaki killing roughly two hundred twenty-six thousand people. The dropping of the atomic bomb was a very controversial event in the United States from the events that lead up to the dropping, the complex decision to dropping the bomb on an actual city, and how the dropping of the bomb helped shaped the way nations fight wars, and how they determine the damage that could be done if they were to use a weapon of mass destruction on civilians.
Prior to the dropping of the Atomic Bomb, the United States was in WWII on the side of the allied powers which consisted of
…show more content…
Great Britain, Russia, and France and were at war with the Axis powers which consisted of Germany, Italy and Japan(Foner,867). World War II unofficially started in 1939 when Germany invaded Poland on September 1st and officially started on September 3rd when Great Britain and France declared war on Germany for attacking Poland(Foner,867). By mid-1940, almost One Year after the start of the war, Germany had conquered most of Europe including Belgium, Netherlands, and France leaving Great Britain fighting all by themselves(Foner,867). By September of 1940, the Axis powers had officially formed, After Forming the military alliance the Axis powers set their eyes on Britain. From 1940 to 1941 the Axis powers and Great Britain fought in the Battle Of Britain(Forner,867). Seeing that Axis powers, who favored dictatorship and Communism, were winning the war the United States slowly start to helping the allied powers by passing acts like the Lend-Lease Act to give military aid to countries such as Great Britain, Soviet Union, and China as long as they returned all of it after the war(Forner,868). In November of 1941, The United States intercepted Japanese messages that said they planned to attack the Pacific soon(Forner,868). The day the attack finally came was on December 7, 1941, at Pearl Harbor a naval base in Hawaii which became the first attack on the US since the War of 1812(Forner,868). Within hours 2,000 plus American servicemen were killed along with 187 aircraft,18 naval vessels including 8 battleships being destroyed(Forner,869). Shortly After The United States declared war on Japan with Congress vote almost unanimously 388 to 1(Forner,869). The day after The United States declared war Germany decided to declare war America(Forner,869). After the United States Joined the war the balance of the war didn't really change until may of 1942 when the American Navy turned back a Japanese Fleet in the Battle of the Coral Sea (Forner,869). Around the same time of the Battle Of the Coral Sea, The United States were Starting a Project on the military potential of an uncontrolled fission chain reaction(Encyclopedia Britannica). The idea from Albert Einstein who came from Germany to warn the United States about how Germany was using the uncontrolled fission chain reaction to make types of Nuclear weapons(Forner,899) The name of the project was Manhattan Project and with General Leslie R. Groves in charge of the operation(Encyclopedia Britannica). In 1941 Harold C. Urey one of the scientists working on the Manhattan project and G.B. Pegram went to Great Britain and Canada to get help on making the atomic bomb after finding out they were working on weapons using the same method of uncontrolled fission chain reaction(Encyclopedia Britannica). By the time the bomb was ready, the allies had assured victory in Europe with V-E Day on May 8th which ended the war with Germany(Forner,898). With the atomic bomb officially tested and declared ready in July of 1945 President Truman faced a difficult decision. While the war with Germany was over The United States were still at war with the Japanese. Truman had four options to use at his disposal to fight against the japanese he just had to choose the right one(National Park Service). His four options were to continue conventional bombing of Japanese cities, invade Japan, demonstrate the bomb on an unpopulated island; or, drop the bomb on an inhabited Japanese city(National Park Service). The easiest decision would be to continue the conventional bombing that the U.S was already doing to Japanese cities and destroying the homes of their citizens until they surrendered. Although it would cost more and be less effective in getting the Japanese to surrender. It wouldn't cost the United States the lives of their soldiers. Truman’s second option was to invade Japan while this would seem like the logical option. It would also be a costly one with it costing the United States millions of dollars. It would also be costly because a war with Japan would cost the United States the casualties of millions of soldiers because Truman knew that the Japanese would not surrender easily.(National Park Service). So while this might have seemed logical it would have caused way more damage than good for the United States. The third option at Truman's disposal was to drop the Atomic bomb on an unpopulated city or Island(National Park Service).
