Arguments Against Immigration

740 Words2 Pages

One of the most pressing problems currently facing post-industrial societies is the slowing rate of reproduction in the native populations. One of the most notable examples is the country of Japan with a population decrease of 0.7% since the last census. This might not sound like a large amount but population growth and decline is an exponential function with this rate rapidly accelerating. This is a problem the US would be facing as well with the decline in birth rates after the Baby Boom in the 1950s and 1960s. One of the biggest factors that is preventing this from occurring is the immigration of people from all over the world to the United States.

While immigration gets a bad reputation in certain political circles, the truth …show more content…

One of the most common arguments against immigration is that immigrants take American jobs. This is only true in the negligible proportion of jobs where the skill sets of natives and immigrants overlaps. It has in fact been shown that immigration increases the wages overall due to the increased aggregate output that a larger workforce brings. However current laws prohibit this positive development that comes with a larger workforce. H-1B temporary visas for new skilled immigrant workers are limited at 85,000 annually and do not meet demand. Acquiring permanent residency or green card is a lengthy and potentially costly process that most people cannot even start simply because they aren’t allowed to work in the US for a long enough time in order to for the application to go through and be approved; a process that could take years. An immigration policy focused on increasing economic growth would be able to admit more immigrants with the education and skill sets desired by domestic employers would be mutually beneficial and lead to a better economy …show more content…

The fourth peak period began in the 1970s and continues today. These peak immigration periods have coincided with fundamental transformations of the American economy. The first saw the dawn of European settlement in the Americas and the colonization of this continent with the initial settlement of immigrants. The second allowed the young United States to transition from a colonial to an agricultural economy by providing a larger workforce necessary for farmwork. The industrial revolution gave rise to a manufacturing economy during the third peak period, propelling America's rise to become the leading power in the world with immigrants once again providing the necessary labor to run the factories and propel America into the industrial and postindustrial stages of development. Today's large-scale immigration has coincided with globalization and the last stages of transformation from a manufacturing to a 21st century knowledge-based economy. As before, immigration has been prompted by economic transformation, just as it is helping the United States adapt to new economic

Open Document