Argumentative Essay-Does Assigning Homework Pay Off?

672 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Advantage of homework

“Educators and policy makers must ask themselves — does assigning homework pay off?” (Monica Fuglei- The Homework Debate: The Case Against Homework) Homework is something that children have dreaded at the end of their school day for a long time. This topic has been debated over and researched for many years. The case against homework is clear. Homework should be eliminated from education. Homework is ineffective, unfair to many students, and has too great of an opportunity cost. Henry David Thoreau wrote, “It is not enough to be busy; so there are ants. The question is: What are we busy about?”
Homework is ineffective. Homework is redundant, repetitive, and it does not educate students. “According to UVAToday, there is no substantive difference in the grades of students related to homework completion.” (Monica Fuglei- The Homework Debate: The Case Against Homework) Alfie Kohn’s book The Homework Myth:Why Our …show more content…

It eats away time that students could be spending time with family, friends, events, and adventures. When they are out and about they learn things about themselves and the things around them. Homework isn’t just unpleasant, it takes away time that student can experience other things. For example; many teachers assign homework over the weekend and it takes away time that students could use for organized sports, or to hang out with friends and their community. Children could participate in something much greater in their community, like volunteer or participate in a political rally. Children could also use the time to find their passion. “The article goes on to note that those who oppose homework focus on the drawbacks of significant time spent on homework, identifying one major negative as homework’s intrusion into family time.” (Monica Fuglei- The Homework Debate: The Case Against Homework) Students only have 18 years in their parents house and they should spend it with their families, friends, and

Show More
Related

  • Why Kids Should Not Have Homework

    616 Words  | 2 Pages

    Healthline.com has said that “Students in high achieving neighborhoods who spend too much time on homework have more health problems, stress, and alienation from society.” Being sick of school is one thing, but when school is making you sick because of the homework you have now is bad. Elementary kids having physical problems just from homework can eventually lead to other possible problems down the road. These problems include substance abuse, becoming a high school dropout, and possibly death by suicide. So why risk a student’s life for a few homework

    Read More

  • Homework, the greatest tool for success!

    866 Words  | 2 Pages

    Homework attributes to student success. According to Harris Cooper, a comparison of homework with no homework shows that the average student in a class with homework assigned would score 23 percentile scores higher on tests of the knowledge assessed than students in classes with no homework assigned (4). Cooper’s meta analysis concluded in the early elementary grades, there wasn’t a clear-cut agreement on the benefits of homework. However, in grades 7-9, the percentile gain doubled to twelve from a percentile gain of 6 in grades 4-6. Homework had the greatest effect on high school students grades tenth through twelfth with a percentile gain of 24. The study suggest that as homework’s difficulty and amount increased,, students percentile gains increased(5). The longer it takes to complete homework, the more the benefits increase. Another positive effect of homework is that it leads to better retention of knowledge learned in the school day. This means that if a student is assigned quality homework, it will help the student remember what he or she learned during school. ”Students in the U.S spend less time studying content than other students in different countries (Marzano and Pi...

    Read More

  • Why Kids Should Not Have Homework

    764 Words  | 2 Pages

    There should not be homework for students. For starters, homework pushes families further apart from each other. Secondly, homework causes kids to actually do worse on schoolwork and tests. Lastly, homework causes kids to get stressed out and depressed because they have to go home and do homework instead of have there own free time. Those are a few reasons why students should not have homework.

    Read More

  • Personal Opinion Essay: Homework Should be Banned

    1104 Words  | 3 Pages

    In conclusion, homework is a waste of time. Time that can be better spent is with family and having fun participating in extracurricular activities. Eliminating homework allows students the reward of free time and the invaluable time spent with family. Homework creates unnecessary stress and strain for parents and students alike. Also, homework allows teachers to pawn off their own teaching responsibilities to students and parents with hours of homework. Homework is not beneficial and it should be banned for students Kindergarten thru 8th grade.

    Read More

  • Why There Should Be No Homework

    830 Words  | 2 Pages

    Have you ever wanted to just shred up your homework or throw it out the window and have no consequences? Kids are assigned daily homework from the time they start kindergarten at the ripe young age of five. Is it really necessary to do this? Does it even help with better learning or even higher test scores? The amount of homework we do wastes time, money, paper, and trees because it’s practically the exact same thing we did in class that day.

    Read More

  • Limiting Homework

    549 Words  | 2 Pages

    I sacrifice sleep, family time, and personal time for an hour of math, an unimportant essay, and random assignments.”(Waters). In addition the author said “teachers seem to give the most work when it is least needed, such as during Homecoming Week or prom weekend, or before advanced-placement tests or a huge athletic game.”(Waters). These quotes are important because it shows that there should be a limit on homework. There should be a limit on homework because children need time for activities instead of doing homework right after school then having to go to bed after they're done with there homework. For my last reason Homework is not always helpful. The article says “Maybe kids should learn whatever they're interested in and write an essay on it” (“Too much homework?”). The author states “many homework assignments are repetitive, unnecessarily boring or of limited educational value” (Greenspan). These quotes are important because it shows that there should be a limit on homework. There should be a limit on homework because if the homework doesnt help then why should they give the homework out sense it would be a waste of time for the child. Therefore In conclusion, Teachers should have a limit on how much homework they are

    Read More

  • Persuasive Essay: Should Students Give Students Homework?