The thought process behind this idea was if they could get Japan to bring a scientist to the dropping of the bomb it would scare them so bad that they would surrender without having any more casualties on either side(National Park Service). This idea also had many downfalls as well like what if the bomb had a systematic failure or if it made the Japanese even angrier.
The fourth and final option that Truman faced was to drop the Atomic bomb on a heavily populated city(National Park Service). The United States thought the process in this idea was to drop the bomb on a city that was not only heavily populated but it also had to have a military influence there, not have been the target of the conventional bombing that was taking place, nor could they (National Park Service). Their reasoning behind this was so the Japanese would not be able to be full strength if a war was to break out and to hopefully make them surrender.
Truman ultimately decided to go with option four bombing the heavily populated cities Hiroshima and Nagasaki. In my opinion, I feel like this was the correct decision. Although his decision came under much scrutiny because it killed hundreds of thousands of innocent people the decision was correct the correct one because it was the quickest most effective way to end the
war. The dropping of the atomic bomb is still relevant today because it showed the power of nuclear weapons and influenced the way wars are fought. Because of the atomic bomb, the world now knows how devastating and destructive nuclear weapons can be and the lasting effects of them since the cities that were bombed with the atomic bomb haven’t recovered since. It’s also relevant because the wars after that have involved the uses or threatened to use nuclear weapons such as the Cold War the United States had with Russia and the ongoing battle the United States has with North Korea. The Enola Gay controversy was really blown out of proportion. I believe that the Smithsonian’s original exhibit design was perfectly fine because it would have explained an important part in American History and the decision to why America decided to drop the atomic bomb. Even though this would have been a good thing many people believed it was conversational because it was the plane that killed millions of Japanese people and also felt that it was celebrating the killing of these people(Lienenthal and Engelhardt, pg 2). I, on the other hand, disagree with this opinion because I feel like this exhibit would have helped us Americans understand get a better understanding the decision and why it is so important in American and World History. In conclusion, although the dropping of the atomic bomb on Japan was very controversial it was the right decision by Truman because it was the best option out of them all to ensure victory and make sure no Americans soldiers were lost. Also, the Enola Gay exhibit would’ve been a very effective way of showing the power of the atomic bomb and the effects nuclear weapons such as the atomic bomb can have on a those that deploy the nuclear weapon and those who are on the receiving end of the nuclear weapon.
The first reason on why Truman made the right decision was because the atomic bomb ultimately helped to prevent the deaths of American troops. There would have been over 100,000 losses during the first stage of the attack against Japan, leading to over one million casualties of just Americans during the defeat of Japan(Tucker 1). Although there is no way to confirm the amount of predicted deaths, any amount of American deaths would have been avoided with the use of the atomic bomb. Comparing a million predicted deaths of Americans to the 140,000 (±10,000) that were actually killed in the Hiroshima bomb(Faragher 4), the decision implementing the bomb was executed in the correct way.
Truman had thought through the possibilities and had decided that using the bomb would be the most effective and quickest tactic. As a president Truman had a responsibility to protect his country, citizens, and foreign affairs, so deciding on the best method to establish everybody’s needs was difficult. There were many things to worry about: fighting on Iwo Jima and Okinawa, bombing Japan, and building the bomb. His decision was mainly based on how the US citizens felt and the following actions of japan. Japan refused to accept an unconditional surrender, which was demanded by the allied powers in order to stop the war against them. On August 6, 1945 Truman allowed Enola Gay to drop the atomic bomb on top of Hiroshima and later Nagasaki to end the war.
It was believed that dropping an atomic bomb on Nagasaki would resolve a number of problems in a simpler fashion than prolonging the conventional warfare until Japan finally ceded defeat. The primary goal of this extreme force was to bring a swift end to the war in the Pacific,(Walker) but a secondary goal was to display the military and technological might of the United States to allies and rivals around the world (Walker,). The use of multiple nuclear weapons made it clear to Japan and the world that Truman's threat of “utter destruction” was intended to be carried out unless Japan delivered what the United States wanted―unconditional surrender (Cite).
Upon reading “Prompt and Utter Destruction: Truman and the Use of Atomic Bombs Against Japan” by J. Samuel Walker, a reader will have a clear understanding of both sides of the controversy surrounding Truman’s decision to drop atomic bombs on the cities of Hiroshima and Nagasaki during World War II. The controversy remains of whether or not atomic bombs should have been used during the war. After studying this text, it is clear that the first atomic bomb, which was dropped on the city of Hiroshima, was a necessary military tactic on ending the war. The second bomb, which was dropped on Nagasaki, however, was an unnecessary measure in ensuring a surrender from the Japanese, and was only used to seek revenge.
The United States entered WW II immediately following the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor on December 7, 1941. The U.S. entry was a major turning point in the war because it brought the strongest industrial strength to the Allied side. The Americans helped the Allies to win the war in Europe with the surrender of Germany on May 7, 1945. However, the war in the Pacific continued. The war with Japan at this point consisted primarily of strategic bombings. America had recently completed an atomic bomb and was considering using this weapon of mass destruction for the first time. The goal was to force the “unconditional surrender” of the Japanese. Roosevelt had used the term “unconditional surrender” in a press conference in 1943 and it had since become a central war aim. Truman and his staff (still feeling bound by FDR’s words) demanded unconditional surrender from the Japanese. Consequently on July 26, 1945 Truman issued an ultimatum to Japan. This ultimatum stated that Japan must accept “unconditional surrender” or suffer “utter devastation of the Japanese Homeland”. This surrender included abdication of the throne by their emperor. Japan was not willing to surrender their dynasty and ignored the ultimatum. On August 6th and August 9th, atomic bombs were dropped on the cities of Hiroshima and Nagasaki respectively.
The United States of America’s use of the atomic bomb on the Japanese cities of Hiroshima and Nagasaki has spurred much debate concerning the necessity, effectiveness, and morality of the decision since August 1945. After assessing a range of arguments about the importance of the atomic bomb in the termination of the Second World War, it can be concluded that the use of the atomic bomb served as the predominant factor in the end of the Second World War, as its use lowered the morale, industrial resources, and military strength of Japan. The Allied decision to use the atomic bomb not only caused irreparable physical damage on two major Japanese cities, but its use also minimized the Japanese will to continue fighting. These two factors along
If they do not now accept our terms they may expect a rain of ruin from the air, the like of which has never been seen on this earth.” (Truman).The justification of the bombs was the fact that the bomb was only in retaliation to a hostile nation and there refusal to cooperate with the American government. Japan was attacking with no fear they were unwavering because there military mind set was to never surrender because it was a sign of weakness it was against their nature. And so was the United States we were not going to give up though we were not gaining anything from this war only loosing we had the same sort of national mindset that we could to surrender for the fear of being preserved as week. So with the rejection of surrender the United States dropped the bomb in order to stop a more brutal war and to protect the United States from having to drop out of the
Under President Franklin D. Roosevelt’s administration the atomic bomb was being developed. After Roosevelt died, his vice president Harry Truman was appointed President of the United States. Truman was never informed about the bombs development until an emergency cabinet meeting (Kuznick 9). Truman had to make the fatal decision on whether the bomb was to be dropped on Japan. With the idea of going to war, Truman had to think about the lives of the thousand American soldiers. The American soldiers had begun using the method of island hopping, because the bomb was not available. The idea of dropping a bomb was that the war itself could possibly end in its earliest points. The dropping of the atomic bomb could also justify the money spent on the Manhattan Project (Donohue 1). With a quote by Franklin D. Roosevelt “This will be a day that will live in infamy”, Pearl Harbor was a tragic day for Americans. The United States had lost many soldiers, which they had claimed that they will eventually get revenge. The alternates of dropping the bomb was also discussed at the Interim Committee. The American government was trying to get an invitation response from the Japanese government. If the United States did not drop the bomb and ‘Operation Downfall’ ha...