    730 Words  | 2 Pages

    When considering the choice of whether teachers should assign homework or not, the choice should definitely be that students should not get homework. One reason that students shouldn’t get homework is that students will live a part of their life full of stress and exasperation. A lack of sleep is another negative effect of assigning students homework. It can also be the only commodity that can affect how much children learn outside of school. If the reader of this incredibly important claim ignores this, every student in this nation will have to live in stress and hassle. They will come home every day and sit down at their unorganized desk full of papers. They will spend the next 5 hours trying to finish homework without getting distracted by anything around them that is fun, unlike homework. Homework is a burden for plenty of students and families.The future of the children in this nation is at stake. Countless students and parents are against homework, make the correct, honorable choice for the betterment of our

    Read More

  • Why Kids Should Not Have Away Time?

    736 Words  | 2 Pages

    Students should not have homework because it takes away time from their activity or it just gives them more to do then to just relax. First, Vicki Abeles, the writer for Motto, states

    Read More

  • Homework: Is It Beneficial or Harmful to Students?

    980 Words  | 2 Pages

    Although homework may seem like drudgery, the hard work that is put into homework may pay off in the long run. In the article, “Does homework really work for students?” Jacqueline Carey, the mother of seventh grade student Micah Carey, stated that “homework gives [students] a good foundation for when they move on further in school” (Johnson). Not only that but according to Donyall Dickey, principle at Murray Hill Middle School, “if students do not acquire things in class, they will acquire them through homework” (Johnson). As we can see homework helps and prepares us for higher grade levels while in primary school that can possibly prepare us for college. It also helps us to remember the materials that were taught in class. Another reason homework can be beneficial is the fact that it can prepare us for tests and the dreadful pop-quiz that a teacher may randomly give us. This fact was proven, according to a 2006 study by Harris Cooper, director of Duke University’s Program in education, in the article “Homework or Not? That is the (Research) Question”. The studies instituted that “students who had homework performed better on class tests compared to those who did not” (DeNisco). Another compelling thing about homework, are the qualities a skills th...

    Read More

  • Today's Homework Stress

    639 Words  | 2 Pages

    Dr. Michael Nagel, an associate professor at the University of the Sunshine Coast, says homework has no scientific benefit and that it could even be bad for a student’s brain. “The adult brain does not fully mature until the third decade of life (a person’s thirty’s) and too much stimulation could cause unnecessary stress on a student.” An analysis conducted by Pearson showed that the number of hours spent on homework was between ten and sixty-five hours a week, with females scoring higher on the hours of homework, stres...

    Read More

  • The Benefits of Homework

    1156 Words  | 3 Pages

    Homework offers multiple benefits for real life. One benefit of homework is that it helps the student develop essential skills. While homework may seem like a tedious task, it can help a student comprehend the material. Homework is necessary for more than just a grade; it is an assignment that teaches you valuable life skills. According to “Do students have too much homework?”, homework should lead students to be better at taking what they know and applying it to a certain task. Students tend to portray homework as something that they have to get done without knowing the value that lies behind it. Homework enables the student to recall a certain problem and apply it to another distinctive situation. According to “Do students have too much homework?”, applying knowledge is the most important. Learning is definitely important but what students do with the facts that they learned is essential as well. Applying knowledge allows the students to take a simple fact and relate it to a grander scheme of things. Relating what they know will enhance their creativity and let them see behind the lines of how everything connects.

    Read More

  • Too Much Homework

    1227 Words  | 3 Pages

    We all know the downfall of homework: the frustration and exhaustion, family conflict, time loss, and decreasing interest in learning. No study has ever demonstrated any academic achievement linked to assigning homework. There is also no support to the fact that homework provides nonacademic benefits at any age. Here are a few examples: building character, promoting self-discipline, or teaching good work habits. All teachers who assign homework want to believe that the gain outweighs the pain. Although, there is no evidence of that and they must rely on faith (“Homework: No Proven Benefits”, pg. 1). Michellea, a mother of a middle school student, says that some work can reinforce certain skills, but hours of homework are unhealthy and unproductive. Mominseattle agrees. She contemplates that such a heavy load can result in potential drawbacks to the students. Hours of homework a night plus a full day of school can be just as much work as an adult at a full-time job. She believes students should enjoy their childhood, as short as it already is. MagnetMom complains about how her daughter’s homework takes away her beneficial sleep. With busy families, like hers, they have many after school activities, so when they get home, they do not have time for too much homework. She says ...

    Read More

  • Should Schools Ban Homework?

    2036 Words  | 5 Pages

    People all around the world and in the United States are beginning ban homework and create No-homework policies after seeing how difficult homework is starting to be for students. Students are working on homework more often instead of being in clubs and sports, because they are scared of not being able to complete their assignments if they join extra curricular activities. This might be true but it doesn’t address the whole issue. Some people feel that homework should be given because it improves learning; however, there are educational ways other than homework in order for students to succeed. Homework should be banned because it gets in the way of

    Read More

  • Why We Should Not Have Homework Essay

    565 Words  | 2 Pages

    Do you have the daily fight about doing homework? Well I think we should not have homework. Even though some may disagree that it is good. I know homework is bad because, homework has no academic benefit,has bad medical effects ,and parents feel that can’t help. One reason why we should not have homework is homework has no academic benefit.

    Read More

  • Persuasive Essay Homework

    459 Words  | 1 Pages

    Students get overwhelmed after having seven hours of school, then going home to two more hours of homework. Teachers might contend homework helps practice skills we learned in class. But if we learned it in class and did worksheets in class, then we shouldn’t have to do any at home. When we go home to do our homework we can’t concentrate

    Read More

More about Argumentative Essay-Does Assigning Homework Pay Off?

Open Document