President Truman's decision to drop the atomic bomb on the cities of Hiroshima and Nagasaki were the direct cause for the end of World War II in the Pacific. The United States felt it was necessary to drop the atomic bombs on these two cities or it would suffer more casualties. Not only could the lives of many soldiers have been taken, but possibly the lives of many innocent Americans. The United States will always try to avoid the loss of American civilians at all costs, even if that means taking lives of another countries innocent civilians.
On August 6, 1945, the U.S. dropped the world’s first atomic bomb over Hiroshima. Three days later, a second bomb was dropped on Nagasaki. On August 15th, the Japan announced unconditional surrender in World War II. To this day historians still discuss why the U.S. decided to use the atomic bombs. Orthodox historians argue that the decision to drop the bombs was a military one designed purely to defeat the Japanese. Revisionist historians argue that the bombs were not needed to defeat Japan; the bombs were meant to shape the peace by intimidating the Soviets. After analyzing the documents in The Manhattan Project it has become clear that the U.S. used the bombs during WWII not only to defeat the Japanese, but also to intimidate the Soviet Union
There were many factors as to the argument relating to the atomic bombs leading to the United States final decision. Many people had arguments for the bombing and others had arguments against the bombings, but it is still not determined if the United States made the right decision. After Truman decided to bomb Japan, they had to plan it out. They first had to decide where to release the bomb. They ended up choosing Hiroshima, Japan and Nagasaki, Japan as their two locations.
The dropping of atomic bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki, Japan were ethical decisions made by President Harry Truman and the United States government. By the time of the atom bomb was ready, the U.S. had been engaged in military conflict for over four years and lost over 400,000 soldiers. Truman claimed, "We would have the opportunity to bring the world into a pattern in which the peace of the world and our civilization can be saved" (Winkler 18). The bomb was aimed at ending the war immediately and avoiding prolonged battle in the Pacific Theater and the inevitable invasion of Japan. President Truman hoped that by showing the Japanese the devastating weapon the U.S. possessed, that the war could be brought ...
In 1945, Germany had surrendered, but the war in the Pacific raged on. The allies were becoming desperate to end the war before it was necessary to carry out a full scale invasion. New developments in science had made it possible for the United States to weaponize the atom, and the consequent bomb created was dropped on Hiroshima and later Nagasaki at the approval of President Harry S. Truman and his advisors. In years to come, Truman would have to face questions over the merit of his actions. Although some may believe the atomic bomb was needed because it ended WWII, it was unnecessary to drop the nuclear bomb because of the alternatives that existed, the effect it had on the Japanese people, and because of the unethical reasons for dropping it.
The decision to drop the atomic bomb was contemplated by officials in the American government for a prolonged period of time. Ultimately the conclusion was that dropping the bombs would be beneficial to America. The American government rationalized dropping the bombs by stating that it would terminate the war with Japan and save a plethora of American lives. America did issue an ultimatum declaring that Japan should cease to resist and in return conditions would be provided for Japan to finish the war with honor. This ultimatum was ignored and the alternative was absolute destruction of Hiroshima and Nagasaki. (Dollinger) Most officials believed that taking this last step would force Japan’s surrender and shorten the war which would result in a decrease of American casualties. (Barnes) Winston Churchill approximated that one million American lives were preserved by utilizing the atomic bomb.
If one aim was met with the Hiroshima bombing, it was the physical effects, which were able to devastate an entire city. Dropping the atomic bomb was a decision that no man would want to take on. Truman went with all the facts and his gut feeling. There was great loss for Japan, but even some of the Japanese soldiers were happy that the United States dropped the bomb.